News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by davzie on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:02AM (#31666025)
Probably the only country that is being honest about its inflation amount then.
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by toxik on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:11AM (#31666113)
Do you mean to say that other European countries are lying? This proposition seems knee jerk.

Inflation can be computed by anyone, so I don’t even understand how you could lie about it.

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by davzie on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:15AM (#31666144)
We have 9% inflation in the UK but the reality of the costs of things that you need to live a relatively simple life (food, heating oil, fuel costs), have all gone up way more than 9%. A shop that used to cost me £80 a week now cannot be had for under £110. So you can calculate them all you like and look at the data, but the reality in my life is that prices have risen way beyond the 9% we're told is the amount.
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by toxik on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:18AM (#31666168)
That is completely normal, though. Inflation is not the exact price adjustment of every basket of goods over time, that is simply not possible to represent in a single number - rather, it is some arbitrarily chosen basket of goods meant to represent an average household.

It does not have to be perfect to be meaningful.

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by ls15 on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:19AM (#31666878)
> It does not have to be perfect to be meaningful.

It is deceptive though, if this number is not representative of people's actual cost of living and it is then used to adjust their income for inflation. How clear is it that this basket really represents an average household (today)?

Employer: "What do you mean, cost of living has gone up by 14%? Official inflation is 7%, but the best I can do this year is 3.5%."

Politician: "Inflation is X every year, so we increase pensions by X% every three years."

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by anonymousDan on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:27AM (#31666258)
The problem is it is not necessarily arbitrary - governments can pick a basket that masks inflation in areas that it wouldn't suit their agenda to highlight.
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by pessimizer on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:49AM (#31666489)
"Arbitrary" means "picked." It doesn't mean "random" (although you certainly can pick things randomly.) The alternative to arbitrary choice is systematic choice i.e. having a set of specific meaningful criteria that determine something.

So I agree with you, but the problem is that it is arbitrary, and the arbiters could be rigging the outcome with their choices.

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by yuropeen on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:21AM (#31666195)
> That is completely normal, though.

If not using basics like food, fuel, and pricing on rent or mortgage - what are we basing the numbers off of? If it's the stable price of a Spotify subscription, rather than real goods needed to survive, something is horribly off.

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by em500 on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:02AM (#31666646)
The basket and weights for UK CPI are here: https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/inflationandpriceindices/arti...

and for the US: https://www.bls.gov/cpi/tables/relative-importance/home.htm

The weights are based on estimates of how consumers actually spend on different goods and services, rather than on how much someone would need to spend for subsistence or survival.

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by toxik on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:25AM (#31666239)
That is exactly what inflation is computed from. Like literally.
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by gambiting on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:37AM (#31666365)
Then how can it be only 9%? My gas price has increased by 200% in the last few months. In August, my electricity is going up 400%. Petrol alone has gone up by about 50% compared to few months back.

Sure bread is still roughly the same as it was. But living costs have absolutely exploded recently, and far far beyond the 9% indicated.

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by gruez on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:56AM (#31666564)
>My gas price has increased by 200% in the last few months

That seems... unlikely.

https://www.globalpetrolprices.com/United-Kingdom/gasoline_p...

At best it doubled, but that's not the same as "increased by 200%", which implies it tripled.

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by gambiting on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:57AM (#31666583)
I was paying 3p/kWh of gas, now I'm paying 9p/kWh. Also I understand the confusion, but "gas" in UK means heating gas, gasoline is called petrol.
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by fleddr on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:44AM (#31667242)
If you have relatively stable expenses, you can calculate your own inflation just by comparing year to year.

Historically for me real inflation is the formal EU number + 2%. So that means that they're usually about a 100% off as inflation has been low for a long time, until now.

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by rwmj on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:44AM (#31666427)
You can calculate your personal inflation rate although you need to start by tracking your expenditures: https://monevator.com/personal-inflation-rate/
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by nerdponx on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:52AM (#31666517)
Because headline inflation is not equivalent to "% change in cost of living", and the media should stop reporting it as such.
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by Grimburger on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:04AM (#31666674)
I can agree with this but basket substitution is the dirty little secret of economists.

If the cost of meat goes up so much that everyone starts eating dog food, the inflation print will barely rise at all.

It's not a real measure for QoL which I hope most people would accept as being what societies actually strive for.

In fact most measures like GDP and a few others have no real bearing on increased living standards. GDP per capita should be the only real number when talking about economic growth for starters. Even then catastrophes like natural disasters and war bump up those numbers due to rebuilding so it's still quite a rough metric to report on each year.

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by em500 on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:32AM (#31667072)
It's not much of a secret when even in high school economics class I was taught about different substitution methods (Paasche, Laspeyres[1]) with various drawbacks.

It's done because factually consumers buy different and producers produce different things over the years, and it's hard to impossible to observe/measure which substitutions are by necessity and which by preference.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_index#Paasche_and_Laspey...

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by Grimburger on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:58AM (#31667444)
The average person in society doesn't have the knowledge of a high school economics student though. Even those that learnt eventually forget it.

There's always an implicit older == smarter bias in society but I doubt many people who passed with good grades in high school economics are good at the basic concepts into their 30's.

Not to mention the MMT experiments that have been undertaken in the west over the last few years. I'm not even sure MMT proponents understand the consequences of such things. There's been a lot of resource misallocation that no one seems able to take responsibility for.

GDP, inflation, interest rates, etc are oft considered the main KPI's for politicians by the people who vote for them. It's a dismal science even for those well versed in its ways.

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by em500 on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @10:12AM (#31667633)
I mostly agree (except for the weird MMT stuff). OTOH, I believe governments and schools at least in my country have made a good faith effort to try to educate kids widely about these matters.

But most kids and adults alike probably find textbook economics and statistics as appealing as unsweetened oatmeal, and strongly prefer to consume sensationalized headlines and conspiracy theories. There's some tension between free choice and paternalistically nudging/forcing the population towards healthier stuff, that I wouldn't know how to resolve.

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by nerdponx on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:50AM (#31666499)
The point that you are either dismissing or missing is that headline inflation tends to include products that have extremely sticky prices, and tends to exclude products with prices that fluctuate freely. Therefore, headline inflation tends to be a poor proxy for change in cost of living, and is at best a lagging indicator.
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by glenngillen on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:23AM (#31666218)
Here’s a post from last year that I thought did a great job of illustrating your point, and how misleading the reporting of a single inflation number is without also knowing the variance: https://economicsfromthetopdown.com/2021/11/24/the-truth-abo...
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by davzie on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:41AM (#31666401)
A great read thanks!
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by rawbot on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:17AM (#31666154)
Same here in Germany. My napkin calculations on food & groceries is at least 30%.
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by maratc on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:22AM (#31666207)
Inflation is only computed by some central statistics office. The state debt obligations are bound to inflation, so there's a conflict of interest here.
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by tejohnso on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:33AM (#31666322)
I thought it was pretty common knowledge that inflation numbers are deceptive and easily manipulated. It's [controversial].

It's the decline of purchasing power over time based on a basket of goods / services. So it all depends on how you fill that basket.

[controversial]: https://www.investopedia.com/articles/07/consumerpriceindex....

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by panick21_ on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:40AM (#31666391)
That might work for some measures of inflation, but it doesn't work for the 'GDP Deflator' for example. That is a different way to measure inflation (and a more exact one) and it not so easy to fake.

And even if we go with CPI stuff, the agencies that do these things try to stay consistent. At least in western countries they don't just do whatever they want.

The idea that all departments of all western governments are secretly changing the data inputs to achieve some sort of grand conspiracy about inflation number is pretty much delusional thinking.

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by tejohnso on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:55AM (#31666549)
> The idea that all departments of all western governments are secretly changing the data

I don't think they have to do it secretly. They do it in the open, otherwise there wouldn't be an Investopedia article on CPI controversy that clearly indicates a few problems. There's no internal whistle blowing going on. It's in the open.

> And even if we go with CPI stuff, the agencies that do these things try to stay consistent.

Sure, perhaps they "try", but:

"Over the years, the methodology used to calculate the CPI has undergone numerous revisions".

"Some critics view the methodological changes and the switch from a cost of goods index (COGI) to a cost of living index (COLI) as a purposeful manipulation that allows the U.S. government to report a lower CPI."

My personal problem with CPI is that it doesn't include the cost of purchasing a home. I get it...it's not a "consumer good" or whatever. But if you're talking about inflation, and everyone jumps to CPI for that, then CPI should include it, or maybe the media should stop quoting it so much. It's not representative of what people want it to be. People want a way to quantify how much harder it is to establish a good life with their earnings. And I don't think the government is being honest about that. Maybe it's too much to ask.

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by panick21_ on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @02:43PM (#31672148)
> They do it in the open

Then please point me at the methodological changes done by these government in the last 1-2 years that were specifically designed to hide higher inflation.

> "Some critics view the methodological changes and the switch from a cost of goods index (COGI) to a cost of living index (COLI) as a purposeful manipulation that allows the U.S. government to report a lower CPI."

Can this pattern be shown to always lower CPI and can they show that all western governments have enacted the same changes?

And such a methodology would maybe work over a long time-span, it could not be used to hide 1 years high inflation.

CPI is just a dumb and useless measure all together. It really should have no relevance to economic discussion. For macro economic analysis of any kind, the GDP deflator is to be preferred.

> People want a way to quantify how much harder it is to establish a good life with their earnings.

That is a wrong way of thinking about any inflation measure.

> And I don't think the government is being honest about that. Maybe it's too much to ask.

Not sure what honest means here. I don't think the government states anywhere that CPI is some magical measure of 'how easy it is to establishing a good life'.

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by pessimizer on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:04AM (#31666664)
No, the idea that administrations game the numbers to support their previous actions and future proposals is a given. Diagnosing people as mentally ill because they understand this is scary.

The real problem is this class of claim:

There are secret statistics that support my reaction, which would without those statistics be obviously irrational. I do not have access to these statistics, because their existence is being intentionally hidden from me, but from my trips to the grocery store and discussions in the breakroom, I know what they are intuitively, with a fairly high precision. I have been confirmed correct by some people I've met on the internet who are saying the same thing.

If you felt this way, and could find enough people who also think this is true, you should be able to do a survey on your own, more representative basket of goods, and come up with a number that you find more meaningful. If you couldn't, you could at least attack the current basket of goods and methodology with specific criticisms, rather than vaguely plausible FUD. Instead, vaguely plausible FUD rules, because statistics that are not being offered are unfalsifiable.

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by panick21_ on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @02:37PM (#31672057)
A basket of goods is only relevant if you can compare it to historical data, otherwise its pointless. And if you start now you can't select your basket of goods and project it back.
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by aseembehl on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:18AM (#31666169)
There is a lot of play room in computing inflation numbers. For example, there are assumptions based on which input variables are smoothed out to reduce noise.
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by throw457 on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:13AM (#31666127)
Because he wants it to be. It’s way easier to blame someone acting nefarious than living in reality.
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by yuropeen on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:17AM (#31666156)
> Inflation can be computed by anyone, so I don’t even understand how you could lie about it.

Lies, Damned Lies and Statistics

Choose carefully and cherry-pick how you source your input numbers, as garbage in means garbage out.

Then let friendly media spokepersons help your PR quest by stating the numbers as if handed down by God himself. Then let peons on the internet call you conspiratorial.

All in all, we shan't worry - these numbers are all simply transitory :)

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by toxik on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:21AM (#31666192)
Basic econometrics is now useless under the parole of “lies, damn lies”. Good stuff.

How about you propose a different metric then, that surely will be infallible and completely fair to everyone.

[dead]
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by npteljes on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:16AM (#31666842)
"You know" will not do its job, when you're dealing with complex systems. (Or, in my opinion, at any part of life.) You know why don't the web developers just put on the button on the website? You know just a normal button. And it just needs to work normally.

On the other hand, I understand the disillusion and the distrust in the establishment, and in experts. People appoint themselves as experts all the time, and put down others by implying that the other don't understand the thing.

In case of the current inflation, I don't think that this is what's happening. The source of distrust, I think, is the basic understanding of the metric itself, and the implications drawn from it. For example, that one's monthly spending should be the same amount higher as the inflation. In this regard, inflation is meaningless, at most it's a rule of thumb of sorts.

Politicians, of course, will lie to you, and they'll be using anything, including numbers, to back it up. But that still doesn't mean that the method to calculate inflation is meaningless. For one, you can do it for yourself - which is of course hard, because I don't imagine you have historical data for prices of a bunch of products. But for example, if you're willing to trust another source, premium users of Numbeo can get a bunch of historical data, from which you could calculate inflation to your liking, including the products/services you actually buy and use.

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by mytherin on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:09AM (#31666735)
> Food, Fuel, Housing - You know, the basics.

So, exactly what the HICP contains then [1]?

[1] https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php...

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by throwaway4good on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:30AM (#31666289)
The source is eurostat which is an EU institution. But yes. I too think the numbers are correct and largely representative of what is going on.
Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by arlort on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:34AM (#31667100)
I don't think other countries are lying

But eurostat depends on data being provided by national statistics agencies, so it wouldn't really show

Re:Estonia clocks fastest inflation in the Eurozone at 20.1 ... by whazor on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @11:08AM (#31668461)
Estonia is quite good with technology, maybe they have better inflation measurement techniques?