If you're hearing thunder now, in a way, you're hearing an event in the past. The farther the thunder traveled, the farther into the past you are experiencing.
Across the expanse of space, you are not just hearing, but seeing into the past. The farther the light traveled, the farther into the past you are experiencing now.
By this logic, I'm the newest thing in the universe, because it takes the shortest time for me to observe myself.
The fact is, simultaneous observations don't necessarily mean simultaneous events. If you hear 2 people shouting at the same time, but one person is very far away and one person is near, you can assume the person farther away actually shouted first. The reason this happens is the different delay across different distances.
The distances have to be much greater to notice the difference with light compared to sound. But compared to the expanse of the universe, light actually travels quite slowly. If the sun disappeared, we wouldn't see it disappear on Earth for 8 minutes (that's how long it takes light to reach Earth). Essentially, we are seeing the Sun as it was 8 minutes in the past.
The effect is even greater outside our solar system and even greater beyond our galaxy. We see stars and galaxies as they were, not just minutes but years and years in the past. Some stars that we see now have certainly already reached the end of their life, exploded into a supernova and collapsed. We just haven't seen it yet. The light from those events haven't reached us yet.
Everything we see is of something as it was in the past. Even though we are seeing all the stars and galaxies simultaneously, the farther away it is, the farther into the past we are observing.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vector_clock
Take a photon starting from your chest and give it t1.
* Assume that the speed of light is symmetrical. *
When the photon hits the next person's eyes, it is t1 + distance/speed of light.
Meaning, the photon is "from the past".
Since all photons arriving are from the past, the photons travelling the shortest distance are the newest (representing the largest timestamp).
So, the thing with the largest observable timestamp is yourself.
The confusion arose because the OP said "you are the oldest thing in the universe you can observe". They should have said "you are the most recent thing in the universe you can observe".