Re:My students cheated... a lot
by paulpauper on Saturday May 28, 2022 @10:02PM
(#31545582)
when businesses do it, it's called delegation, efficiency, or collaboration, but when students do it, it's called cheating. it's unfair in that sense.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I'm curious what you call it when, say a car company programs their vehicles to notice when they are on an emission test stand and will operate differently to get the best test result possible. Because regulators call it cheating and society as a whole suffers from it.
Re:My students cheated... a lot
by paulpauper on Saturday May 28, 2022 @10:23PM
(#31545697)
maybe the regulation or test is not necessary?
Except society as a whole has deemed it necessary for lots of reasons. Even strict libertarians tend to think one of the better roles of government is to regulate negative externalities.
Re:My students cheated... a lot
by paulpauper on Saturday May 28, 2022 @11:06PM
(#31545948)
has society also deemed it necessary that all undergrads must take anthropology? I was not aware that this was put to a vote.
Depends. If the hiring group has said, for example, you need an ABET degree to be qualified and ABET has said an anthropology course was part of the required curriculum, then yes.
In other words, groups (society and otherwise) have created standardized curriculums for a reason. You may not agree with their decision, but the reasonable response is to remove yourself from consideration, not to lie in order to get the outcome you want.
This has nothing to do with fairness. It has everything to do with integrity. You justifying these actions is part of the problem. This is the attitude that these businesses you are accusing take themselves. "Others are doing it so why shouldn't I?" It is a direct lead to societal decay.
The justification here, is that focusing on individuals does not solve the problem, and instead only helps you feel better about yourself by how evil you think other people are.
Instead of focusing on why you think other people are more evil than you are, instead people should focus on ways to actually solve the problem, instead of satisfying their internal need for moralization.
This is a preposterous comparison of apples to oranges.