News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to create a dashboard in Python with Jupyter Notebook by blagie on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @08:19AM (#31738094)
Yes, I've found dashboards useful.

Generalizations or problematic, since so much of this depends on industry, company, and role.

I'm in an industry (education) where at-a-glance dashboards have a proven track record of dramatically improve learning outcomes. It turns out that:

(1) Teachers, while believing they know their students, actually don't. Teachers also regularly fail to grasp what students do and don't understand.

(2) Allowing teachers to monitor their students, both individually and classroom wide, leads to much better outcomes.

In the context of a classroom, teachers are busy, non-technical (and sometimes incompetent), so an at-a-glance view is critical. For an example of real-time dashboarding done well, see Learning Catalytics. It grew out of a highly-respected physics education research project (Peer Instruction, by Eric Mazur), and allows teachers to monitor student understanding during lecture. Showing where misconceptions exist allows for deeper dives and deeper conversation. There are many systems like it, and ample evidence of improved student growth when they're used.

That's very specific, I know, but there are similar examples in other industries I've worked in.

Re:How to create a dashboard in Python with Jupyter Notebook by urthor on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @09:32AM (#31739185)
Real time monitoring during a live task is certainly a use case I've never thought of.

A very good point.

I remember a piece on programming education research awhile ago. Said education outcomes improved considerably if you constantly bombard students with multiple choice questions.

Administering that through a dashboard would be essential.

Re:How to create a dashboard in Python with Jupyter Notebook by falcor84 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @10:05AM (#31739685)
> education outcomes improved considerably if you constantly bombard students with multiple choice questions

I would love to read more about that, if you happen to have a link to share.

Re:How to create a dashboard in Python with Jupyter Notebook by urthor on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @10:06AM (#31739711)
Re:How to create a dashboard in Python with Jupyter Notebook by falcor84 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @11:10AM (#31740629)
Much obliged.

I see the relevant part seems to be the following, in the "Tip 4" section:

""" The key to making demonstrations more effective is to make learners predict the outcome of the demonstration before performing it. Crucially, their prediction should be in some way recorded or public, e.g., by a show of hands, by holding up cue cards marked with A, B, C, or D, or by talking to their neighbour. We speculate that the sting of being publicly wrong leads learners to pay more attention and to reflect on what they are learning; regardless of whether this hypothesis is true, instructors should be careful not to punish or criticise students who predicted wrongly but rather to use those incorrect predictions as a spur to further exploration and explanation. """

Re:How to create a dashboard in Python with Jupyter Notebook by blagie on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @03:00PM (#31744326)
That part has been replicated (see e.g. vicarious learning, from Derek Muller as well as Miki Chi, studies on Khan Academy in-video questions, etc.).

However, it's not the most relevant part. The most relevant part is simple use of active learning. The classic paper here is Hake (Interactive-Engagement vs. Traditional Methods: A Six-Thousand-Student Survey of Mechanics Test Data for Introductory Physics Courses). However, it's been replicated discipline-by-discipline (lots of papers in PNAS). Best summary is ICAP by Miki Chi. Miki didn't invent it, and ICAP isn't the most rigorous, but she's pretty good at these summaries.

Having students do anything beyond listening leads to huge improvements in student learning, basically no matter what it is. Some things lead to bigger improvements than others, of course. Even clicking a "next" button occasionally shows a (very modest) gain. For good interactive engagement, doubling of learning gains is a good lower-bound over passive listening.

Re:How to create a dashboard in Python with Jupyter Notebook by urthor on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @07:15AM (#31751377)
Note that it's Active Recall according to other education research.

Not only active participation, but actively being forced to remember the knowledge, in a different format to the original, is the key.

Teaching another student is definitely an approach to this. But a gentle touch multiple choice question also works.

Re:How to create a dashboard in Python with Jupyter Notebook by blagie on Thursday June 16, 2022 @05:37AM (#31764094)
No, that's not really fair.

There's a broad range of techniques which have significant learning gains beyond passive learning. Active recall is one of them. We have no clear sense of how they compare to each other or how they work in combination. There is ample evidence for active recall, but there is equally ample evidence for a dozen other techniques much like it. We don't have great studies comparing them side-by-side.

The best hypothesis for how they compare is ICAP, referenced. It's still a hypothesis. You can look at the evidence behind it.

Much of this is context-dependent too. Active recall is great for factoids. If you're trying to learn a date in history, memorize a word in a foreign language, or a formula in math, your best bet is a spaced repetition system (how you time active recall makes a big difference too; spaced repetition > simple active recall > passive recall).

If you're trying to understand a concept like force (in physics), what an integral means (in math), make sense of the tradition away from serfdom, or compare ethical systems between two cultures, active recall is almost irrelevant. At that point, the best methods are probably constructive and interactive learning.

Re:How to create a dashboard in Python with Jupyter Notebook by urthor on Saturday June 18, 2022 @08:17PM (#31795004)
I agree.

In my mind, active recall is an excellent technique that's appropriate for the first lecture covering a topic.

Which is why I like it as a prompt in a lecture, not so much later on.

Constructive learning in my mind comes later.

Re: the balance between constructive learning and other types.

I feel that we often accelerate the students too quickly to constructive learning, whilst they can still benefit from rote learning some worked examples.

The balance between rote learning and "copying" worked examples, and constructive learning from first principles, is a very difficult one.

I truly think that, certainly for programming education, all my professional life I've gotten huge mileage out of genuinely copying in example projects and tutorials into a text editor.

I think we underestimate just how much students benefit from rote learning.

I think programming education would benefit far more from 19 year old rote learning from retired 65 year olds. I find the college education system is fairly broken, in that it deploys researchers who are excellent lecturers, but far too few 65 year olds.

And there's an ocean of extremely willing to teach 65 year olds out there.

Re:How to create a dashboard in Python with Jupyter Notebook by mistrial9 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @09:48AM (#31739469)
honestly this is a nightmare'ish point of view for anything but hard science at senior level. The emotional environment of being monitored constantly is toxic. Control-oriented people gravitate towards constant monitoring in similar ways as the Executive and their Dashboard are described above. How can thinking and feeling humans delegate interaction in a learning environment to machinery ?
Re:How to create a dashboard in Python with Jupyter Notebook by blagie on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @02:55PM (#31744237)
That can be true, but it's not true in this case. Eric Mazur's classroom is sort of a visitor sport -- people come from around the world to observe. I'd encourage you to do the same. It's very human.

As originally implemented, the technique was pretty simple:

- You give a traditional lecture

- Every five minutes or so, students are asked a question to see if they understand concepts

- The system peers students who answered differently to discuss. Students can change their answers at the end.

- The instructor and class see aggregated statistics (e.g. 90% of people answered 27, 5% answered 54, and 5% gave other answers)

- Based on the feedback, the instructor can do a deeper dive into places where there are common misconceptions

Today's class is very different. Mazur juggles all sorts of peer learning models, 360 reviews, etc. in ways which are superhuman. But that's the original model.

Most of the uses of formative assessment lead to classrooms feeling more personal, more personalized, and more human.

There are control-oriented systems which scare the heck out of me, like GoGuardian and Securely, but this isn't it. There is a complex ethics question of how to build systems which don't dehumanize students.

Re:How to create a dashboard in Python with Jupyter Notebook by urthor on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:32PM (#31747333)
The problem with voluntary question and answer is that the loud kids ask questions.

The shy kids sit there and be quiet.

"Prompt" questions, like multiple choice, are a good way of encouraging reluctant students to come out of their shell."

Re:How to create a dashboard in Python with Jupyter Notebook by blagie on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @07:14AM (#31751370)
It's not voluntary. 100% of students are asked a question. In the eighties, this was entered into a classroom response system (a clicker where kids press a button on multiple choice) and an eighties-era computer would process their responses for an eighties-era dashboard, presumably using one of those $20,000 CRT projectors.

Today, it's cell phones and laptops, and they do a lot more than multiple choice. Students might be asked to highlight text in a passage (and the system shows a heatmap), to draw vectors, etc.

Re:How to create a dashboard in Python with Jupyter Notebook by urthor on Saturday June 18, 2022 @08:21PM (#31795024)
I didn't have that growing up at all, but I think that's an excellent way to get 11 year olds to learn something. Minus the $20k projector.
Re:How to create a dashboard in Python with Jupyter Notebook by urthor on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:31PM (#31747317)
Mate it's a classroom of 9 year olds.

They can't be trusted to dress themselves.