News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by sdfhdhjdw3 on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:14AM (#31751816)
Oh jesus christ, the constant whining!

This is science. This is how it works. Maybe there's nothing else to discover, maybe it will take us 100 years, we don't know, that's why it's called research.

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by Certhas on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:37AM (#31752078)
You are mischaracterize what's happening entirely. The article is not whining and it's not claiming that this is somehow shaking the foundations of science. But we are potentially in the middle (or even at the end) of a monumental shift inside physics. Particle physics produced fantastic discoveries over the second half of the twentieth century and it might just have hit a major major wall (or in the lingo of the field, encountered a desert) where we can not expect new discoveries in the next decades or centuries.

If that's so it will mean a major restructuring of the field of physics. It has vast implications for researchers that chose what to work on or whom to fund. Yes it's all part of research, but the flavor and type of research in one of the most prominent fields of science is undergoing a massive shift. That's news that's well suited for a publication called Science. And it reflects genuine scientific debate that's been going on for more than a decade on the inside.

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by BurningFrog on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @09:24AM (#31752514)
It would make sense to more resources to other fields.

But institutions don't tend to dismantle themselves, so I expect a few decades of "we might find something soon!" until the leaders have retired.

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by ced on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @09:33AM (#31752635)
> In 1973, professor Sir James Lighthill was asked by the UK Parliament to evaluate the state of AI research in the United Kingdom. His report, now called the Lighthill report, criticized the utter failure of AI to achieve its "grandiose objectives." He concluded that nothing being done in AI couldn't be done in other sciences. He specifically mentioned the problem of "combinatorial explosion" or "intractability", which implied that many of AI's most successful algorithms would grind to a halt on real world problems and were only suitable for solving "toy" versions.[15]

> The report led to the complete dismantling of AI research in England.[15] AI research continued in only a few universities (Edinburgh, Essex and Sussex).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_winter

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by awhitby on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @09:50AM (#31752857)
In retrospect it was at least arguably the right call, no? Suspend most research and resume when available processing power was orders of magnitude greater, a process that was independently driven by demands other than (and much greater than) AI research.

Playing devil's advocate only slightly, maybe particle physics should similarly pare down to a bare maintenance level of research (or even mostly teaching) for a few centuries until we can harness much higher energies.

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by astrange on Thursday June 16, 2022 @06:07AM (#31764262)
They were right; modern ML doesn’t use any of the ideas the previous generation of AI people were pursuing. It turns out no expert system is a match for just doing a bunch of matrix multiplications.
Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by spicymaki on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:57AM (#31752217)
> This is science. This is how it works. Maybe there's nothing else to discover, maybe it will take us 100 years, we don't know, that's why it's called research.

I think the argument is not whether we invest in research or not, but are we putting our limited resources into viable research or not. Sabine Hossenfelder argues that many researchers are more interested in testing their pet theory based on mathematical beauty than actually working on more boring forms of fundamental research. This imbalance leads to poor returns on research investments.

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by tokai on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:44AM (#31752141)
Which whining? From the article:

>It’s too early to despair, many physicists say

or

>“I very much doubt that in 20 years, I will say, ‘Oh, boy, after the Higgs discovery we learned nothing new.’”

The whole article is about how the upgrade to the LHC will give more precision and more data. Even if it was whining, critiquing and bickering over the status quo very much a cornerstone of science. Your annoyance looks like something coming from a place of dogmatism..

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by denton-scratch on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:24AM (#31751912)
> Maybe there's nothing else to discover

AFAICS that is not one of the options; there are mysteries and contradictions whose explanations remain to be discovered. But maybe we can't discover more using the LHC (which I doubt).

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by prionassembly on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @10:18AM (#31753283)
There's the mythology of the heavens being held up by the titan Atlas, who rests on top of a cow, which rests on top of a turtle... the kiddy version continues on top of another turtle, on top of...

I once had a vision -- yes, a vision, something deep came to me as I laid half-awake -- that after a few dozen turtles the actual ground was made of jackstraw[1]. It rested on a firm tangle.

I've always felt since then that the world and the universe themselves are made of contradictions. That some contradictions are fundamental, and this is why since Socrates we've always been so focused on finding contradictions. Because maybe we can find the ones we can't pick apart.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pick-up_sticks

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by denton-scratch on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @02:22PM (#31757093)
> the world and the universe themselves are made of contradictions.

In logic, it's said that from a contradiction you can validly deduce any proposition.

The idea that contradictions are fundamental is horrifying; it implies that any attempt to reason about the world is doomed. I don't know how it would affect me if I believed that. I hope you have a good therapist!

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by Grimburger on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:14AM (#31751820)
> Maybe there's nothing else to discover, maybe it will take us 100 years, we don't know, that's why it's called research.

At what price?

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by quickthrower2 on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:32AM (#31752007)
Cheaper than not doing it
Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by highwaylights on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:17AM (#31751848)
Less than it cost to research, develop and manufacture all of the components in the device you typed this on.
Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by BurningFrog on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @09:25AM (#31752537)
Sure, but that effort is providing enormous benefits to all of humanity.
Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by lucretian on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @09:58AM (#31752957)
has it...?
Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by Grimburger on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:20AM (#31751878)
I'd put that amortised cost at about $1000 upfront in 2022 dollars for my high quality internet comment and many others like it.

If you need high energy, pure vacuums and ultra low temps, surely space is where such experiments should be conducted on bigger scales in future to push it further?

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by superluserdo on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:45AM (#31752160)
Space won't work for the kind of physics the LHC does.

The fundamental problem is that collider physics relies on being able to create collisions of exactly known quantity as your input (eg in the LHC's case, proton-proton collisions at a 14TeV centre of mass energy). If you don't control the input, you can't extract any information about the output you detect, in the same way that you can't create a simulation of snooker by looking at the balls on the table, without knowing how they were set up before being hit.

The other problem is that to probe the frontier of particle physics, you need truly immense statistics to get enough of the incredibly rare collisions. Think bunches of hundreds of billions of protons colliding tens of millions of times per second. The upshot is that you'd not only need to build the detectors in space (which are thousands of tonnes with extremely precise electronics that need whole server farms plugged directly into them to process the terabits of data coming out each second), but you'd also need to build the entire collider in space too.

Even then it's a rather pointless endeavour, since the colliders require a colder temperature and higher vacuum than even interstellar space, nevermind within the solar system.

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by Grimburger on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @09:52AM (#31752884)
> Space won't work for the kind of physics the LHC does.

https://home.cern/science/engineering/cryogenics-low-tempera...

> The LHC's cryogenic system requires 40,000 leak-tight pipe seals, 40 MW of electricity – 10 times more than is needed to power a locomotive – and 120 tonnes of helium to keep the magnets at 1.9 K.

Launch cost per kg aside for the detectors and basic framework, space is the best place for pushing the boundaries of high energy physics experiments in the future.

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by superluserdo on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @11:26AM (#31754419)
All that stuff you're describing would still need to be sent to space, for no upside. That includes the 27km+ long collider ring. I haven't even mentioned the fact that this stuff is built 100 metres underground precisely to avoid noise from cosmic radiation.
Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by highwaylights on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:26AM (#31751938)
I can't speak to whether it would cost less to do these experiments in space, I'm no expert on the colliding of particles and the implications thereof.

In any case - how much of that $1000 is attributed to the research and development of the wheel in Ancient Mesopotamia?

How much is attributed to the discovery of electricity, and to General Relativity?

If we weren't attempting to get answers to fundamental questions we'd still be living in caves.

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by fennecfoxen on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:55AM (#31752204)
> I can't speak to whether it would cost less to do these experiments in space, I'm no expert on the colliding of particles and the implications thereof.

I'm a nonexpert who has some vague idea of how these things work.

There's two kinds of accelerator: circular and linear. In either case, you have a tube, often underground, a bunch of accelerator components along the tube, and a detector component. I believe but I am not sure that a key advantage of the circular one is that you can accelerate the particles in the beam as they take multiple loops around the tube. The disadvantage is that when charged particles turn they lose energy by emitting electromagnetic radiation, and the whole point of the accelerator is to stuff these particles full of energy to make interesting collisions. This is mitigated by having higher-radius accelerators, which is the key reason we build things like the Large Hadron Collider and make it so very large in the first place, instead of just trying to add stronger stuff at existing accelerators.

So what do you intend to do in space?

The quasi-achievable near term might see a linear accelerator that consists of two components orbiting and firing particle beams into a third (the detector) because we are obviously not orbiting the mass of the LHC in the near term, and we're not orbiting anything that's rigid and also substantially larger than a rocket payload. It will no doubt be tricky to align the beams, as the orbits are ellipses and the beams need to be approximately straight lines (or close enough, blah blah spacetime). But the fundamental problem is that you're going to need to do all your acceleration all at once, at the accelerators, which immediately negates any possible advantages you could possibly have from space.

Perhaps you could do something very clever with an orbit-sized circular accelerator with accelerators spaced at intervals around the planet. You'd need a lot of launches of some intense equipment (I believe the Earth-based accelerator components are giant supercooled magnets). You'd also need an energy source, lots of engineering prowess to get everything in good working order (LHC bringup was very hands-on) except any adjustments will have to be done in orbit, and then when it's running you'd face the problem of LOLmaintenance.

I'm going to be honest, I'm more skeptical about this than about the Mars colony.

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by Grimburger on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:31AM (#31752000)
Fair chunk of the cost is people working for slave wages in Asia and has nothing to do with with ancient Mesopotamia, let's be honest and not disingenuous here.

Are you actually interested in discussing the topic at hand?

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by headmelted on Thursday June 16, 2022 @06:23AM (#31764364)
Ok. Slave wages too.

My point is that all technology is built on prior discoveries and all matter of other factors that produce the civilisation, that produces doohickies, to look up cat memes.

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by sdfhdhjdw3 on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:44AM (#31752142)
Spoken like a true ignoramus.
Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:45AM (#31752163)
Are the folks who allocate funding unserstanding of this predicament, the possibility that it will take 100 years to discover anything else?
Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by adamsmith143 on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @09:48AM (#31752823)
>Maybe there's nothing else to discover

This is fundamentally wrong. We know the Standard Model is not the final theory of Physics so there are still things to discover.

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by NateEag on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @10:14AM (#31753222)
If you think the Simulation Hypothesis has any merit whatsoever, you should consider the possibility that the Simulation does not have a fully-consistent engine, just one that was "close enough".

Note, of course, that the same could be true in a coincidentally-generated universe, as well as a deistic or theistic one (the latter two being effectively indistinguishable from a Simulation).

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by astrange on Thursday June 16, 2022 @06:19AM (#31764337)
It must have a pretty good physics engine since we don’t see any strange artifacts in the sky from the times pre-cosmic inflation. In particular, it can’t be very quantized or we’d see giant “upscaling” artifacts.

It also appears to give us exactly enough computational power to build quantum computers, but not any more than that. That seems like a pretty inconvenient choice for us and the simulators.

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by NateEag on Sunday June 19, 2022 @08:34PM (#31804975)
These are good points. Thanks for sharing them!

I'm not personally all that convinced by the Simulation Hypothesis, but I recognize it's a legitimate possibility.

... right alongside the possibility that base reality doesn't have a fully consistent physics system. So far assuming reality works has panned out pretty well, but we can't be sure that will just always be true.

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by adamsmith143 on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @11:53AM (#31754895)
Not sure it's worth thinking about. You would think that a sufficiently powerful simulation could procedurally generate an arbitrary level of detail so there wouldn't really be gaps.
Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by NateEag on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @01:03PM (#31755936)
Only with a perfect procedural algorithm.

Which may not fit with any hypothetical Simulator's goals, anyway.

Most games don't feature an absolutely perfect Newtonian physics engine. The physics is just a means to an end, not the fundamental point of the whole endeavor.

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by sdfhdhjdw3 on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @01:16PM (#31756127)
> This is fundamentally wrong. We know the Standard Model is not the final theory of Physics so there are still things to discover.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man#Steelmanning

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by pizzaknife on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:16AM (#31751843)
literally my sentiments exactly. Next thing you know, someone will be clamoring to make the LHC a profit center and complain about its solvency!

edit: I have no dog in the fight, but I do appreciate the concept of "Art for Art's sake." To me, the LHC embodies the physics equiv of that statement.

Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by japanuspus on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:41AM (#31752111)
You do realize that most of the money for LHC end up in industry, not academia?
Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by pizzaknife on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @03:22PM (#31758066)
could you rephrase this question?
Re:Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare ... by bmitc on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @08:36AM (#31752064)
Funding is not infinite.