I mean, this has been going on for at least 97 years if you include light bulbs:
“The cartel lowered operational costs and worked to standardize the life expectancy of light bulbs at 1,000 hours (down from 2,500 hours), and raised prices without fear of competition, in what has been described as a "classic example of planned obsolescence". The cartel tested their bulbs and fined manufacturers for bulbs that lasted more than 1,000 hours.”
They could have standardized on a power efficiency metric, but there's an intrinsic inverse relationship of efficiency versus lifetime for tungsten filaments.
Back in the day companies did not try to eat every tiny bit of consumer surplus, so this cartel was a win-win situation.
Phoebus being about efficiency was merely a coincidence.
And at this point who really needs "forever"? We're getting to a point where the average person will at most change their lighbulbs 2-3 times in a home (I doubt the vast majority of the population lives in the same place for more than 20-30 years).
Actually:
> Report Highlights. The average length of homeownership is 16 years, with lower-earning and less educated householders more likely to remain in their homes longer.
https://ipropertymanagement.com/research/average-length-of-h...
So maybe 1 lightbulb set change per home...
Why does that seem fundamentally more reasonable to you then each occupant replacing the walls just once?
Replacing walls is super complicated and messy and uncomfortable.
Nothing cynical there: you are simply correct. There's overwhelming evidence that companies profit from selling user's data, engage in planned obsolescence and deploy numerous tricks to disrupt the second hand market.