I manage a property in a college town. Most of my tenants are first time renters just moving out of the dorms, so they've never learned these hard lessons before. I try to help them out by telling them about how they can get screwed on deposits, and tell them to take pictures of any damage they find and print it out so I can sign it.
I just hope they take that lesson with them after they leave my place.
Also I remind them that they have a right to a walk through at the end of the lease and never charge an item on a deposit that I haven't discussed with them first. I always give them a chance to fix it first. Usually they just say "bill me" (probably because it's their parents money) but sometimes they will fix it or they will help me fix it. It's a lot more work on my part, but on the flip side I'll have tenants messaging me a decade later thanking me for being honest and kind. So I guess it's all worth it.
I sat in a PMs office in a high rise I was moving out, waiting for them to take care of something.
I noticed my move-out inspection report (which we were ABOUT to do), oddly already filled, some. "Blinds - dirty, needed cleaning", "Carpet - stains not removed, needed cleaning", about half a dozen items which according to their "costs incurred" ate up most of my deposit. Oddly, since I knew they hadn't been in the apartment recently, even without my consent, because I'd been packing and cleaning. I'd even brought with me receipts for the carpet cleaning etc.
PM comes in, grabs some papers and a clipboard from her desk, including the form. "Let's go get started".
"Oh, while I was waiting, I apologize, my eyes must have caught that some of the paperwork on your desk was for us, so I looked over at it, and saw it was already filled out for the inspection?"
Umm, ahh, stammer, stammer. "Oh, how strange. I must have, uhh, photocopied a previous form without realizing it wasn't empty."
Didn't make any sense on any level, but whatever. We started with a new form, and I made sure that none of that BS made its way back on.
Rate the expected value of all insurance services at $0, that's my approach. (I guess you could call that giving up on step zero!) Why bother doing business with people whose profit model consists of taking your money now so they can decline to return it later? The better they are at their jobs, the worse a deal it is for you.
I will continue happily paying my insurance premiums, and ardently hope that I never get any of that money back.
Of course, there may be specific types of insurance/warrantee programs that are a bad idea for one reason or another, but that's not an argument against insurance in general.
A lot of people must give up here. I had a car totaled by a hit-and-run driver and the insurance company wanted me to settle for $10k less than the car was clearly worth. (I had lots of proof of this.) It took a month of me telling the adjuster "I'm not settling" before I got that $10k. It was the most infuriating customer-company relationship encounter I had ever had. I felt like the person was intentionally misunderstanding me and making false statements. I tried to get to their manager a few times, but they wouldn't. It was clear that the person's manager was in complete agreement with the course this situation was taking.
So I asked to see comps. Sure enough, all but one of the comps was in that ballpark, from about 3-4 under, to nearly 30.
Except one. Which was about 140 miles away, and listed for $11,500. Clearly a salvage or rebuild or something (water damage, whatever, obviously not accurate). Dragging the average down like a boat anchor.
"The ad doesn't say Salvage Title so it's a valid comp."
They just kept repeating that like a broken record.
I definitely recognize the "broken record" part of your comment!
What the author did. Take them to arbitration.
If you were an idiot and opted out of arbitration you’ll need to spend a lot of money going through the courts. If you didn’t, you may be able to get representation on a contingency basis.
Remember I read that in a novel as a teenager, and since then I've always complained if I get rejected. Almost always work, as they then finally actually look at your situation. And if it doesn't work, I keep going until they realize making me whole will be less costly than the time I make them spend.
Had to look it up, the novel was "The Rainmaker" by John Grisham.
A bit OT:
But ESPECIALLY the rental market - professional or private - is horrible on this. Before purchasing my home, I had rented 7 different apartments over the years.
No mater how thorough I'd be on washing out apartment, or how careful I'd be with it, they would always find something - and claim deductions on the deposit.
This worked for the first apartment I rented - after that I got wiser, and took pictures of everything before actually moving in. Better yet, with the landlord or representative as witness. Document everything. I even recorded the phone conversation - informing that the conversation would be recorded, and if that was a problem, we'd take everything in writing.
This saved me lots of deposits. Like clockwork, I'd be informed that they found something - sending evidence. I'd reply back with my evidence, and suddenly everything's OK.