WaMu failed in 2008 and was handled fairly well for a bank with $300B+ in assets.
A bunch of the euro crisis government bailouts happened because governments went underwater trying to save their banks.
From a quick investigation I can't see any bank that operates branches in all three of the largest countries (France, Germany and Italy), never mind all 27 member states. And those that do operate in many countries (HSBC must have the most) can have their local subsidiaries insured by the appropriate countries, just as they are insured by the FDIC when they open branches and take deposits in the US.
—-
There’s also a credibility problem. When the US stress tested its banks, the ones that passed did not fail. When the EU did it, some of the passing banks ended up needing saving, and this happened multiple times, sometimes even with the same bank.
Who do you think runs the FDIC?
Former chair: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jelena_McWilliams
> In December of 2021, McWilliams announced her resignation from the FDIC.[11] Following the election of President Joe Biden, Democrats controlled all the seats on the FDIC except for the one she held.[12] She resigned after expressing her frustrations in an essay published in the Wall Street Journal with what she called the erosion of agency norms at the FDIC and a "hostile takeover" by the other directors.
The FDIC is a captured entity. It is used as a political weapon and as a weapon for industry since it’s inception.
These “inspections” enabled the hostile take over by other banks. The FDIC sells the assets and those assets are purchased by the mega banks for cheap.
Who runs the FFIC? Former employees from these mega banks.
https://www.fdic.gov/resources/resolutions/bank-failures/fai...
It goes a long way to refute your claim (unless you count the buckeye state bank as a mega bank).
The highest bidder is naturally a mega bank, which the members of the FDIC worked at previously.
---
the FDIC does two things; it makes sure that depositors are made whole, and it is supposed to stop bank runs from being contagious. Selling to another bank instead of taking it over makes both of those things much easier, because the FDIC does a good job of making sure the acquiring institution can actually handle it (unlike the EU counterparts, where sometimes the acquisition schemes ended up tanking the acquiring bank too); and because the acquiring bank exists and has money available, depositors have pretty much uninterrupted access to their deposits. (It's also not quite a sale, in that the FDIC voluntells the acquiring bank that they're about to take over a bank: https://www.npr.org/2009/03/26/102384657/anatomy-of-a-bank-t...)
One thing to note is that while FDIC does insure deposits, it takes a while for them to get everything sorted, so you could be waiting weeks to get your deposits back. Given that a majority of households survey cannot handle a $400 surprise financial emergency, this outcome is still pretty bad for bank depositors.
The FDIC pretty much never uses the “deposit insurance” because the banks never get to that point of failure when the FDIC can instead just be a broker to a larger bank.
That means you and I never really have to simulate how many $250,000 balance bank accounts to actually open for our cash millions.
Even in 2008-2009 with the wave of bank failures, the insurance wasnt pulled. And so the behavior of the director composition doesn’t seem to have influence there.
How will we be able to have knowledgeable regulators without being able to employ people from the industry?
It should or could be ran by accountants from accounting firms. Probably would be more suited anyway.
b) How would you take over (especially short term) ownership of a bank without having any idea about how banks work? Don’t get me wrong, the revolving doors between regulators and regulated are a problem. But I fail to see how just removing the door altogether is a successful fix.
Second, they aren’t insuring only. In fact, they are typically liquidating. I think that’s part of the issue, it’s not a regulator body or an insurance body. It’s a liquidator that works, in part, at the behest of big banks and politicians.
I don’t have any obligation to disclose anything, nor is it “prudent”.
Take my comment as you will, from a random person on the internet. I provided context in the quotes and citations I left — none of which you commented on..?
To the point, what are you adding to the discussion with this? Not trying to come across snarky, but I don’t understand.
Also, I work in the technology sector and would never consider I needed to disclose that on HN when discussing, say, Google.
Either is just far too big a field to expect that a conflict of interest is inevitable.
I am not sure that todays hyper-consolidated megabanks are a better implementation of a well regulated market. As most of them nowadays are just too big to fail. So part of the mandatory market forces cannot be used lest you want to generate broad reaching consequences.