News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by PedroBatista on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:44AM (#31527696)
Since when a company has the option to “recognize” or not a union?

I feel this is one of those questions with a simple answer, but the more you learn the more your sadness increases..

Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by Sakos on Friday May 27, 2022 @07:18AM (#31528241)
To follow on this line of questioning: What are the legal requirements for businesses to accommodate unions comprised of their employees?

There are clear obligations in Germany for how to integrate unions in a business and where/how they're able to influence business processes. How is it in the US?

Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by SpicyLemonZest on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:10AM (#31529842)
In the US, employers are only required to recognize majority unions, which are formed by a majority of employees in what we call a “bargaining unit” and legally granted both the right and obligation to represent everyone in that unit. They can be formed through an election or through what’s happening here, where the company voluntarily recognizes that the union has majority support. Employees are free to form smaller “minority unions” but employers don’t have to talk to that kind of union if they don’t want to.
Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by a_humean on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:49AM (#31527722)
Well given that a union at least initially isn't part of the formal company structures almost by definition then there needs to be some process of recognition that yes this organisation that claims to represent my employees does in fact represent my employees.

That is what those union ballots are about - the union needs evidence that they are representatives of the employees of the company.

A union has to start somewhere. Of course depending upon the legal jurisdiction a company might not have much of a choice if a union meets a legal threshold, and in the case of union action they might not have a choice otherwise than deal with a union.

In this case I doubt MS had a choice, I guess what is notable is that they have not needed to make such a choice before now.

Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by alistairSH on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:25AM (#31530008)
Well given that a union at least initially isn't part of the formal company structures almost by definition then there needs to be some process of recognition that yes this organisation that claims to represent my employees does in fact represent my employees.

But in this case, the union is already established and recognized by the acquired employer. MS (or any other acquiring entity) shouldn’t be allowed to ignore an existing employer-labor relationship. If that were true, any time a company unionized, the stockholders could just continually buy itself with another shell company and terminate the union relationship.

Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by pastacacioepepe on Friday May 27, 2022 @07:08AM (#31528175)
> recognition that yes this organisation that claims to represent my employees does in fact represent my employees.

Uhm, and why should the company have a say in this, when it's the employees that are already telling the company that they are unionized?

Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by chrisseaton on Friday May 27, 2022 @07:25AM (#31528281)
How else do you think the company should determine if it wants to interact with the union or not?

Obviously the company isn’t going to work with literally any union that emails them and says it has a demand, without knowing if the union has anything to back up its demands or not.

If someone came to demand your money and said ‘or else’ you’d ask what the ‘or else’ is, wouldn’t you?

Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by pastacacioepepe on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:53AM (#31529653)
> How else do you think the company should determine if it wants to interact with the union or not?

Pretty simple.

Check how many employees are part of the union. Does the union represent a majority of the workforce or at least a minority but made of important employees? Then you better listen to what they say, or they could go on a strike.

The only way to make companies agree to your demands is to promise them a larger loss if they don't agree.

Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by jcrawfordor on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:57AM (#31529712)
Union elections are how that check is performed. Microsoft appears to be skipping this process though and voluntarily recognizing the union, presumably because they know it would win such an election. This is probably only coming up because as a part of the acquisition process they are terminating and rehiring all the employees, which removes the existing union representation since the old employment relationship no longer exists. This is of course mostly just a paperwork exercise but is common in acquisitions since the acquired is not necessarily legally taking control of the acquired corporation itself, but rather its assets.
Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by chrisseaton on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:31AM (#31530087)
Isn't this an answer to the original question then?

> Since when a company has the option to “recognize” or not a union?

The company has the option to ignore the union if not enough employees are members, or the employees aren't important enough.

How does it know how many are members? They have to tell it or they ballot them.

If the union doesn't have this support, the company ignores them.

I don't get why that's so hard to understand?

Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by chrisseaton on Friday May 27, 2022 @07:19AM (#31528254)
If the union doesn’t have enough clout then the company can just ignore it.

I don’t get why that’s surprising?

Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by Semaphor on Friday May 27, 2022 @08:14AM (#31528645)
> I don’t get why that’s surprising?

From another [0] comment 2 minutes later:

> There are clear obligations in Germany for how to integrate unions in a business and where/how they're able to influence business processes. How is it in the US?

[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31528241

Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by chrisseaton on Friday May 27, 2022 @08:22AM (#31528706)
I guess even in Germany a union can't just show up, with no demonstrable employee support, and start dictating that the company listen to them?

You say 'comprised of their employees' - who determines this? You need a secret vote at least, or some kind of voluntary indication of support. You need to know people aren't being coerced.

Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by jcrawfordor on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:54AM (#31529673)
Union elections are held in the US under regulations established by the National Labor Relations Board. These include, among other things, a secret ballot and measures against coercion. Employers are generally required to recognize a union which wins such an election.

That said, it is also common for acquisitions to be structured as a transaction in which all employees are terminated by the acquired organization and hired by the new organization. This effectively "resets" the process and may require employees to hold a new election. However, employers can always recognize a voluntarily and skip the NLRB process which would make recognition mandatory. It seems that Microsoft has indicated their willingness to do so.

Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by anamax on Friday May 27, 2022 @12:33PM (#31531513)
A secret ballot is NOT the only means.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Card_check

Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by jcrawfordor on Friday May 27, 2022 @04:08PM (#31534285)
The card check process is more of a special case of voluntary recognition, in which the employer can agree to skip the election if the petition for election already has a majority of the employees. Typically the employer can still require that an election by secret ballot be performed, the exception requires special dispensation of the NLRB which is obtained by demonstrating that the employer has or intends to tamper with the election.

The concept of a normalized card-check-only process is generally favored by unions because the NLRB election process is widely viewed as excessively favoring employers. However, it has never passed congress. That is, the "card check" as it is often discussed doesn't actually exist as the legislation proposing it has never passed. The existing mechanism is a fairly narrow exception that mostly exists for employer convenience.

Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by danaris on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:25AM (#31530014)
I'm not sure what it would even mean for a union to "just show up".

A union is by definition a group of employees. I guess you're talking about, maybe, representatives of a national union coming to an employer without there first being a union vote within...?

That's not remotely like what's being discussed here. What this situation is, and what's being talked about, are a union formed within the company (whether or not it's affiliated with a national union) and whether the employer has to recognize it and bargain collectively.

I can't even fathom the idea of a union with no members at a given company or organization "just showing up" and trying to get the management to bargain with them on their workers' behalf. It's just utterly nonsensical.

Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by chrisseaton on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:34AM (#31530128)
> I can't even fathom the idea of a union with no members at a given company or organization "just showing up" and trying to get the management to bargain with them on their workers' behalf. It's just utterly nonsensical.

That's how many unions work.

For example look at what is happening with Amazon warehouses - existing external unions turn up and try to recruit workers.

You also see it for example in the UK where unions have a political party and try to use that to change labour laws through normal government elections.

Whether or not that's nonsensical is a matter of opinion!

Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by danaris on Friday May 27, 2022 @04:14PM (#31534355)
I don't think that's a reasonable interpretation of what you said earlier, though. You were talking about a union "showing up and dictating to the company", not "showing up and recruiting employees to join the union through the normal legal process, then bargain collectively with the company the way unions do".
Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by chrisseaton on Friday May 27, 2022 @04:26PM (#31534475)
Bottom line is - the union needs to convince the company to listen to them. If they don't convince the company, then the company can ignore them. That was the original question.
Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by jsdwarf on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:47AM (#31529583)
In Austria, the situation is as follows: the employees of a company can decide to form a works council, which may or may not consist of Union members. To establish a works council, you need support statements of at least 5 employees. The works council itself is then elected by all employees of the company. They can choose between different candidates, who might be more or less union-friendly. The works council checks for violation of labor laws and is also consulted if employees are set off.
Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by melony on Friday May 27, 2022 @11:21AM (#31530633)
And that's why Germany is riding on its legacy manufacturing industry's coattails and its political position in Europe instead of cranking out real innovations like the US.
Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by ChuckNorris89 on Friday May 27, 2022 @11:24AM (#31530671)
Not really. The reason Germany rests on legacy industries and failed to innovate in the software/internet age, has nothing to do with unions, but is mostly liked to conservative mentality.
Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by itsdrewmiller on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:59PM (#31534192)
Usually that refers to voluntary recognition - acknowledging that the unit wants to organizing without forcing an NLRB election. I believe there already WAS an NLRB election for the Raven QA workers though, so that shouldn't apply here. I think the gist of the article is that Activision was set on continuing to fight until their last legal recourse was exhausted, while Microsoft accepts the current state of things.
Re:Microsoft to Reportedly Recognize Raven Software’s Union ... by banannaise on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @11:55AM (#31571065)
Anyone has the option to do anything; the question is how you will be prevented from or punished for doing it.

In this case, the answers are: not at all; and lightly at worst.