More along the lines of: "Pretty please take away people's freedom and here's a huge bucket of cash set up as an anonymous corporate shell donor. If you don't support us we'll give this huge bucket of cash to your opponent. kthxbye."
But I agree that a lack of term limits or accountability means that its the career politicians who are ultimately responsible.
Step 1: Use bucket of cash to gain access to and develop a rapport with a politician, increase the rapport and dependency with campaign contributions
Step 2: Convince said politician of your perspective, namely that the works of art your company has struggled to create are threatened by people who want to "steal" them without paying.
Step 3: Convince said politician that it's necessary to go to special measures to protect content from being "stolen" because it's such a big and growing "problem".
In many cases these steps can be quite natural and good seeming. The biggest problems are that the MPAA/RIAA have a lot more access to politicians than and a much more well honed "pitch" than any organization seeking to defend individuals.
It amazes me when people see a bad result and insist that there must be a bad person behind it all somewhere. Do people not realize that more evil will come from a bad system full of good people than will ever come from a few bad people in a good system? Germany wasn't bad in WWII because of Hitler -- there are a million little Hitlers running around the world at any given moment. Germany went bad because the Weimar republic was in such a state of disarray [insert long discussion here] that armed political gangs thrived.
People see the problems with the patent laws and content industry and they insist on "attack!" when the only thing that will do is make the system less stable and open to more of the same exact kinds of things they're upset with in the first place.
Why do we insist that every story have a villain?
I would say, though, that identifying a villain is immensely helpful in mobilizing opposition, even if the villain is more caricature than reality. Hitler is a great example; no one cared that the reality of the Nazi state was a diffuse and dreary bureaucracy of Eichmanns and Speers. It was Hitler's face that went on war posters.
Ok, more precisely: "pretty please take away people's freedom or else we might tell everybody that you're a poopy head."
Advertising works. I've canvassed the last 4 or so national election years and every single time I hear a lot of people echo the latest attack ad as truth, or say "I just don't know who to believe".
No, your response doesn't address your goal at all. CFR doesn't do a darned thing to "reduce the effects of corruption". It seeks to decrease the possible vectors of corruption (both in quantity and magnitude), but it does absolutely nothing to address the effects of corruption.
What yummyfajitas and others have been arguing is precisely for a solution to the problem you cite, the effects of corruption. That is to make it so that it matters much less how a bureaucrat gets corrupted, by stripping him of power to the greatest extent possible, so that the potential for damage he can cause is minimized.
I don't think that this systemic view aligns with the campaign-finance-reform argument argument at all; the people who want money out of politics regard money itself as the root cause of the problem, but neglects to address the real underlying incentives that money - merely an abstraction of value - actually represents. If you take money out of the picture, those incentives will still exist, and still convey political advantage. Who dominates politics then, if not the wealthiest? The most well-connected? The most ruthless?
The real, underlying systemic problem is the centralized concentration of de jure power in a small set of political institutions. This will always be susceptible to concentrated influence, whether via money or otherwise.
Our modern trend toward increasing political centralization and removal of constraints on power is what's making corruption so lucrative and effective: if you build it, they will come.
Many of those who are most vigorously agitating for campaign finance reform want a strong and centralized federal government that isn't influenced by interests that compete with their own. But you can't have your cake and eat it too: if that's what you order, it's coming with a side of corruption (and a mixed metaphor fresh out of the blender).
Noone's claiming they have a perfect system, I'd be satisfied if we stopped sliding backwards.
What was wrong with the Citizen's United decision? What's wrong with high advertising spending?
Are you implying that voters are really so easily influenced by the mere volume as advertising that advertising alone is the overriding determinant of electoral success? If that's your point, isn't it actually an indictment of democracy itself?
If we want a better working system, we need a better democratic process. Sadly the US was a pioneer in that and is still stuck with a system, that was brilliant for its time, but needs updating. We need a system that allows more than two parties to participate and we need better campaign funding regulation.
That's the only way we can permanently stop BS like this
Personally, I've like many aspects of the Starship Troopers model: if you don't care enough to serve your country (military or humanitarian), you may still live there, but you are disenfranchised. I suspect there is the real potential for tyranny of the voters, but, in theory, the service is supposed to limit that.
It's not the fault of corporations. It's not the fault of politicians. It's the fault of corporations and politicians working together. When that happens, it is usually not in the public interest.
http://news.cnet.com/2010-1071-946732.html?tag=mncol;txt
http://www.politechbot.com/docs/congress.p2p.letter.081002.p...
http://news.cnet.com/Senators-aim-to-restrict-Net,-satellite...
http://news.cnet.com/8301-10784_3-9920665-7.html?tag=mncol;t...
Please note that I was attempting to avoid partisanship by naming Orrin Hatch (R, Utah) as well.
The content industries don't cause this. They go to politicians and say "pretty please take away people's freedom to protect our profits". That's the only thing they have the power to do.
Politicians are not helpless babies who have no choice but to give big content what it wants. They are intelligent adults who choose to side with big content.
The people you need to bring down are Biden/Obama, Orrin Hatch, etc.