News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by OskarS on Friday June 03, 2022 @05:39AM (#31606162)
Excellent news! The energy consumption required by proof-of-work blockchains is simply unacceptible, and it’s perfectly appropriate to adress it using new laws. Hopefully other states and countries will follow suit.
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by cft on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:04AM (#31606740)
The ongoing fiat dollar experiment, initially to finance the Vietnam war is unacceptable to me. The resulting impending unraveling of USD as the world reserve currency might be unacceptable to you.

Money and government should be separated, otherwise it provides the government with wrong incentives.

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by yossarian1408 on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:25AM (#31606885)
100% this. I wonder if people consider the carbon footprint of maintaining petrodollar hegemony.

But they will lose that hegemony. It happened to the denarii, it will happen to the dollar. The question is - what would be best suited to replace it? Our contenders are the Euro, the Yuen or Bitcoin.

Seems an obvious choice.

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by chrischattin on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:28AM (#31606515)
Washing machines alone across the U.S. use more electricity than the entire Bitcoin network, just to put things in perspective.
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by Kbelicius on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:55AM (#31606691)
Maybe today. PoW is akin to a paper clip maximizer. The more value the network holds the more energy it needs to use. The cheaper the energy gets the more of it needs to use. So why not jut nip it in the bud?
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by OskarS on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:07AM (#31606764)
Washing machines wash clothes, they provide value to the world. And they are subject to plenty of government regulation.
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by yossarian1408 on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:26AM (#31606899)
The petrodollar might be valuable to the US, it certainly isn't doing the world any favours.
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by gchamonlive on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:30AM (#31606524)
Yet clothes can't be washed by using proof of stake methods
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by troorl on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:41AM (#31606596)
They can be washed by hands, like billions of people still do in the 3rd world. But that's a sacrifice most western environmentally-conscious folks aren't willing to make.
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by gchamonlive on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:07AM (#31606759)
Hand washing clothes is a regression, specially considering industrial applications, whereas proof of stake is in many ways a progress in the way consensus is reached for blockchains.

Being environmentally-conscious is about reducing carbon footprint with smarter processes, not reverting to older ways for the sake of cutting electricity consumption. That was an unfortunate fallacy.

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by DavidSJ on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:33AM (#31606543)
Do you have a source for this?
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by mcfedr on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:31AM (#31606533)
But they provide value, in a way mining does not
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by chrischattin on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:35AM (#31606560)
That is entirely your subjective opinion. I think the exact opposite – that Bitcoin is one of the most positive for humanity, world changing inventions ever created.
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by alkonaut on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:52AM (#31606665)
potentially. Any day now. Just over the horizon. Just like last year.
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by troorl on Friday June 03, 2022 @05:44AM (#31606209)
Acceptable to me. Such bills on the other hand seem perfectly inappropriate to me.
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by malermeister on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:08AM (#31606385)
Could you please elaborate the advantages of pow crypto mining that outweigh the environmental concerns associated with it?

Please cite specific, real-world examples if possible, not vague ideas and promises that haven't come to fruition yet.

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by troorl on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:22AM (#31606472)
I deem the fiat standard responsible for countless wars and atrocities that have occurred in the past 100 years. The environmental issues that come from mining seem so minor and insignificant in the long run that all the aggression that is justified by them prevents me from taking such attacks seriously. Every year humanity develops better solar panels, leverages geothermal energy more efficiently, improves the fission NPPs and comes closer to designing fusion reactors. It's only a matter of time before we enter the age of cheap, green and almost limitless energy.

I think it's a question of mentality. Some people bet on human ingenuity, and some are willing to halt the progress completely because it hurts "mother earth" in their imagination.

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by vesinisa on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:54AM (#31606681)
The environmental impact of Bitcoin is not any less real than the power consumption & CO2 emissions of an entire country.[1] Since limitless energy is obviously not yet here (and is very unlikely to become a reality in the short term), it is irresponsible to dismiss these concerns.

After fourteen years of running this experiment, Bitcoin (and other cryptocurrencies) have not yet delivered a single real world application that would be beneficial to the society at large - as far as I know.

I can't help wondering if some of the advocates, who continue to defend these technologies, own themselves cryptocurrencies and have a personal profit motive in glorifying/hyping the technology - for example by hinting that cryptocurrencies would have solved "countless wars and atrocities of the past 100 years".

[1]: https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption/

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by malermeister on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:31AM (#31606526)
So basically it's a purely ideological pitch? I'm sorry, but I'd rather spend our limited resources on practical progress that benefits people.

If we do end up in the "age of cheap, green and almost limitless energy", we can use some for crypto, why not. But we're not there yet and I'd rather not put the cart before the horse, given how important an issue energy and climate are.

Your way of accusing sceptics of being in the way of "progress" recalls the promises of soviet planners or various cults. Beware of vague salvation promises in the future - utopian fantasies usually have dystopian outcomes.

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by troorl on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:39AM (#31606585)
I don't consider it an ideological pitch, but who am I to characterise my own words?
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by actually_a_dog on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:43AM (#31606605)
You haven't offered any objective evidence that your viewpoint is correct, which ipso facto implies it's a purely ideologically based statement. To paraphrase an old expression, "you can 'deem' in one hand and shit in the other and see which one fills up first."

Your tone is also similar to that of the stereotypical 14-year old "libertarian/ancap" living in their parents' basement, and your only other comment on this site outside this thread is one from over 6 years ago accusing the Washington Post of publishing fake news. This doesn't affect the truth or validity of what you say, but it doesn't help, either.

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by DonHopkins on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:41AM (#31606988)
Yes, I was getting a distinct "parents' basement" libertarian larva vibe from his tone and lack of evidence too. I wonder if he knows the price of a bar of soap, or cares about externalities or anyone but himself.

It also doesn't help his case that the Levenshtein Distance from "troorl" to "troll" is only 2.

https://planetcalc.com/1721/

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31401754

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kv_-KOdM6Wk

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by DonHopkins on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:35AM (#31606950)
>It's only a matter of time before we enter the age of cheap, green and almost limitless energy.

If it's coming so soon, then how about you immediately stop burning coal and shilling ugly ape jpegs for a while, until all your utopian libertarian promises are finally fulfilled and free of unintended consequences.

But until such a time, just put a lid on it, m'kay?

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by Beltiras on Friday June 03, 2022 @08:36AM (#31607388)
None of what you mention strictly demands POW blockchains. Is the nature of money changing? Perhaps. Does it need POW to change? No.
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by cortic on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:21AM (#31606464)
There really aren't any environmental concerns with crypto. Crypto (PoW), like any other industry, invests in energy infrastructure. The concern right now is that its sometimes cheaper to pollute than to use green energy. All our politicians have had plenty time to ensure this is not the case; We should be more than angry that they have failed.

If we establish, through regulations, subsidies and taxes, a situation where it is always cheaper to use green energy; Crypto would bring nothing but massive investment in green energy development.

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by malermeister on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:33AM (#31606546)
If we accept that energy is a limited resource, we have to think about how we allocate it. PoW Crypto takes up a lot - what does it give us to justify that expense?

Even if we get to a point where we can power crypto purely with green energy - that might still mean that not enough green energy is available to power other, potentially more important use cases.

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by cortic on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:12AM (#31606791)
I don't accept that energy is a limited resource, like all other resources it requires investment. Reduce investment and you get less of that resource. Increase investment and you get more of that resource at a cheaper rate (as mass production kicks in at different levels). Crypto, and any other popular industry; Invest in the cheapest energy available, growing that market while profiting from it. Its OUR job (democratically) to ensure that green energy is the cheapest energy available...

There is really no other way to fix this.

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by malermeister on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:34AM (#31606947)
There's a limited amount of fossil fuels available.

There's limited amount of space for solar panels, wind turbines and hydroelectric power plants.

Even if we were to achieve fusion, we'd be limited by e = mc^2, where m is limited within a radius that is reachable without losing energy on transport.

You can't fix a physics problem with market ideology.

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by cortic on Friday June 03, 2022 @08:42AM (#31607440)
If the limit is unreachable except in our imagination, we can think of it as unlimited. At least for the purposes of policy right now.

And i think you are being unfair conflating the current energy shortage with a hard limit that the human race may never reach. The current energy shortage might have been averted if the investment from industries like crypto, was invested in renewables..

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by plebianRube on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:17AM (#31606830)
Energy is not a pie. Producers overproduce energy in order to meet peak demand. Most grid mining uses off peak energy, since the utility would rather sell it cheaper than not have anyone buy it at all.

Off grid mining finds stranded energy which stops methane being flared directly into the atmosphere and converts most of it to CO2, which is factually better than any amount of CH4 being released.

By making stranded energy viable PoW actually allows green energy production to be built where existing demand cannot make it economically viable.

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by eis on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:13AM (#31606411)
You should probably specifically mention PoW and not crypto mining in general. There are crypto mining mechanisms like PoS which use a negligible amount of energy.
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by tromp on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:17AM (#31606436)
The term mining is only used for PoW. For PoS the term staking is used.
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by malermeister on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:15AM (#31606426)
Fair point, edited.
[dead]
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by troorl on Friday June 03, 2022 @05:56AM (#31606293)
Yes, I openly dismiss your petty and uncalled for attacks on me and the PoW blockchains entirely.
Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by karamanolev on Friday June 03, 2022 @06:07AM (#31606382)
Petty - I don't think so. They're based on legitimate health and well being concerns. You're free to destroy your health/future, but not mine. Whether they're right or not (and I think they are) is irrelevant. They're not petty.

Uncalled for - the context here (the bill) is about banning certain things related to mining on PoW blockchains for environmental reasons. Comments to ban PoW blockchains entirely for the same reasons is called for. Again, this is irrespective of the commenter's correctness.

Re:Senate Bill S6486D Establishes a moratorium on cryptocurr... by JumpCrisscross on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:40AM (#31606980)
> I openly dismiss your petty and uncalled for attacks on me and the PoW blockchains entirely

I was involved with this bill. It’s being replicated in a few other state houses.

I was on the fence, initially. (I am by default sceptical of regulation.) But the mean argument against was more or less the above. Dismissal without evidence or even attempt at argument.

Hence the 2-year term. If nobody can make an actual argument in that time, the moratorium should expand to all power generation (you can do whatever you want after the meter, this targets behind-the-meter deals) indefinitely.