News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by splitrocket on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @05:35PM (#31575244)
The math here is pretty straightforward, however, it doesn't look like all of the components necessary to do the math are available.

1. How long do I "own a solar panel"? Indefinitely?

2. What is the wattage of the solar panel and where is it located? i.e. what wattage will it produce consistently YoY? What power market?

3. What percentage fees does Legends take?

Frankly, #1 is the most important factor here by a long shot.

Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by maerF0x0 on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @05:45PM (#31575343)
gonna pile on here so it's easy for OP to answer.

4. What contracts are in place to maintain the panel, and lease the space? What happens if the building decides to discontinue service. Will the solar panel be delivered to me (at what fee?) will the solar panel be re-placed on top of another building? (at what fee?)

5. are the devices insured against common forms of damage? (wind, hail, acts of humankind)

6. Can we implement at "DRIP" style reinvestment program where our ROI just funnels back into more?

Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by yepnopemaybe on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @06:02PM (#31575479)
These are all great questions - so far we've worked with accredited investors to place $100K+ solar facilities while we've built our product. They are basically beta testers while de get out design, software, payments integrations, etc going.

We answered those questions for accredited, for everyday retail investors it will depend on the solar facility we select and the financial structuring design.

Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by guerrilla on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @06:37PM (#31575772)
I really wanted to take you seriously but that's impossible if you won't answer any fo these simple questions. This is a real bad look that does not inspire confidence.
Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by adenner on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @06:17PM (#31575608)
Great questions, lacking in answers... would you care to share what you expect the answers to be? It is hard to get on board with the number of unanswered questions.
Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by maerF0x0 on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @07:59PM (#31576394)
Never mind my peer's noise. Thanks for helping me understand where you're at. I kinda guessed that this really was a launch testing kind of scenario where you'd check for demand before fully "finishing" the offering. No problem, it's a good idea to do research before sinking your life into something no one wants.

I dont know if you heard of or followed sweater ventures. But this kinda feels like a similar niche, but w/ a solar angle instead of VC .

Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by kingcharles on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @06:21PM (#31575649)
Tell me you don't want to answer the questions without telling me you don't want to answer the questions...
Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by yepnopemaybe on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @07:05PM (#31575980)
Happy to answer any questions. The fact is that financial return will depend on the risk profile - which we will depend on factors like

a) Will the investor take on construction risk b) Will the facility be insured c) Who is the power customer (off taker) how creditworthy are they, and what are the terms? d) Will the financing include tax equity incentives and how will they be distributed.

These questions are all a matter of design and pragmatism. I want the financial design to be as considered as, and will integrated to, the user experience design.

Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by seunosewa on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @07:53AM (#31580574)
Looks like you're not yet ready for retail investors?
Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by anakaine on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @06:48PM (#31575854)
100k+ facilities is a bold claim. Do you mean panels?

How many panels does the average facility have?

Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by yepnopemaybe on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @06:54PM (#31575896)
Sorry, I meant $100K
Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by freemint on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @07:14PM (#31576055)
Ouch.
Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by _eht on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @06:44PM (#31575823)
They even numbered them for you...
Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by dpifke on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @06:01PM (#31575468)
7. Can I re-sell my "panels" (shares in the facility) at a later date if I want out?
Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by yepnopemaybe on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @06:04PM (#31575492)
We hope to eventually operate a secondary market where you could do this. Depends on a few regulatory factors we are still considering. Definitely a priority.
Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by dpifke on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @06:25PM (#31575677)
I'm curious the legal structure of what you're selling here. The terms and conditions on your website[0] seem generic, and don't describe the offering.

You're promoting something you call "shares"[1], which promise to pay a dividend. Regardless of whether or not they can be resold, I assume your counsel has figured out a way that these aren't considered "marketable securities" within the meaning of the Securities Act of 1933, which would trigger all sorts of SEC scrutiny.

I assume you're familiar with the early business model of Prosper Marketplace and their struggles[2] with the SEC over a similar issue.

Does this fall under the Regulation Crowdfunding exception[3] or is there another loophole?

(This is not meant as criticism; I'm genuinely curious. I'm not an expert, and the legal landscape has quite possibly changed since I last researched this issue.)

[0] https://www.legends.solar/legal/terms-and-conditions [1] https://www.legends.solar/learn/actual-ownership [2] https://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin/2008/33-8984.pdf (PDF) [3] https://www.sec.gov/education/smallbusiness/exemptofferings/...

Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by yepnopemaybe on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @06:50PM (#31575872)
We are still structuring our first product - so it will depend, but we have options for all of these questions. From the securities side, we might consider Reg A+ or other crowdfunding regulation. I'd look into the structure Masterworks.io uses to learn more (I've in fact discussed this with their GC).

We've been building our beta with accredited investors under Reg D.

Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by dpifke on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @07:03PM (#31575961)
Interesting, thanks for the answer.

For others (like me) that haven't heard of Masterworks:

Masterworks creates a Delaware LLC issuer (taxed as a partnership) and files an offering of ordinary shares with the United States SEC under Regulation A. Each issuer will use proceeds from the offering to acquire a single work of art and title to the artwork will be contributed to a Cayman Islands segregated portfolio company for the benefit of the issuer. The issuer will have no indebtedness, no other assets and will conduct no operations other than relating to the ownership, maintenance and eventual sale of the artwork. The issuer is administered by Masterworks pursuant to an administrative services agreement that provides that Masterworks pays all ordinary and necessary fees, costs and expenses in exchange for membership interests in the issuer.

(from the FAQ at https://www.masterworks.io/)

The Regulation A amendments from the JOBS Act ("Regulation A+", circa 2015) are indeed more recent than my last look at this, so I can't comment further. The Cayman Islands domicile rubs me the wrong way, but that may be out of ignorance.

Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by wang_li on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @07:56PM (#31576373)
8. If I decide to can I come get my solar panel and take it to my cabin?
Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by yepnopemaybe on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @09:13PM (#31576910)
Great question! We've often contemplated the Vinovest.io model. Vinovest sells fine wine as an investment. Because you own the individual bottles and are entitled, for a fee, to have them sent to your door, they avoid most securities headaches.

I wonder if we could do that for individual panels, particularly given deployment of module level Enphase micro inverters.

Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by Ekaros on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @02:59AM (#31578967)
9. Can I halt the production of my panels in case I want to manipulate the market?
Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by vorpalhex on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @06:09PM (#31575532)
(2) is critically important as well. A panel is going to do differently in Texas than Maine.
Re:Legends Solar – Buy operating solar panels on commercial ... by yepnopemaybe on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @07:11PM (#31576037)
Both Texas and Maine would be unlikely candidates. Maine has some pretty stringent and arbitrary rules about behind-the-meter commercial power arrangements. Texas is possible with commercial facilities, but their regulatory framework is also deterrent, really to any kind of development.

To be honest, in all odds the financial return is more likely to be dependent on factors like who the off-taker is, if the financing includes construction risk, if we are insuring the facility, etc than its physical location.