Re:Colombia shares unprecedented images of treasure-laden wreck
by yesenadam on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:12PM
(#31676130)
I know, right - "Spain insists that the bounty is theirs since it was aboard a Spanish ship" - I couldn't believe that! Like if you catch someone stealing stuff from your house and loading it into a truck, and they say "It's mine because it's it my truck". Not just saying it, but insisting on it in court. Shameful.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Colombia shares unprecedented images of treasure-laden wreck
by frozenlettuce on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:25PM
(#31676229)
It's interesting because because former colonial powers argue that they acted by the moral standards of that time - and thus can't be judged today for that. And on the first opportunity they demonstrate that we didn't improved much as a species.
Re:Colombia shares unprecedented images of treasure-laden wreck
by adastra22 on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:28PM
(#31676253)
That is absolutely standard legal practice though. Laws generally aren’t retroactive for good reason.
Re:Colombia shares unprecedented images of treasure-laden wreck
by FpUser on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:11PM
(#31676508)
I understand non retroactive part. But claiming stolen gold now - I do not think it should ever be legal. On top of that it is simple disgusting. Really shows what their values are. Enlightened society my ass. They should be shown middle finger.
Re:Colombia shares unprecedented images of treasure-laden wreck
by adastra22 on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @11:08PM
(#31677192)
It was never stolen though. Wars of conquest and slavery were perfectly legal under international law at the time.
I agree it’s a dick move by Spain and really tarnishes their reputation today. But that’s not a legal argument.
Re:Colombia shares unprecedented images of treasure-laden wreck
by happy_path on Thursday June 09, 2022 @03:15AM
(#31678397)
Another example: Is UK going to pay reparations to its old colonies? Don't think so.
Re:Colombia shares unprecedented images of treasure-laden wreck
by seoaeu on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @10:32PM
(#31677018)
I think the claim is that back then the law was “finders keepers” so it shouldn’t retroactively be called theft. Personally I don’t find that argument very compelling.
Re:Colombia shares unprecedented images of treasure-laden wreck
by ajmurmann on Thursday June 09, 2022 @01:22AM
(#31677820)
Whose moral standards at the time? Seems like there was no agreement between indigenous South Americans' government and Spanish invaders at the time either.
Re:Colombia shares unprecedented images of treasure-laden wreck
by AlotOfReading on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @10:05PM
(#31676839)
More specifically, the Brussels convention that underlies modern marine salvage law carves out military ships as exempt from salvage rules. Spain insists on being tone deaf and maintains that their treasure ships were in fact military vessels and that the cargo is therefore still the property of Spain.
Re:Colombia shares unprecedented images of treasure-laden wreck
by happy_path on Thursday June 09, 2022 @10:37AM
(#31681725)
Is the US government going to return their lands to Native American peoples?