Neither option compares to DOCSIS 3.0 (no requirement to update splitters), DOCSIS 3.1 (requires updated splitters in the networks) (shared bandwidth up to 2GHz) and those won't be able to compete with Fiber's shared or dedicated 1THz+ bandwidth.
Most certainly. Tbaytel, Bruce Telecom, and CityWest are municipally owned. Sasktel, provincially. There are also a number of cooperatives, which has proven to be a nice model as well. My family farm in Canada is connected with fibre, offering gigabit service, by one of those co-ops. Canada's rural internet landscape is half decent as the big players never established themselves there.
> Do they pull the same trick of begging for government money to build rural infrastructure and then never build anything?
Yes, there are some known instances of that.
Where I live (rural area), a private ISP covers the county with fixed wireless and competes with a national ISP that does the same but with satellite for infill where there is no tower coverage. The various levels of government announced plans for massive funding to provide "high speed" internet everywhere, and Bell manages to be the only qualifier for our county, taking the entire subsidy to the tune of millions of dollars. They still do not provide fixed wireless service to this day but they do continue to provide backbone and peering to the other ISPs. Eventually, and unreliably.
Depends on the state. In mine (NC), they aren't not unless you had one before the telcos bribed the General Assembly to pass their build outlawing it.
They're legal in a fair few of the states out west. There's one in Utah called Utopia which is a grouping of 11 cities that even provides a 10gbps service.