Re:Show HN: I made a site that shows jobs where you can work...
by bombcar on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @04:16PM
(#31758861)
You can even give hundreds or thousands of dollars to people as gifts without reporting requirements.
The requirements kick in when people are trying to avoid paying social security tax, basically, or paying for work under the table.
> I'm not suggesting it's necessary to pay any person you associate with.
So you agree the right to free association is orthogonal to the idea of hiring people to do a paid job then, right? In which case, how is having labor hiring laws a violation of free association, when you agree you can still freely associate with people? In which case, arguing "free association" in terms of arguing that labor hiring laws being unjust isn't really a valid argument then, huh?
Like, I can go down to a park with a group of friends and not have to tell the government about it. I can attend a church and practice and not have to tell the government about it. I can have a dinner party at my home with my friends and not have to tell the government about it. I can freely associate with whoever I want, that's not a crime.
I can't hire a bunch of people who are not legally allowed to work in this country, as currently the government wants to disincentive unrestricted immigration and have made this action of paying people for labor they deem improper illegal. This is an immigration policy, not a free association policy. FWIW, I'm one to argue we should relax some hiring practices and reduce barriers to immigration in many ways, but this really isn't a "free association" kind of issue.