Ah, fair enough, my memory is imperfect and I'm not inclined to paw through old HN comments.
Edit: ack, and I misspelled his name and the edit window closed
Re:V Language Review
by amedvednikov on Monday June 20, 2022 @08:02PM
(#31817940)
No, he also had criticisms like "the V compiler depends on an OpenGL context creation library, so the claim that it has zero dependencies is false, the author is a scammer".
AFAIK your stated reason for the silence is not accurate. Andy’s criticisms were always based on V making claims that no one could evaluate because it was closed source/unreleased (and then used those claims to solicit money from people). Once V was made open source, those criticisms no longer applied, as things like TFA could be written.