I think this is a perfectly fine argument because the claim is so outrageous. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence and none has been presented. I'd also say that defining sentience is the job of the person claiming it.
1. Continuity of input: The AI needs to be constantly "on", constantly receiving input of some sort, and constantly able to produce output, rather than being strictly limited to producing discrete responses to discrete stimuli.
2. Continuity of learning: In addition, the AI needs to be continually update its "mental model" of the world—in effect, constantly "learning" and re-training its neural network on the input it receives.
I believe there are likely to be other requirements on top of these, but I am sufficiently learned neither in neuropsychology nor machine-learning/AI to be able to speak (or even reason) with any confidence about them.
If an AI's only input is text, I'm not sure it can meaningfully be conscious, because of the discrete nature of text. Note that I'm not sure it can't—someone may come up with a way to make such a thing work that I haven't imagined—but I think that's an important part of why I doubt the fundamental ability of current-gen AIs to come close to the threshold for consciousness.
What would it take for them to agree that a given program is sentient? From what I can see, most of it is "it would have to not be a program".
I see a lot of "it's not sentient, it just synthesizes responses from tons of learned human chats", but what if that's what humans do as well? I don't know that I'm not just a maximum-likelihood-response synthesizer!