Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service
by sp332 on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @02:49PM
(#3155320)
The TSA maintains a secret watchlist and black list. The fact that this list seems to be arbitrary and disconnected from intelligence agencies doesn't make it better.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service
by antics on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @02:57PM
(#3155366)
I totally agree.
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service
by throwawayday on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @09:27PM
(#3156717)
it actually makes it worse: you now have at least 2 agencies you have to watch
Re:FBI to launch nationwide facial recognition service
by ck2 on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @03:27PM
(#3155492)
TSA operates VIPR which is doing intelligence gathering.
The TSA is not an intelligence organization. Its job is not to secretly develop intelligence. It does not have the same problem of needing to not be accountable to the public as, say, the FBI or the NSA.
Second, that claim is a lot stronger than you're pretending it is. If you're going to throw around a term like "police state", you will need a lot more proof than hand-wavy "every day they add new stuff like this". Everything in your argument is attributable to selection bias, and if you're going to level a convincing point, you will need to do more than appeal to the fact that people seem to want to believe this stuff. TBH when you say that, it makes me wonder if you really know what a police state even is.
Third, my point is not that there is no abuse or that the government is incapable of doing bad things, it's that we should be evaluating pie-in-the-sky predictions with actual evidence. "We are becoming a police state, DUH" is not evidence. And neither is the ridiculous claim that tomorrow the OWS people will be barred from flying.