News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by busterarm on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:06PM (#31782010)
> Corporations bargain collectively by default;

Only with unskilled labor.

My profession is skilled and the skillset is in demand and hard to find. I bargain for myself, thanks.

I have repeatedly and at length discussed on HN about my 3 separate union membership experiences and how I will never again repeat them.

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by pessimizer on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:20PM (#31782227)
The no-poach cartel that ruled big tech for like a decade would like to have a word.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by busterarm on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:28PM (#31782352)
If your skillset is sufficiently rare and in-demand than Google/Facebook/Apple aren't your only options for high-paying employment.

Heck, I haven't even worked for any of those yet and last I checked at least 2 of them were offering less than what I make for my role.

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by adam_arthur on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:29PM (#31782360)
That's an oligopoly/cartel, which represents monopoly power on labor demand, and is illegal
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by AlexandrB on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:41PM (#31782519)
Did anyone go to jail over it? No. I doubt anyone was even fired. It was settled for $415 million split 4 ways between the companies involved[1]. So it's "illegal", but in terms of repercussions experienced by the offenders I'd say it's up there with a $150 speeding ticket.

https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/apple-google-others-...

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by adam_arthur on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:49PM (#31782622)
That's a problem with elected officials/regulatory agencies.

I'm a strong believer that government's number one priority should be to maintain a competitive market, as in the long run that produces the best outcomes for broader society.

Unfortunately they've failed quite badly at it. Especially in regards to big tech.

Important to direct ire towards those that are responsible, representatives need to be held accountable

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by jasonlotito on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:25PM (#31782303)
People like to forget about this. With the way salaries work in this industry, we are all underpaid.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by noSyncCloud on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:29PM (#31782367)
> I bargain for myself, thanks.

Well, that's good to know. I guess the rest of the world can stop worrying about themselves since you're taken care of.

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by CamperBob2 on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:36PM (#31782458)
He's saying he doesn't want the choice denied to him, as unionization advocates frequently attempt to justify.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by toomuchtodo on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:46PM (#31782585)
Democracy needs no apologies. You are denied choices everyday because society and government have agreed upon those choices. There will always be those upset because they feel their rights are infringed upon.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by sershe on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:16PM (#31783698)
By that logic, slavery in the US was a-ok if/because it was supported by the majority. That is why rights not subject to majority exist and should exist.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by busterarm on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:52PM (#31782660)
And the right to determine the terms with with you negotiate away your labor is among the most sacred.

Letting others do that for you is much closer to indentured servitude or slavery.

The problem with all of these collectivsts' arguments is that they all believe themselves to be in their utopia's social planning committee rather than themselves a laborer. And that's if they made it past the "shoot all the troublemakers" phase of their revolution.

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by toomuchtodo on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:54PM (#31782687)
What you advocate for, not organizing, is what got us to the indentured servitude and slavery current state (US centric of course). Those who can’t recognize that are beyond hope (as they ignore the economic data clearly demonstrating the benefits), and to cater to them or entertain their desire to maintain the status quo helps no one but themselves.

Edit: This forum has some sort of empathy deficiency in aggregate.

[dead]
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by SamoyedFurFluff on Friday June 17, 2022 @05:43PM (#31784762)
You can work in tech and your work could be accurately described as indentured servitude. Tech if anything has a disproportionate amount of one specific kind: immigrants on employer specific visas.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by busterarm on Friday June 17, 2022 @07:56PM (#31786000)
Points for being kind-of true.

First off, let's establish that the oft-abused H1-Bs have salary minimums that put them in the top 5% of earners in the United States and in most cases the top 99.9(999)% of earners in their home countries.

Second, the visas don't prevent you from seeking employment through other employers, but at certain phases of your status here between visa, green card and resident it will reset your timetable.

Third, while the timetable for people from say India is absurdly long, from many other nations it is much much shorter.

Fourth, at all times visa holders have the loophole of getting married to get a better visa. Most people living somewhere for an extended period of time at least have the social skill to negotiate setting up a family (citation: the continued survival of the human race). Even if you marry another immigrant, both visa-holders have the convenience of opting to use the shortest schedule table between both nations. You'll often see, for example, Indian visa holders marrying Australian visa holders...The current schedule for new Indian applications is like 35+ years while the Australian schedule is ~5.

So yes, there are people in somewhat abusive situations. They stay in them because it's still an opportunity that puts them ahead of at least 95% of the world's population. Is that like indentured servitude or slavery? No, not really.

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by SamoyedFurFluff on Friday June 17, 2022 @08:20PM (#31786157)
Um, with polite response: a lot of these points are ethically dubious and at best say “they’re well paid, so they don’t really count”. At one point it says one can marry to get out of their indentured servitude, which… yikes, dude, imagine what a dangerous position that puts someone in if they can’t divorce a potentially dangerous relationship for fear of deportation.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by busterarm on Friday June 17, 2022 @08:51PM (#31786332)
Don't be ridiculous. The overwhelming majority of people are going to get married. More than 40% of them to someone they meet at work. That's just life.

Stop interpreting things the most hyperbolic way possible. Basic statistical facts paint quite a different picture than you are.

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by SamoyedFurFluff on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:17PM (#31786769)
I’m not saying that marriage itself is bad, I’m saying that being in a marriage where you cannot freely leave isn’t an alternative to a job you cannot freely leave, which is an exploitation of labor that’s over represented in tech, in response to a poster who questions why tech should be trying to defend their labor. In none of your points have you reasonably addressed the original concern, which is that exploitation of labor does exist in tech, except to argue that it’s okay because of money, or they can enter a marriage that they cannot freely leave without also risking their immigration status and that’s somehow not a concern.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by andrepd on Friday June 17, 2022 @03:16PM (#31782980)
Again, kindly notice that there are other people in the planet besides yourself.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by joshuamorton on Friday June 17, 2022 @09:32PM (#31786549)
You're free to work at a non-unionized company, of course, or even found your own.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by andrepd on Friday June 17, 2022 @03:08PM (#31782873)
I did not know "collective bargaining in a capitalist wage-labour system" was actually synonymous with "proletariat uprising", but here we are.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by busterarm on Friday June 17, 2022 @03:26PM (#31783081)
Forgive me, but in NYC where I'm from nearly 100% of the people talking about unions are Wobblies (IWW people) and nearly 100% of them are tankies but even if they aren't their union advocates for a revolution anyway.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by xibo9 on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:12PM (#31782102)
"unskilled labor"

What an extremely elitist phrase.

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by moooo99 on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:16PM (#31782169)
> What an extremely elitist phrase.

This! I hate when people talk about "unskilled labor" because there is no such thing. There definitely is work that requires less training than other jobs, but there is no such thing as unskilled labor.

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by busterarm on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:49PM (#31782635)
You're certainly glad that your uber driver can't be suddenly promoted to airline pilot though, right?
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by moooo99 on Sunday June 19, 2022 @05:31AM (#31797738)
So you would define an airline pilot as skilled labor but driving an Uber (I have never used Uber, so I will compare it to a taxi) as unskilled labor.

Flying a plain certainly takes a skill. So does driving a car. Both are skills. They certainly differ in the time required to obtain that skill, but that does not change the fact than an unskilled person can't drive a car through dense urban traffic bringing you safely to your destination, neither can they land a an airplane.

If a job was really unskilled, anybody could do it without any training at all. People usually don't pay for actually unskilled things because they can do it themselves just as good

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by goodpoint on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:11PM (#31783638)
So what?

Besides, driving a car safely is very much a skill. It's life-saving by definition.

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by bigbillheck on Saturday June 18, 2022 @07:45AM (#31789012)
Uber drivers have to pass an examination by the state which usually requires many hours of lessons and supervised training. How is that unskilled?
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by busterarm on Saturday June 18, 2022 @02:28PM (#31792455)
85% of Americans have a driver's license too.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by bigbillheck on Sunday June 19, 2022 @06:03AM (#31797923)
A skill being common doesn't make it no longer a skill.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by busterarm on Sunday June 19, 2022 @10:57AM (#31799985)
But common skills don't command elevated wages.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by bigbillheck on Sunday June 19, 2022 @11:52AM (#31800474)
We're not talking about wages, we're talking about who counts as 'skilled labor'.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by busterarm on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:26PM (#31782321)
It's not elitist. Some skills are effectively commoditized. They don't require specialized, rare knowledge, years of training and constant personal investment.

If you pick a job that literally anyone else can learn to do in a few days, then the cap on your salary and lack of bargaining power is on you.

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by foobarian on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:54PM (#31782690)
I mean, it is elitist. Is that inaccurate? What I don't get is why that is supposed to be bad. It's just a fact.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by function_seven on Friday June 17, 2022 @03:07PM (#31782863)
"Elitist" is almost always used as a pejorative. Just looking up the definition of it points to social power, wealth, class hierarchies, etc. It is rarely used to just mean "smart, capable, skilled" in a neutral sense.

The comment above was clearly using it as a pejorative.

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by totony on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:18PM (#31782193)
Do you have a better term for it?
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by busterarm on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:37PM (#31782470)
Back in my younger years, I worked a lot of unskilled-labor type jobs.

The starkest difference that I recognize between people in those jobs and people in my career is that in the former people have a hard time showing up to work on-time or at all and in the latter everyone is pretty tuned in and works hard.

It only hit me late in life that success in life really can be just as simple as showing up.

I guess what I would say here is that the kind of people who feel that they need collective bargaining agreements probably overlaps quite strongly with the group of people that have a hard time showing up.

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by andrepd on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:08PM (#31783588)
Yes grampa, the disadvantaged kid who never got a chance to learn a "skilled job" should just pull himself by the bootstraps, show up, give the manager a firm handshake. Yawn.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by busterarm on Friday June 17, 2022 @05:25PM (#31784571)
I worked shitty jobs into my 30s before I landed on my career. Suck it up.

Also you're missing the point. I didn't say anything about pulling yourself up by your bootstraps. You DON'T have to work hard. I said just show up. Every day. On time. That's literally the one thing I've seen in life that differentiates people who are successful in life from those who aren't.

And I know bank security guards who show up every day and live fulfilled happy successful lives. What I was saying was that commonly you'll find in unskilled labor jobs are people who don't show up every day. Not all of them but a large number. They won't do the minimum to succeed in life. They need the coddling.

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by andrepd on Friday June 17, 2022 @05:46PM (#31784803)
I'm sorry, but your impression is wrong. The biggest correlate with income is not your punctuality, not hours worked, not productivity. It is this: your parents' income. This directly contradicts the (popular) view that we live in a meritocracy where all you have to do to succeed is work hard and be smart and apply yourself.

> What I was saying was that commonly you'll find in unskilled labor jobs are people who don't show up every day.

Mind sharing the study of workplace absenteeism that you're basing that opinion on?

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by busterarm on Friday June 17, 2022 @08:02PM (#31786045)
I never correlated income with punctuality.

I correlated lack of punctuality with overrepresentation in low-wage+low-skill jobs.

There are also plenty of high-social status, skilled, low-income jobs that are thoroughly dominated by the upper classes, like college professors, journalists, rank & file media/fashion, and orchestra musicians. Those jobs are not low-skill and people in them tend to show up to work.

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by JumpCrisscross on Friday June 17, 2022 @03:11PM (#31782916)
> Do you have a better term for it?

Apparently the euphemism treadmill is on low-wage labor [1]. Which is dumb, since it literally though not conceptually covers graduate students.

[1] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/u/unskilled-labor.asp

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by triceratops on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:20PM (#31782219)
High-paid/low-paid labor?
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by totony on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:27PM (#31782333)
Skill is a proxy for supply whereas pay is a proxy of supply-demand. It might actually be a better term, since even if you do very skilled labor, you would prefer an union if there was no demand.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by bpodgursky on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:28PM (#31782346)
This is a terrible substitute, since there are a lot of low-paid high-skill jobs (ex, graduate students, TAs).

There's a meaningful labor liquidity difference between a job that takes 2 years of training and 2 days of training, and it's important for policy decisions. Sorry?

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by totony on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:32PM (#31782403)
But aren't those low-paid, high skill jobs likely to be unionized? Only issue I see with that term is that union affects pay.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by bpodgursky on Friday June 17, 2022 @03:21PM (#31783035)
I am not trying to argue about the merits of unionization. I am saying that "low-skill" is a meaningful term we should not drop.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by goodpoint on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:12PM (#31783642)
"labor" and "job"
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by noSyncCloud on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:27PM (#31782332)
More exploited | Less exploited?
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by sershe on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:17PM (#31783715)
Thank you for complimenting the above insightful comment! :)
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by adam_arthur on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:14PM (#31782134)
I wouldn't divide it between skilled and unskilled. It's more a product of supply and demand.

Unskilled labor can have decent bargaining power if there's a shortage of unskilled labor.

It just so happens that there tends to more frequently be shortages of skilled labor

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by bjornsing on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:25PM (#31782301)
> Unskilled labor can have decent bargaining power if there's a shortage of unskilled labor.

Not really, because that’s the definition of unskilled: it takes no special skills to do the job. So if there’s a shortage and wages go up dramatically then skilled labor can take its place. (The opposite is not possible/ advisable though.)

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by adam_arthur on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:30PM (#31782384)
Being willing to do the job is a hurdle on its own. And there is variance between employee quality for "unskilled" labor too.

E.g. think about customer facing roles and social skills/aptitude. Having all friendly/nice employees can drive greater revenue for a business. Chick fil a and costco are famous for hiring friendly employees, can have meaningful results for the business

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by busterarm on Friday June 17, 2022 @08:09PM (#31786086)
And plenty of businesses have gone the other way and decided that the personal touch of being greeted by a human being provides less business value than a computer. E.g., McDonalds, Wendy's, your grocery store.
Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by jasonlotito on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:24PM (#31782288)
> I bargain for myself, thanks.

Judging by that history, you aren't doing so well. Good luck, and hopefully things improve!

Re:Kickstarter Union voted 97.6% to ratify one of the first ... by busterarm on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:38PM (#31782492)
I haven't been part of a union for more than 20 years now. I'm doing great.