News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by ck2 on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @12:51PM (#3154757)
Oh this will end well. Nah it will never be abused or have mission creep.

Now the TSA will have a database to use on everyone while they wait in line for a bus, train or plane.

You protested at OWS? No flying for you. Oh you false match a felon? No flying for you either.

I wonder when they will just start grabbing people left and right off the street to do iris scans like the military does to the locals in Iraq and Afghanistan.

Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by antics on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @01:34PM (#3154959)
IMO, that's super myopic. When intelligence agencies do something visible to the American public that causes any sort of discussion, it forces what they are doing (which is usually supposed to be secret) into the spotlight, which makes them generally more accountable. They do not like to do their job with people looking over their shoulder; they typically avoid this wherever possible. Besides that:

* Even on a very good day, the government is demonstrably bad at deploying new technology, especially at scale.

* Especially when that scale involves training any personnel at all.

* Especially when people are wary of that technology anyway.

* Especially when they are deploying suspicious technology in a visible arena.

* Especially when this technology will be observing US persons.

It doesn't look like it from the outside, but there is a lot of politics and bureaucracy in deploying a system like this, not just internally, but also from places like politicians.

In my experience, people who have never been around an organization like the FBI seem to have a naive view of what is possible. My recommendation is to critically evaluate anything that anyone tells you about what goes on in such places.

Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by nextparadigms on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @02:15PM (#3155158)
I think that's being a little too naive. Let's face it. The trend is turning USA into a police state. How isn't that not clear by now? Every other day they add new stuff like this, or breach more privacy or expand TSA in other areas, and so on.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by antics on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @02:27PM (#3155216)
FUD, [edit:] IMHO. [not trying to be a dick.]

The TSA is not an intelligence organization. Its job is not to secretly develop intelligence. It does not have the same problem of needing to not be accountable to the public as, say, the FBI or the NSA.

Second, that claim is a lot stronger than you're pretending it is. If you're going to throw around a term like "police state", you will need a lot more proof than hand-wavy "every day they add new stuff like this". Everything in your argument is attributable to selection bias, and if you're going to level a convincing point, you will need to do more than appeal to the fact that people seem to want to believe this stuff. TBH when you say that, it makes me wonder if you really know what a police state even is.

Third, my point is not that there is no abuse or that the government is incapable of doing bad things, it's that we should be evaluating pie-in-the-sky predictions with actual evidence. "We are becoming a police state, DUH" is not evidence. And neither is the ridiculous claim that tomorrow the OWS people will be barred from flying.

Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by sp332 on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @02:49PM (#3155320)
The TSA maintains a secret watchlist and black list. The fact that this list seems to be arbitrary and disconnected from intelligence agencies doesn't make it better.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by antics on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @02:57PM (#3155366)
I totally agree.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by throwawayday on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @09:27PM (#3156717)
it actually makes it worse: you now have at least 2 agencies you have to watch
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by ck2 on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @03:27PM (#3155492)
TSA operates VIPR which is doing intelligence gathering.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by CamperBob on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @02:57PM (#3155364)
To the extent they are not an intelligence organization, they are not effective, and a waste of funding.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by antics on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @03:11PM (#3155430)
Oh yeah, I totally agree with that. Seeing any of the organizations up close it is obvious that this is true.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by redthrowaway on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @03:39PM (#3155544)
So the revelation that the NSA had been illegally wiretapping hundreds of thousands of Americans led to the NSA being more accountable? As I recall, it was swept under the rug and the blame was placed on the whistleblowers.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by antics on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @04:15PM (#3155688)
That's not really the point, though.

What you're describing is an invisible exercise of power. What I'm saying is, exercising power in a public fashion, particularly when such a display involves technology that people are nervous about to begin with, causes there to be more attention focused at the organization in question. Generally they avoid this because it means they have more oversight. Maybe this opens doors to things like the above, maybe it doesn't.

Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by asolove on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @05:02PM (#3155868)
Yes, just like with backscatter radiation, shoe examinations and 3oz liquids at airports. They generated media heat, but didn't lead to any attention or oversight. Everyone is used to them now, I'm generally the only person in line to request the grope-down.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by mahyarm on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @04:16PM (#3155697)
US Airports don't seem especially bad at deploying xray scanners.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by grout on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @08:40PM (#3156585)
"US persons" is a term of art. Who do you work for?
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by antics on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @03:58AM (#3157586)
I'm a student, and I'm an RA at my University. I don't work for the government in any way, shape, or form, either directly, or via secondary means (like a contractor), if that's what you're asking.

Anyway, that's bad form to ask. :(

Edit: Also, for those not in the know, "US Person" is a legal term that covers not just US citizens, but also legal aliens and citizens of certain countries like the UK that we hold close ties with.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_person

Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by suking on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @01:49PM (#3155042)
Like The Patriot Act? Yah - that hasn't been abused at all - nope.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by esrauch on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @04:37PM (#3155772)
The patriot act hasn't been applied at scale though. It's easy to abuse your power at small scales, it's difficult at large scales just because you are relying on many potentially inept people.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by throwawayday on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @09:28PM (#3156718)
at least until you disarm the populace, then it's 'free play' all day long
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by esrauch on Friday October 28, 2011 @05:47PM (#3170240)
Hm, so you really think that people with hunting rifles are keeping the government in line?
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by throwawayday on Sunday October 30, 2011 @03:02PM (#3175118)
yep, cause so long as they have to worry about an uprising of an armed populace they will at least show a little restraint.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by mc32 on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @01:25PM (#3154914)
Isn't this at least arguably better than broadcasting a suspect's photo over the local news outlets --which is the current way of dealing with this information deficiency?

It's not being used to convict people, it's used to identify a suspect who could end up being found guilty via normal procedure --but this does not bypass that procedure.

Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by slowpoke on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @01:56PM (#3155071)
I'm very sorry, but I heavily object to the notion that we should treat everyone like criminals. It completely invalidates the assumption of innocence, which - as far as I am informed as an European - is part of the Constitution).

Besides, as the grandparent mentioned, the potential for abuse is too high. Especially in the hands of a government who shows clear tendencies towards a police state - which most western ones do, including the US.

Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by anigbrowl on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @02:03PM (#3155100)
I'm very sorry, but I heavily object to the notion that we should treat everyone like criminals.

So do I. Automating facial recognition seems preferable to broadcasting mugshots and perp walks. The technology already abounds in the private sector anyway; if you can take a photo with your phone and have Facebook or Picasa ID and tag the people in it, it's unrealistic to demand that law enforcement abstain from using technology available to teenagers.

Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by slowpoke on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @04:08PM (#3155661)
That's an argumentum ad populum. Just because everyone and their mother uses it is no justification for law enforcement to use it as well - especially considering that these people are (at least in very abstract theory) supposed to be good examples for the general populace. The fact that these technologies are abused to such a degree should be an argument to limit their usage, not further extend it.

>Automating facial recognition seems preferable to broadcasting mugshots and perp walks.

You might know the story of boiling a frog. The fact that you think it's fine is the worst thing about this ordeal. Next thing we know, people will be fine with a totalitarian government for the same reason.

Also, maybe we should consider finding better ways to fight crime instead of fighting criminals, which is, in the long term, pointless. I can never resist to quote Motörhead's March Or Die when it comes to this topic:

  Children weep and widows wail,
  Our education systems fail,
  To hide our guilt we build more jails,
  and we shall build still more
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by tptacek on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @04:31PM (#3155748)
I don't understand this response. 'anigbrowl is saying that everyone's privacy is violated by private facial recognition deployments constantly, and law enforcement's alternatives --- which are already universally accepted by our jurisprudence --- are more invasive.

Sometimes it does make sense to tie law enforcement's hands behind its back. But it doesn't always or even often make that kind of sense. So why exactly in this case do we want to hobble them?

I'm also not sure how much productive conversation there is to be had about what technology law enforcement should get access to when you appear to not believe in the concept of law enforcement at all.

Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by slowpoke on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @04:58PM (#3155850)
> 'anigbrowl is saying that everyone's privacy is violated by private facial recognition deployments constantly, and law enforcement's alternatives --- which are already universally accepted by our jurisprudence --- are more invasive.

And I am saying that instead of allowing law enforcement to use this technologies as well (because hey, everyone is using them), I'm saying we should instead limit everyone else from using it, as well. Especially big corporations like Google and Facebook.

>you appear to not believe in the concept of law enforcement at all.

I never said that. What I've been saying is that law enforcement is merely reactive. It doesn't solve problems, it merely fights the symptoms. The true problems are an entire generation of disillusioned people, a failing society reigned by corporate greed and kept in check by false hopes and dreams (yes, I'm talking about the American one). You have to fight these, not (just) the things they inevitably produce.

Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by anigbrowl on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @05:09PM (#3155895)
That's an argumentum ad populum. Just because everyone and their mother uses it is no justification for law enforcement to use it as well

Yes there is; if private citizens have access routine to technology that law enforcement is barred from using, then you'll have situations where there is photographic evidence of criminality that police are unable to act on (a popular example lately: webcams on laptops being used to ID thieves). If the police can't or won't act on it, while the recognition technology is freely available to web service users, then you're quickly heading for vigilantism and a lack of confidence in law enforcement.

Vigilantism has a poor record in dispensing justice as it has no procedural safeguards or judicial review whatsoever. Historical records show that prior to the establishment of professional police forces, rates of murder and other violent crimes were considerably higher. State-run police forces are what we got after market solutions had failed.

David D Friedman has studied libertarian approaches to law enforcement in some depth, and points out various shortcomings as well as some apparent benefits: http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/England_18thc./Englan...

Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by slowpoke on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @01:55AM (#3157379)
You don't get my argument, it seems. I oppose the carefree usage of this technology as a whole, not just its usage by law enforcement, while you are arguing with a fallacy based on the current situation. This won't lead us anywhere.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by anigbrowl on Wednesday October 26, 2011 @03:46PM (#3160125)
I get it, but you can't put the genie back in the bottle. The face-tagging in my desktop photo-management applications is already insanely good.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by DennisP on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @06:14PM (#3156114)
Broadcasting a suspect's photo is only done when there's a newsworthy story about a crime. Automated face recognition can be done routinely on a much vaster scale.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service by naz on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @03:18PM (#3155454)
So what you are saying is that it is ... a slippery slope?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope