Yes. And there was also an impact that instead of an influx of new people on a regular cadence it was never ending. People were used to a brief disruption of netiquette standards and then things would go back to normal. But once the gates opened it was a never ending, yet increasing, set of new people arriving every day. It didn't take long for the new folks to outnumber the old hands.
To your creator:consumer point, that is also true. And I also think part of it was that the existing crowd couldn't comprehend that this was the case. People on Usenet at the time tended toward certain personality types. It was a bit of a shock when the average poster started to have wildly different goals and expectations.
Re:Eternal September
by justsomehnguy on Friday June 17, 2022 @04:15PM
(#31783680)
> The earliest ISPs were exactly that: attempts to welcome and help people to join the internet.
As a (mostly former) member of some old communities: it were just the same in the all cases, a small group of visionaries (or just a bunch of folks high on enthusiasm) which are slowly deluted by innate bureucrats and the grind of describing the same things over and over to the people who can't see the bright red "FAQ: NEWCOMERS PLEASE READ!" right in their faces.
But they did actually welcome and help people. The earliest ISPs were exactly that: attempts to welcome and help people to join the internet.
Eternal September is more a function of the number of people in a particular community not about whether or not people help other newcomers to join. The difference is that the early folks came from the tech world and had a level of involvement that was entirely different from the one that the later joiners had and so we ended up with a significantly dumbed down and re-siloed internet.
The creator:consumer ratio is what dropped.