I can't be the only one who feels like this is simply 'buying votes' in an attempt to try and salvage some seats for the upcoming midterms. And, of course the people with debt want the debt forgiven unilaterally and post-haste, so it makes sense they're clamoring for it. In a democracy, who turns down free money?
The fact of the matter is that these loans are unsustainable. They saddle people with life-long debt that they can never get rid of, dooming them to a life of poverty because of a choice they made when they were young, which everybody at the time told them was the right choice.
That particular debt forgiveness is simply the right thing to do. It will free a lot of people from poverty.
But clearly there are also measures necessary to prevent this from happening again, like a reasonable maximum to how much can be lend.
I would prefer that the change be that loans can be discharged in bankruptcy instead of this one off forgiveness.
That said, I agree with you on bankruptcy being a better idea. From what I understand, these loans are harder if not impossible to get rid of through bankruptcy than other loans, despite being far more crippling.
In general, I'd like a rule that all interest-carrying loans must be able to be eliminated through bankruptcy. Only interest-free loans should be exempt. Also: a cap on student loans to discourage excessive tuition. Tuition is just insane (and where is that money going? I hear plenty of younger professors are struggling too).
My first pass on fixing education is that we should remove the non-discharge of student loan debt. Gen-Z could boycott this system by declaring bankruptcy immediately after graduation which would have relatively minimal affects on their lives relative to the debt and schools would be forced to lower costs
Votes are already bought by wealthy campaign contributors.
Anyway, aren't politicians supposed to help the public financially? If a politician campaigns on tax cuts, tax credits, and tax incentives, isn't that also "buying votes"? Which politician is not buying votes with their stated economic policies?
I’m not an economist but I suspect that in a society with a strong welfare system, universal healthcare, and free higher education then wages wouldn’t have to be as high as they are in the U.S. for certain industries. I don’t claim that student debt forgiveness is the efficacious or even that it should be done. I do claim that it’s best to ‘buy’ votes by creating a society with strong social programs.
It's not a false dichotomy because he's saying the root cause would get worse if student loans were forgiven.
You can argue whether or not that's true, but the claim he's making is not a false dichotomy.
It's actually quite popular: https://www.forbes.com/sites/zackfriedman/2022/04/18/student...
I might support 0% interest rates so I guess that might be considered canceling some student loans for all?
This is a false dichotomy. The root core of the issue should be addressed. However, that would require an act of Congress, whereas federal student loan forgiveness can be accomplished immediately via executive action. This is why people are calling for it now, because it can be done right now. Also, the President promised to do so multiple times during his campaign.
> Universities can charge more, and students can continue to take out larger loans
Universities are already charging more, and students are continuing to take out larger loans despite the lack of forgiveness.