Re:When Commenting Systems Go Bad
by terryjsmith on Friday October 28, 2011 @09:24AM
(#3168118)
There is quite a bit of flexibility that the author seems to have missed. But speaking as someone who has just recently tried Disqus on a major blog for work where a number of the comments are anonymous, the simple fact that the button is ambiguous ("Login as...") did dramatically drop the number of comments. I suspect this is largely due to the fact that most visitors are one-time visitors, not regular users of our blog, but I don't have any data to back up that assumption yet.
And how do you build a community with a bunch of anonymous users?
You give them a field lableled "Name" they can type something into when they leave a comment. Now they are not anonymous.
Re:When Commenting Systems Go Bad
by damncabbage on Friday October 28, 2011 @09:56AM
(#3168245)
I agree with all of your points except for #3.
I think the "principle of least surprise" rather than the "principle of expecting-the-user-to-remember-how-to-use-THIS-particular-commenting-system" applies here.
My biggest question in response to your points is why the administrator (and not the users) is given the power to set these options. Maybe its much easier from a technical implementation sense? I can't imagine that administrators are more concerned with dictating how their readers see the comments than getting users happy and actually commenting.
Re:When Commenting Systems Go Bad
by jamesgeck0 on Friday October 28, 2011 @09:24AM
(#3168115)
Issue 3 sounds like a glitch. I've written comments while logged out and been able to log in without loosing them. I use a Disqus account and not a Google account to log in, though.
Re:When Commenting Systems Go Bad
by alexchamberlain on Friday October 28, 2011 @09:24AM
(#3168114)
There is no such thing as user error.
Re:When Commenting Systems Go Bad
by mattdeboard on Friday October 28, 2011 @09:28AM
(#3168134)
Spoken like a true "biz dev" guy.
Re:When Commenting Systems Go Bad
by fredBuddemeyer on Friday October 28, 2011 @09:42AM
(#3168185)
what does respect for the user have to do with biz dev? if you want to connect with another system (human or machine) you accomodate it.
Re:When Commenting Systems Go Bad
by mattdeboard on Saturday October 29, 2011 @12:20AM
(#3171105)
There is such a thing as user error. Don't be ridiculous.
1. "Comment display is broken". That's a matter of opinion. I personally prefer threaded comments as I find it easier to see the structure of a conversation that way. HN and (sorry) reddit use threaded comments, and I'd consider their comment systems among the best on the Web. Youtube, on the other hand, goes for "flat" comments, and, well, have you ever tried to follow a conversation on there?
Either way, Disqus actually gives the site's administrator the option: http://whatever.disqus.com/admin/settings/appearance/. The author is right though, having the ability to switch between the two on the front-end would be super.
2. "Comment paging is broken". Completely agreed on the 900+ comments on pages of 10. However Disqus gives the administrator the option to separate comments into pages or keep them all on one page. I personally don't get hundreds of comments, so I keep pagination turned off.
3. "Login kills comments". Sounds annoying, but honestly that sounds like user error. Disqus does say "Post as..." when you're logged out, which I guess is KIND OF ambiguous, but surely it's the user's responsibility to make sure they're logged in under the correct account if that's what they want?
4. "Newest first is weird". Why? I prefer it. Again, personal preference. And again, Disqus gives the site administrator options for sorting.
I don't want to sound negative, but I can't help but feel this post was ill-thought-out and badly researched. The sites the author is speaking about have apparently just switched to Disqus, so I'm going to assume the administrators haven't got to grips with how the service works yet.
Finally: I just realised that I sound like a PR stooge for Disqus. I'm just a user, honestly.