News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by mort96 on Monday June 13, 2022 @01:24PM (#31728583)
I don't understand the whole "free will is an illusion" thing. To me it seems obvious; I clearly do have free will because I choose to do things on my own volition. And the "me" who does the choosing is made up of largely deterministic electrochemical processes which respond to stimuli, with a bunch of feedback loops and other complexity. That is all my consciousness is, after all. I don't even know what it would mean for free will to be an "illusion".
Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by somehnacct3757 on Monday June 13, 2022 @02:50PM (#31729881)
There was a good podcast on this recently if you want a deep dive into the philosophy behind the statement.

To give you a jumping off point, 'illusion' has a specific definition in the non-dualist domain so you want to make sure you aren't bringing your own from home. You also smuggle in an 'I' and a 'me' which should be breakpoint-inducing words to mention in a philosophical conversation. The people claiming free will is an illusion have rationally cancelled 'I' out of their statements.

You've basically made the argument against free will in your comment but your definitions are loose so you parse it as an argument for free will.

https://www.samharris.org/podcasts/waking-up-conversations/d...

Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by cillian64 on Monday June 13, 2022 @01:46PM (#31728875)
The idea is that if you’re a bag of chemicals then any decision you make is entirely predetermined based on your current state and the stimulus you receive (potentially modulo some quantum randomness and plenty of chaos). If the decision is totally predictable and predetermined then it stops looking like free will, from a certain point of view. But it’s really just a question of the semantics of “free will”.

Trying to work out whether you could choose differently to your predetermined choice just isn’t a meaningful concept. Imagine you have a deterministic program which returns true or false based on some inputs. If it is modified to return the opposite of what it previously returned, it is no less deterministic.

Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by cecilpl2 on Monday June 13, 2022 @01:57PM (#31729016)
I think it's clearly true that we have internal processes which cause us to take actions.

If those processes are entirely deterministic then that means every action you take is also deterministic - as in, you could not have acted otherwise.

When there are two choices laid out before you, you "choose" one in the same sense that an NPC in a video game chooses its actions: by running a complex set of internal logic.

"Free will" is the notion that you have the freedom to exert your will to choose courses of action. Even though you chose to do A, you could have instead have chosen to do B.

Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by zild3d on Monday June 13, 2022 @02:06PM (#31729128)
It sounds to me like you just explained the "illusion". You're made up of deterministic processes, but it feels like you're making a choice.
Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by mort96 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:11PM (#31747143)
But I am making a choice? I am those deterministic processes. Whatever I decide is my choice. I feel that I am making a choice because I am making a choice, because those deterministic processes which make the choice are all that I am.
Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by zild3d on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @07:09AM (#31751343)
are you actually making a choice, or is it just an output of those deterministic processes? The choice was deterministic.
Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by mort96 on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @12:41PM (#31755609)
The output of those deterministic processes _is_ the choice though? I don't understand how there's any semantically sensible way in which I, as a collection of largely or entirely deterministic processes, can process input and my internal state and reach a choice, where that choice isn't "actually" a choice or isn't "actually" made by me.
Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by Sohcahtoa82 on Monday June 13, 2022 @06:38PM (#31732643)
If you accept that a brain is nothing more than a blob of electrical/chemical circuits that respond to stimuli, then the brain is entirely deterministic.

You think you're deciding things, hence you think you have free will. But all those decisions are based on deterministic circuits, therefore you're not actually in control. Your ability to decide things and act in free will is an illusion.

Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by mort96 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:01PM (#31741365)
But that's the thing, right? Those deterministic processes _are_ me. There is nothing more to me. So I think I'm deciding things because... I am. I am the only thing in control, because the only thing I am is a set of deterministic processes. If my deterministic circuits are making choices, _I_ am making choices.
Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by Sohcahtoa82 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @01:59PM (#31743343)
Then that means you don't have free will. Consciously, you might feel like you do, but it's all deterministic.
Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by mort96 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @03:54PM (#31745146)
But "free will" and "deterministic" just don't seem at odds. It's not just that I "feel" I have free will. It's that I make choices freely, those electrochemical processes are _all there is_. Whenever those electrochemical processes reach a decision, that decision is purely a product of my free will, because those processes are me and I am those processes.
Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by passivate on Monday June 13, 2022 @08:13PM (#31733290)
Wind the clock back to a time when you made a decision. Is it possible for you to make a different decision if you had the exact same mood/context/environment/knowledge and all the sub-atomic particles were exactly identical with the same spin, etc? Current dominant philosophical thought points towards a big NO.
Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by mort96 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @12:09PM (#31741493)
Well current scientific thought says yes because measuring the spin in a particle in a superposition is truly non-deterministic from the perspective of observers, but I don't think that's relevant and I'm happy to think about the brain as an entirely or mostly deterministic thing, so I don't think this is too relevant, but we're not in a clockwork universe.
Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by passivate on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @01:01PM (#31742406)
>Well current scientific thought says yes

Link to evidence?

Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by mort96 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @01:13PM (#31742615)
Well, quantum mechanics describes the universe as a wave function which describes a probability distribution. Most physicists who work on quantum mechanics seem to believe that wave function collapse is a truly nondeterministic process; the only real alternative, from what I understand, is hidden variable theories, which we know imply nonlocality thanks to Bell's theorem.

There's the caveat of Everettian quantum mechanics, where the universe is described exclusively through the wave function which evolves completely deterministically. However, this still causes the observer to experience a measurement outcome as truly nondeterministic; there's just one version of the observer for each measurement outcome.

Here's the Wikipedia article on quantum indeterminacy, which I'm sure you can use as a jumping-off point for further reading: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_indeterminacy

EDIT: Though while this topic is fascinating, I don't think it's extremely relevant to my own thoughts on free will or whatever. I'm perfectly happy to discuss a hypothetical brain which is truly deterministic, and I don't think I would consider a consciousness simulated on a deterministic computer to have any less "free will". The consciousness in the computer would _be_ the circuitry and program. Of course it couldn't make different choices twice given the exact same state and input; it wanted to make the choice it did because of its state and inputs. I don't understand how the choice is any less free just because it's deterministic.

Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by passivate on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @03:47PM (#31745029)
The quantum substrate being non-deterministic doesn't mean that free-will exists/doesn't exist. It has to be shown as such.

What is happening at the quantum level, to the extent that we can understand it, isn't directly translatable into a non-deterministic world at the higher macro level. And so, we do expect and observe a certain level of determinism in our macro scale world. For e.g. A topic relevant to this community - Computing. For the vast vast majority of cases when thousands of people execute the same program on the same or similar hardware at different times in different regions we do expect, and observe the same deterministic result. The outliers to this are primarily due to damage to the processor/equipment, software bugs, or other known factors (including alpha particles/radiation, etc).

Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by mort96 on Tuesday June 14, 2022 @07:25PM (#31747271)
Ah, I see what you're saying. I interpreted what you said to mean that current philosophical thinking is that the universe is deterministic, but you're saying that even though the universe is nondeterministic, the processes in the brain are completely deterministic. This feels like a purely empirical question rather than a philosophical one; I don't know whether there are processes in the brain which depend on quantum measurement outcomes. Though I would be kind of surprised if there's nothing at all; something as simple as putting a polarization filter in front of your eyes would make which exact photons are hitting your retina determined by the outcomes of quantum measurements, which seems to mean you'd be introducing truly nondeterministic noise into the system. But I'm also completely open to the idea that in general, quantum measurements don't affect the processing of the brain or sensory inputs in any way which affects decision-making, if that's what empirical investigation of the matter shows. Whether the brain is deterministic or nondeterministic doesn't really have any impact on the way I think about the concept of free will.
Re:We don't know what makes things sentient–so let's stop ac... by whimsicalism on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:24PM (#31782275)
I think Everettian interpretations are secretly quite popular among physicists because the Copenhagen interpretation doesn't really get you that far. In Everettian QM, the evolution of the entire system remains deterministic.