News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by corrral on Monday June 13, 2022 @06:17PM (#31732467)
Exposure to very bright light (even standing under a shade tree on a cloudy day is far brighter than normal indoor lighting) specifically during key years had been nailed down with high confidence as the primary cause of most near-sightedness, last time I looked into this.

Not sure if they'd figured out the mechanism, but speculation was that bright light is involved in signaling the eye to stop lengthening at the right time.

IOW the cause is, basically, school. In Winter months, kids may hardly see the Sun at all, with very short days and recess often indoors (too cold, too snowy, too wet) especially as schools have seemed to grow more wary of taking kids out in poor weather, over the last few decades. Plus anything else that keeps kids indoors, sure (video games, social media[0]) but school seems to be a lot of it.

[0] And actually, the social media factor likely kicks in well after it matters. Ditto video games unless your kid becomes a gaming addict in the 3-7 age range and you just let that happen.

Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by exceptione on Monday June 13, 2022 @06:24PM (#31732536)
If exposure to bright light is the primary cause of most near-sightedness, than not seeing the sun would be beneficial. I don´t get it, typo?
Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by dan-robertson on Monday June 13, 2022 @06:56PM (#31732783)
Yeah typo. The theory is that eyes change shape over time (I think starting out longsighted) and at some point a hormone is released to stop this changing. It is released when (a) the eyes are typically around the middle of their focal range (ie looking at middle-distance things is done with relaxed eyes) and (b) there is a lot of light. Without the second condition the shape of the eyes will continue to change and then you get myopia.
Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by derefr on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:26PM (#31732985)
See also: metabolic bone disease in lizards. Also caused by a lack of light — in their case, near-UV light.

(My understanding is that the thing changing the shape of the eye over time is the development of the orbital socket bones — so nearsightedness and MBD could have more in common than it seems.)

Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by corrral on Monday June 13, 2022 @08:52PM (#31733546)
Yeah, typo, too late to edit. Insufficient exposure to bright light during key, early years while the eye is developing was found to increase risk so much that it's practically all that matters, at least over a population (I'm sure some unlucky people get it for other reasons, like most things)
Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by wenc on Monday June 13, 2022 @06:45PM (#31732690)
I grew up near the equator where there is a very high rate of myopia despite exposure to sunlight. (Sure we spent a lot of time indoors, but we were exposed to sunlight all year round since there’s only one season: summer).

I think genetics has a larger predictive effect than sunlight.

Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by barry-cotter on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:49PM (#31733132)
> I think genetics has a larger predictive effect than sunlight.

We know this isn’t true because Singapore is practically on the equator and went from less than 10% myopia to over 90% in ~50 years.

Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by stefan_ on Monday June 13, 2022 @08:06PM (#31733237)
I'm not sure this is the argument you are trying to make, unless Singapore moved it's position on earth. Not that genetics are any more convincing, seeing how it's only 50y.
Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by tnzk on Monday June 13, 2022 @09:05PM (#31733630)
Less sunlight due to economic growth and improvement on education in Singapore last 50y?
Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by hndamien on Monday June 13, 2022 @11:50PM (#31734535)
The discovery and test actually came from Singapopre and they ended up making some glass classrooms. Pictures here - https://www.cnn.com/2015/04/05/asia/myopia-east-asia/index.h...

Perhaps it is roof opening...

Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by wenc on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:57PM (#31733185)
Right with the same amount of sunlight.

I’ll grant that with indoor malls and public transit there’s less exposure to direct sunlight, but you still can’t avoid being exposed to the sun daily in Singapore.

Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by djtango on Monday June 13, 2022 @09:43PM (#31733886)
Are you familiar with Singaporean norms?

There is/was a very strong aversion to being outdoors, especially during peak sunlight hours (lunchtime). This compounds with both study culture and digital culture (videogames + tv + phones) and less of a celebration of sports to mean many kids get less direct sunlight than you'd think. Especially now everyone is terrified of UV

Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by wenc on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:02AM (#31734602)
Yes I am.

I don't think OP mentioned being in the direct sunlight, but being exposed to it (visually, as in a source of bright light). Unless you sequester yourself in a room without windows all day, to get anywhere you're likely to need to walk outside to a bus stop, an MRT station, or to get a Grab. And unless there's a tunnel connecting office buildings to hawker centers, folks probably need to walk outside to get lunch (exceptions are malls connected to food courts).

Singaporeans probably get more sunlight than say Swedes over the course of a year.

Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by throwawaySG on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @02:19AM (#31735351)
This study on Singaporean children (https://bjo.bmj.com/content/bjophthalmol/early/2021/04/14/bj...) says that

> Singaporean children had shorter reported time outdoors and lower light levels, relative to their counterparts overseas. In the current study, reported time outdoors was 1.7±1.6hours/day and average light levels were 458±228lux. In contrast, children of similar ages in Australia and the UK reported time outdoors of at least 2–3 hours/day.18 22 Likewise, higher average light levels of 1072 and 1627 lux were reported in Australian (age 10–15 years)16 and American (age 5–10 years) children,20 respectively. Differences in educational demands (homework load and afterschool enrichment classes),23 lifestyle and sociocultural factors may account for the lower reported time outdoors and light levels in Singaporean children

I can't remember exactly how many hours of exposure to sunlight the studies mentioned, but I think it was something like 2-3 hours --- and it might have to be more than just, e.g., being near a window. I'm Singaporean too, and that excerpt from that paper accords with my experience. I highly doubt that I and most of the people I grew up with had that much sunlight exposure per day.

Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by djtango on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @04:08AM (#31736074)
Fair enough - not trying to condescend just establishing what your opinions may be based on.

My own personal (and very anecdotal) observations are that people really go out of their way to avoid exposure to the outdoors. Depending on your lifestyle, it is really possible to spend the day having only been outside for minutes of a day.

I think things are changing but I feel like the last 20-50 years have not really celebrated an outdoors lifestyle. Whereas my time in Europe is somewhat different in that plenty of people optimise to spend time outdoors - probably due to less oppressive weather and kids were encouraged to play outside a lot more

Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by Rastonbury on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:17AM (#31734686)
Not buying the sunlight argument, equatorial countries are hardly afflicted by vitamin D deficiencies or seasonal affective disorder you see in Europe. Solar intensity is stronger year round than summer in some Scandinavian countries. If it were sun, we'd see similar patterns in myopia to vit D deficiency as you get closer to the poles.
Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by djtango on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @03:58AM (#31736014)
This is def a decent counterpoint - on a previous HN thread on this topic I recall studies being done on agricultural vs urban mainland chinese people and how a refinement to the observation so sunlight/outdoors might be a proxy for some other factor. I've seen proposed "distant viewing".

Although one possible nuance is that sunlight to the eyes != sunlight to the skin. In cold climates you wear thick clothes which will block out sunlight to the skin (vit D deficiency) but you may still get plenty of UV to the eyes. Throw in some mountains for distant gazing and suddenly nations that love skiing could be simultaneously vit D deficient but guarded against myopia.

Pure conjecture of course - IANA(Biologist/Opthamologist/Doctor)

Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by lmm on Monday June 13, 2022 @08:29PM (#31733413)
The amount of time you spend in sunlight matters. Kids went from running around outdoors all day (whether for work or play) to spending all day sitting in classrooms.
Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by bpodgursky on Monday June 13, 2022 @11:42PM (#31734491)
Accidentally looking outdoors 10 minutes a day is not really equivalent to (historically) being in the bright sun for 12 hours a day.
Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by wenc on Monday June 13, 2022 @11:55PM (#31734563)
> being in the bright sun for 12 hours a day.

I don't think historically (at least in the past 40 years) most people (barring construction workers and certain jobs) from that region were ever out for 12 hours a day in the bright sunlight.

Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by novia on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:47AM (#31734838)
You can read a book outside under a tree and get enough lumens. When we switched to backlit screens for showing information, this necessitated that more time be spent indoors to be able to make out the words on the screen.
Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by doliveira on Monday June 13, 2022 @06:56PM (#31732787)
There's a reason why they're not just saying "it's genetics"...
Re:In Asia, short-sightedness is becoming ubiquitous by irrational on Monday June 13, 2022 @07:29PM (#31733006)
Have any studies been done comparing children raised in Portland and Seattle (where it rains for the majority of the year so kids spend a lot of time indoors) versus San Diego or some other sunny city?