News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reasons to ditch Chrome and use Firefox by rsync on Saturday May 28, 2022 @03:40PM (#31543087)
"FireFox Containers are a killer feature for me ..."

They are a killer idea but their implementation is disappointing.

In no particular order ...

- You can't clear history for a particular container space [1]

- Containers are only tabs - so you can't, for instance, create a window and have all future tabs created in that window inherit that container

- No "private" (or "burner") container that saves nothing outside of each individual tab

No, I am not interested in solving these basic, first-order use-cases with some rando extension from joey75 @ gitlabusercontent.downloads.tv.

[1] https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1170863

Re:Reasons to ditch Chrome and use Firefox by sfink on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @12:23PM (#31584223)
What's the difference between a burner container and a private window (Ctrl+Shift+P)?

I suspect it would be fairly straightforward to make an extension that set a per-window default container, but I agree that it should be built in functionality. (Whether that default should override site-specific container rules, I'm not sure... I kind of want both options, but I guess that's where it starts getting complex.)

I'm annoyed by the lack of integration between container and history. I never really want to clear history for a non-private window, but I do want to be able to restrict what I see by container when it makes sense and not restrict when it doesn't. My main grievance: searching for open tabs (either by prefixing the location bar entry with "% " or by choosing the Open Tabs option from the dropdown that appears when you start entering something) should match across all tabs, at least in the context of a freshly-opened new tab.

https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1479858

Re:Reasons to ditch Chrome and use Firefox by 41b696ef1113 on Saturday May 28, 2022 @10:07PM (#31545608)
The "burner" container is 100% what I want. There are only a handful of sites for which I want to be able to maintain history.
Re:Reasons to ditch Chrome and use Firefox by kaba0 on Sunday May 29, 2022 @10:01AM (#31549187)
I use temporary containers in combination with incognito mode — I often like having history.
Re:Reasons to ditch Chrome and use Firefox by ravenstine on Saturday May 28, 2022 @10:00PM (#31545571)
Though I absolutely agree that the implementation is disappointing, most concerns about history pretty much disappear if you disable history globally. Having lived without history in my browser for years now, I ponder whether that should be the default because I haven't missed it one bit.

> Containers are only tabs - so you can't, for instance, create a window and have all future tabs created in that window inherit that container

True, but if that's something you want, you can do that without the multi-account container tabs. Just create a new profile that's separate from the default one. The drawback to that is you have to reinstall any extensions you use because they won't be shared.

Re:Reasons to ditch Chrome and use Firefox by sfink on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @12:26PM (#31584263)
In my opinion, history access is a major advantage of Firefox over Chrome. There are many sites that I don't bother to bookmark because I know typing a substring into the location bar will bring it up as a suggestion faster than I would be able to choose it from a bookmark menu. Plus, it displays a bunch of related URLs which are surprisingly often useful.

I definitely would not want to default to disabling it. It's my browser, and letting it remember where I've been enables it to be much more useful to me.