ITER is taking ten years because the equipment required for DT operation won't be installed until 2035, after their second maintenance shutdown. SPARC is intended to progress to DT operation as soon as possible after first plasma assuming all the equipment checks out.
He poo-poos tritium breeding, referring to an article he wrote 5 years ago about the faults of a solid blanket, neglecting to mention that the ARC design has been based on a liquid blanket.
If he wants to criticize the MIT/CFS SPARC/ARC design, he should by all means just go ahead and do so, but this lazy approach of his is just plain dumb and tiresome.
Tokamaks work, high temp superconductors work, and the combination is likely to result in working fusion reactors. If it doesn't, then at least we'll know soon enough via these two private companies. It doesn't make sense to write articles heckling companies which have literally put millions of dollars where their mouths are. Just let them get on with the work, and if they fail, they fail, and we learn something.
I've heard from multiple experts now that you may have this backwards. SpaceTime even made a video about it long ago [1]
We will with certainty not get commercially competitive, or even usable, energy from fusion. Any money spent on that prospect is badly misdirected. Support fusion research to direct money to support plasma physicists, or to keep certain exotic-tech military contractors afloat, or to drive superconducting electromagnetics.
Any money spent on it is not at all badly misdirected, it's rather accurately directed, you could say.
Basically it seems like the ICF method is more effective and as an experimental system, uses much less tritium, but using it to drive a power production system (converting heat to electric power) is much more difficult than with the MCF system, if even possible. The MCF system on the other hand seems nowhere near reaching breakeven.