News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by tromp on Thursday June 16, 2022 @12:54PM (#31768305)
> “Defendants falsely and deceptively claim that Dogecoin is a legitimate investment when it has no value at all,” Johnson said in his complaint,

What makes a cryptocurrency a "legitimate investment" ? It clearly is a risky and highly speculative investment, but it's not clear to me what separates legitimate ones from illegitimate ones. Johnson's claim that Dogecoin has no value at all seems rather bogus, as it still trades at well over 1 cent per coin (we can agree it has no "inherent value").

Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by horsawlarway on Thursday June 16, 2022 @03:47PM (#31770106)
I'd say when the original creator of the "currency" defines it as a joke, and the coin is configured so that ~14.5 million new coins are minted every day... It's safe to consider it illegitimate as an investment.

At a minimum, it certainly can't be considered a valid value store, since the amount of currency in circulation inflates at an incredible pace, and without regard to the current value.

Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by tromp on Thursday June 16, 2022 @04:38PM (#31770699)
I strongly disagree. First of all, whether it's 14.5 coins per day or 14,500 or 14.5M or 14.5B doesn't matter at all, since it's just arbitrary scaling (just like how each bitcoin is really 100B satoshi). Secondly, a fixed block subsidy is an entirely reasonable emission schedule, with yearly supply inflation going down at a steady rate, taking 2 decades to drop down to 5% (better than fiat this year), and taking 5 decades to be the 2% that fiat aims for.

In fact, there's one serious cryptocurrency that chose exactly such an emission, averaging one coin per second forever. It's the only coin that doesn't have the current generation hog the majority of (soft [1]) total supply...

[1] https://john-tromp.medium.com/a-case-for-using-soft-total-su...

Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by randomhodler84 on Thursday June 16, 2022 @06:02PM (#31771550)
100M sats per BTC my dude
Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by joshjdr on Thursday June 16, 2022 @04:54PM (#31770854)
This comment looks like a lawsuit waiting to happen!
Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by Schroedingersat on Thursday June 16, 2022 @04:54PM (#31770849)
No argument that it isn't a scam, but you appear to fundamentally misunderstand the concept of exponential growth.

Adding a linear amount to a pool induces an exponentially decaying inflation rate which becomes negligible after a decade or two.

As such, dogecoin is the same fomo/'store of value'/deflationary scam as all the other coins, just skewed a little less towards the first suckers to join the ponzi scheme

Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by Salgat on Thursday June 16, 2022 @07:47PM (#31772366)
Can we stop with this disingenuous oversimplified "big number bad" argument? Dogecoin is the only major coin with an intentional long term inflation rate comparable to real world fiat. That has merit and novelty as far as cryptocurrencies go, especially if your goal is for it to be an actual currency.
Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by kayamon on Thursday June 16, 2022 @03:49PM (#31770120)
I suppose it depends if there's someone manipulating it. A coin like Bitcoin is immune to internal manipulation -- there's one Bitcoin mined every ten minutes, and no one can change that, no matter how much money they have.

Satoshi proved that a blockchain is only secure if it's the blockchain with the longest accumulated proof-of-work record. Dogecoin's blockchain is shorter, and they can't win a race where the other players are already ahead. Miners will generally only mine the blockchain with the most value, thus the market for one mining the leading crypto squeezes out the market for mining all the others. Miners must vote with their electricity as to which blockchain to support. No other blockchain can ever maintain its stability as long as Bitcoin exists.

The game theory that backs Bitcoin also proves that all other cryptocurrencies cannot work in the long term.

Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by Schroedingersat on Thursday June 16, 2022 @05:05PM (#31770967)
> Satoshi proved that a blockchain is only secure if it's the blockchain with the longest accumulated proof-of-work record.

This statement is correct, but you appear to be fundamentally misunderstanding it. The category being considered is that of blockchains making incompatible claims about the same truth.

Events on the dogecoin blockchain are making no claims about the bitcoin blockchain and vice versa, so this statement is irrelevant. Similarly it is irrelevant between any two distinct tokens even if they originate as forks of another token. You could download the BTC blockchain, take it to a distant planet and transact with it using only local compute just fine. It's just that -- were you to re-establish contact with earth -- omicron-persei-eight-BTC and earth-BTC would now be different tokens. So long as some subset of the population agreed to use the former it would be a valid token and earthlings could transact on your blockchain with their wallets (at the balance they had when you left), it just wouldn't be earth-BTC

Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by kayamon on Thursday June 16, 2022 @06:32PM (#31771817)
As long as communication can occur between the two populations (FTL will present its own problems in years to come), they will trade using the best money available and will not mine the lesser blockchain.

All non-leading blockchains will ultimately fail.

Tick tock next block.

Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by tromp on Thursday June 16, 2022 @04:46PM (#31770773)
> Dogecoin's blockchain is shorter

Not only is blockchain length immaterial to its relevancy, but Dogecoin's chain is in fact longer, as its block interval is only 1 minute, so it is asymptotically 10 times longer than Bitcoin.

> there's one Bitcoin mined every ten minutes

You mean one block (containing an subsidy starting at 50 Bitcoin that's halved every 4 years).

> Miners will generally only mine the blockchain with the most value

Wrong; SHA256 miners will mine the most profitable SHA256 chain, such as Bitcoin. Scrypt miners have totally different ASICs and will mine the most profitable scrypt chain.

> No other blockchain can ever maintain its stability as long as Bitcoin exists. The game theory that backs Bitcoin also proves that all other cryptocurrencies cannot work in the long term.

The theory behind Bitcoin long term security is rather shaky in fact, requiring a constant backlog of high-fee paying transactions once its block subsidy becomes insignificant. Chains with a tail emission face no such issues.

Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by Salgat on Thursday June 16, 2022 @07:49PM (#31772382)
Length doesn't mean much, it's size that matters, and that comes down to total transactions across all blocks, as transactions per block is not some fixed number.
Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by billylindeman on Thursday June 16, 2022 @08:05PM (#31772499)
So it's the girth that matters?
Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by yellowapple on Friday June 17, 2022 @03:37AM (#31775206)
Using 'em as actual currencies tends to benefit from sidechains that speed up the flow of transactions - "veins", if you will - so the more girthy and veiny it is, the better.
Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by IYasha on Thursday June 16, 2022 @04:58PM (#31770903)
>> A coin like Bitcoin is immune to internal manipulation

Even if NSA..I mean, "Satoshi" was to do something with his 1.1M BTC?

Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by randomhodler84 on Thursday June 16, 2022 @06:07PM (#31771602)
Why would spending some old coinbase tx’s from a decade+ ago have any impact on core parameters of the protocol? Whomever is spending coins has no impact on coin emission. I highly doubt they could even bribe the Protocol maintainers.
Re:Musk, Tesla, SpaceX Are Sued for Alleged Dogecoin Pyramid... by suifbwish on Friday June 17, 2022 @10:53AM (#31779091)
Most non physical things you are capable of buying have absolutely no value except what gullible people in large numbers ascribe to them. What you really want to invest in are stars, planets and magical items.