News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SPACs are warning they may go bust by bee_rider on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @08:26PM (#31576579)
Often these 'novel investment opportunities' at least have some pretense for what their purpose is (like my gut doesn't believe high frequency trading is good for society, but folks more educated in economics seem to think it adds liquidity and is actually useful, so whatever I'll defer to them). I'd be curious to know what the good-faith reason for SPACs is (even if it is a lampshading reason).

They seem to be a straightforward attempt to circumvent regulations. The justification I see from basic googling is that the IPO process is biased in favor of big players somehow, and that SPACs are more open to retail investors... but if that is the case -- Why are IPOs apparently so hard for the little guy to get in on? Is it possible that IPOs are actually high risk investments and regulators are trying to shield retail investors from them? Or something else? It is possible I'm missing the point completely, I'm admittedly not sophisticated on this front.

Re:SPACs are warning they may go bust by nfriedly on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @09:46PM (#31577123)
A SPAC (especially when combined with a PIPE [Private Investment in Public Equity], as they usually are), offers the business more certainty about the amount of money they're going to get. The business can negotiate ahead of time and then either accept or reject the deal. (The amount of money is more or less fixed, but the business can negotiate how much of itself it sells for that fixed amount of money.)

In a traditional IPO, there is a set number of shares to sell. The bank suggests a price range, then gets orders from investors for how many shares they'll buy at different prices, adjusting the range as they go, if necessary. Then the bank picks a price that will sell all of the shares. The business doesn't really have a lot of say in the amount of money they end up raising.

Additionally, there is some theory that a SPAC merger can offer projections of future business without opening themselves to liability if the projections don't come true. Whereas that's very clearly not the case with an IPO. Pre-revenue business in particular like that about SPACs. The SEC seems to be against that interpretation of the law, though.

The other thing about a SPAC is that it brings in additional management that, presumably, have more experience with public markets. Some businesses see that as a benefit.

The major downside of a SPAC, from the busines's perspective, is that the SPAC sponsor takes a huge cut of the proceeds. That is, of course, a big upside for the sponsor, and probably the main reason we've seen so many SPACs crop up recently.

Re:SPACs are warning they may go bust by bee_rider on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @04:20PM (#31587498)
I appreciate the comment, especially given that the general environment is pretty hostile to SPACs.

This answers the question of why a company might want to use a SPAC for something other than, basically, evasion of regulations/reporting (which seems to be the main theory here). Is there any reason to think they might be good for the market in general (other than, sort of, 'what is good for businesses is good for the market' type thinking? (this is why I brought up the HFT example)).

Re:SPACs are warning they may go bust by nfriedly on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @04:33PM (#31587693)
Oh, yeah. The "good for the little guy" argument is that essentially anyone can buy into a SPAC before the merger goes through, whereas with an IPO, the bank only takes orders from big investors. Little guys have to then buy from one of those big investors, usually at higher price.

SPACs typically trade at around $10 per share before the merger is announced, and most PIPE deals get the same price. So everyone is on equal footing at the start.

After the merger is announced, the share price tends to rise, so little guys that get in late pay more. But they at least had the opportunity to go in at the same price as the big investors.

So, from that perspective, it is more egalitarian.

Re:SPACs are warning they may go bust by tsunamifury on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @09:22PM (#31576963)
SPACs bring new management and/or bundle together multiple existing companies into one large IPO, allowing you to sort of merge/index/change-manage/IPO all at the same time. This theoretically could allow three dying manufacturing firms to become one functioning public firm.

Yea that’s the best I can come up with. Not super believable.

Re:SPACs are warning they may go bust by xmodem on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @09:43AM (#31581698)
Well, many who think HFT provides a genuine service also have a horse in that race, so I'm not sure that it's wrong to go with your gut on that one.
Re:SPACs are warning they may go bust by bee_rider on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @04:02PM (#31587247)
It is definitely possible. I just think it is interesting to see the other side's argument for things that I'm instinctively averse to. A strong, automatic gut reaction can be a nice touch-off point for thinking about our biases.
Re:SPACs are warning they may go bust by xmodem on Thursday June 02, 2022 @10:15AM (#31595175)
Agree 100%.
Re:SPACs are warning they may go bust by jfengel on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @09:41PM (#31577090)
IPOs are hard for the little guy to get in on because they don't have the full market apparatus behind them, so there's too much overhead. They would rather deal with a handful of larger players, who then turn around and play the market. They often get a discount because they're not playing in the IPO frenzy.

It's not fair, but it's more about the systemic bias for the wealthy rather than a decision to exclude people.

Re:SPACs are warning they may go bust by ssharp on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @09:54PM (#31577178)
I think part of the “good-faith” SPAC pitch was that since there is so much VC money now and companies can close huge series D rounds that there is less need to IPO early. Later stage IPOs don’t give the public as much upside as IPOs used to, so SPACs were a way to give earlier stage investment opportunities to the public.