News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by nlnn on Thursday May 26, 2022 @02:03AM (#31515182)
It's a tough one. If you discover a passion for something as an adult, you'll often wish your parents had pushed you into it as a kid.

I feel this way about music, zero education as a kid, started late as an adult, but feel I'll never catch up.

Though there's no way of knowing whether I'd have felt the same as a kid, or pushed back against it at the time.

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by satori99 on Thursday May 26, 2022 @02:49AM (#31515434)
When I was a small child I begged my mother to ask my teacher to excuse me from school music lessons. They were recorder lessons. And 20 children with recorders were giving me a literal headache every week.

My teacher excused me but reached out to my mother with the business card of a piano teacher she knew, as she considered music to be important.

I am eternally grateful that she did, and that I gave it a try, because even though I was never going to concert-grade piano player, it did mean I had enough music theory knowledge to play around meaningfully with early midi sequencers -- and those skills landed me a professional job in radio production straight out of high-school.

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by Fnoord on Friday May 27, 2022 @07:16AM (#31528231)
I've always been someone who found listening to music important (my father's hobby). 3 kids in elementary school went to 'music school'. I found them posh. I tried once, tagging along, but I guess my ADHD-like symptoms didn't work out (NB: ~quarter of century later I got an autism diagnosis). I also found the teacher very authoritarian. That's the thing: if people were friendly with me they could reach for the stars, but that cold authoritarian method just didn't work with me. Fast forward a few years, I wanted to get into producing music in the 90s, but I could never understand how to connect a synth to something else. I didn't know which cables I needed, what they'd cost, etc. No (IRL) network about music production. Failed. I consider my story being the nemesis of yours. Kudos!
Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by anonymous_sorry on Thursday May 26, 2022 @04:20AM (#31515973)
I had piano and clarinet lessons as a kid, and kept them up into my teens. I rarely practiced except when I was forced to, and I wasn't very good at practising when I did. I don't consider this abuse by the way, I was "forced" to go to school lessons too (not that I'm questioning Wil Wheaton's experience, which sounds quite different). Ultimately I found the repetition required in practising extremely boring, and I didn't have enough inner drive to get better. There's probably (a lack of) natural aptitude involved too, although this is hard to disentangle from motivation - a negative feedback loop maybe.

When I hear an good musician now, I inevitably wish I'd tried harder and could do what they do. If I hadn't had lessons, perhaps I'd blame my folks for the fact that I can't play jazz. But I was given every opportunity, had lessons for years, and didn't prioritise it. I just accept that it wasn't for me.

My parents also encouraged me to join a choir, and whilst I tended to daydream in choir practice, I kept that up into adulthood and it's had a major impact on my life.

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by apohn on Thursday May 26, 2022 @10:04AM (#31518474)
> But I was given every opportunity, had lessons for years, and didn't prioritise it. I just accept that it wasn't for me.

I have a similar story to yours, just with clarinet and flute. Our school (outside the USA) had mandatory lessons and practice, so there was some degree of being forced to do it.

I took some piano lessons as an adult and enjoyed it. My piano teacher told me something that really stuck with me. "People who write Adult piano books know the learner isn't going to become a professional classical musician. So they just teach you to play some fun songs and you can enjoy it. Children's music education makes kids suffer under the assumption that they are might one day take it very seriously and become classical musicians. So you perform scales endlessly, have to learn perfect form, learn instruments you don't want to learn because you need to learn the clarinet before you can learn the Sax, learn a bunch of boring classical music when you are excited by other stuff on the radio, practice like crazy for exams, etc. It completely kills their interest in music."

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by anonymous_sorry on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:21AM (#31526899)
This strikes a chord (sorry). Scales and arpeggios were the worst.
Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by prirun on Thursday May 26, 2022 @09:21AM (#31517994)
> When I hear an good musician now, I inevitably wish I'd tried harder and could do what they do.

I listen to good piano performances on YT and wish I was as good. But then I think about how much time I have spent being good with computers and realize that I could not have spent that much time on piano too. They probably spent as much time over their life pecking on a piano as I have pecking on a computer.

There's only so much time in a day!

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by shkkmo on Thursday May 26, 2022 @02:28AM (#31515313)
There is a difference between pushing you kids to try things to see what they like, and pushing you kids to keep doing something when they've tried it and told you they want to stop.
Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by candiodari on Thursday May 26, 2022 @06:33AM (#31516731)
The problem with this is fear of failure. If kids consider a skill worthwhile, from programming to sport to violin, and they see how good one can be (which can be hard to avoid especially for music) they will get fear of failure.

The next thing they'll tell you is they wish to stop. You cannot talk a kid out of fear of failure. I've never made the least bit of headway.

You shouldn't let them stop, and even force them to practice long enough (like >15 minutes, I'm not talking hours) that they forget about fear of failure and enjoy the next 15 minutes. Maybe even get them into the situation that there's nothing but the violin or some puzzle in code they don't understand for 5 minutes or so. Sport is good for this. If they do Judo and there is a duel, that's 2 minutes they will be focusing on the opponent. Somehow people don't easily get tired of this, and of course they focus.

It's all a balance. Should you let them struggle or give them answers directly? Should you give them opponents that are easy or hard ? Too easy? Too hard? Should you practice very directly or let them choose direction (they inevitably choose unattainable targets, so it's not as easy as you're thinking, but you may be able to guide them to a reasonable choice). Should you push them, maybe even "punish" them (take away cell phone for example)? I've known my kids to literally ask for that (taking away cell phone until they've completed homework or some practice).

And everything works like those opponents in Judo. The more they fight, the harder and stronger the opponent can be while they still learn. At 10 some can take "normal" adults and at 13-14 or so some kids are very liable to win against adults double their weight. But even "meta" this works. The more you push them, the harder you can push them without negative consequences and you should build this up over time.

It's all a balance. In every one of those questions there is a horrible answer that goes way too far ... on both sides of the equation. There is way too much practice and there is way to little practice, and it's even different per kid, when they're ill or feeling well, and how old they get. Otoh, as long as you're somewhere in the middle, it doesn't matter as much as you'd think where exactly you are in the middle. And you can pick one or two, but no more, where you have a slightly more extreme choice.

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by bobthepanda on Thursday May 26, 2022 @03:14AM (#31515601)
also, I feel like piano and violin are the very classic choices for parents picking out music education for their kids, when there is so much more than that to the world of music.

I absolutely hated every single moment of piano and never really got good at it. It was a different story once I got selected for a chorus in school.

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by ludston on Thursday May 26, 2022 @04:05AM (#31515893)
It's quite possible that the musical skills you picked up from your piano lessons are reason why you had the "talent" to picked for your schools chorus.
Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by bobthepanda on Thursday May 26, 2022 @04:15AM (#31515951)
Personally, I doubt it.

My main struggles with piano were chords, and sightreading. Chords aren't really relevant in vocals since a single person can only sing a single note at any given time, and I wasn't great at sightreading then either. And I find breath control a lot easier than trying to anticipate where my hands need to go (as someone with small hands, a lot of pieces were quite difficult)

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by trbleclef on Thursday May 26, 2022 @07:51AM (#31517205)
As HN's only? lurking non-swe choral director I'll just pipe in and say that every school should have a chorus that anyone can be in without being "picked", in addition to any auditioned levels. You can learn to sing the same way you can learn any other subject/skill; that is to say it's entry-level.
Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by bobthepanda on Thursday May 26, 2022 @12:49PM (#31520577)
To clarify, when I say picked I mean that for whatever reason at my high school every incoming freshman was screened for ability and if they were alright they got in.

There was a similar screening process for the ability to swim, though it was actually for selecting those who could not and teaching them.

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by benkwokcy on Thursday May 26, 2022 @02:06AM (#31515194)
You don't have to catch up. It doesn't matter how good you are, only if you are enjoying it.
Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by strken on Thursday May 26, 2022 @03:49AM (#31515794)
This is true in a sense, but the motivation a hobby gives you can depend on your performance. It often feels like there's a skill level where you hit critical mass and feel more rewarded than frustrated.

Kids learn fast and are less afraid to fail, so they can start new things more easily.

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by badpun on Thursday May 26, 2022 @04:17AM (#31515957)
> This is true in a sense, but the motivation a hobby gives you can depend on your performance. It often feels like there's a skill level where you hit critical mass and feel more rewarded than frustrated.

That also depends on your mindset and expectations. I've read a journal of master painter who, after roughly 40 years of doing art, still often felt frustrated and defeated after spending a day at the easel (even though 99% of people who paint would kill to be able to produce a painting he worked on).

Also, Polish poet Barańczak once said: "you know what they call a guy who enjoys writing? A hack".

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by abhaynayar on Thursday May 26, 2022 @04:31AM (#31516027)
The upside of hitting that critical mass is negligible to the downside of not hitting that critical mass.

Even when I get rewarded in things that I took up on my own, I feel that the rewards are quite measly compared to just having a normal healthy mental and physical existence. And these are interests that I took up on my own, I wonder how bad it would be for someone pushed by their parents.

But then again, I guess if someone grows up not having anything they're good at, they might blame their parents for not pushing them. Parenting must be very difficult.

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by irjustin on Thursday May 26, 2022 @02:12AM (#31515229)
At the same time, I understand it. There are some things simply out of reach, music you literally cannot play because those wires weren't built when you were younger.
Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by darylteo on Thursday May 26, 2022 @02:28AM (#31515317)
Exactly... at the elite level activities nowadays are simply out of reach to individuals who were not wholly absorbed in it from a young age.

Federer - 8. Nadal/Djokovic - 4. S. Williams - 3. L. Hamilton - 8. M. Schumacher - 6. Verstappen - 4. Phelps - 7. Messi - 4. C. Ronaldo - 7. M. Carlsen - 5. Lebron - 9. S. Curry - 6

Some people are just lucky to be good at the things they love doing. The others have to be content with getting paid for the things that they're good at to pay for the things that they love doing.

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by ciceryadam on Friday May 27, 2022 @02:09AM (#31526496)
Andre Agassi wrote an autobiography, in it he explains that his father groomed him for tennis greatness by building a tennis court in their backyard, and by sending him to tennis boarding school. Agassi also said that he had always hated tennis during his career.
Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by Jataman606 on Thursday May 26, 2022 @05:58AM (#31516501)
Jimi Hendrix - 15.
Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by alfiedotwtf on Thursday May 26, 2022 @02:49AM (#31515436)
FIFY: music you literally cannot play because you don't have as much time to practice compared to you were younger.

The wires you speak of come from time, practice, effort and habit - i.e the original meaning of the term kung fu.

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by ntlk on Thursday May 26, 2022 @03:46AM (#31515781)
This is it. There are periods in life when the time for practice is more likely to be freely available. As an adult there are other responsibilities to be negotiated.

I’ve made life choices that now result in having uninterrupted blocks of time for learning to play an instrument in my thirties. I’m surprised at how quickly some things become completely effortless when you have time to practice every day.

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by ido on Thursday May 26, 2022 @06:17AM (#31516614)
Be that as it may, children have a higher degree of neuroplasticity than adults. You would have probably learned even faster as a child.
Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by alfiedotwtf on Thursday May 26, 2022 @08:41AM (#31517598)
On the flip side, you're also less likely to be serious wanting to play an instrument, especially classical piano.

I started classical piano in primary school all the way up until I turned 17. I thought I played ok... but I started lessons again about 6 months ago (I'm turning 40 this weekend) and now that I actually want to play rather than be forced to play from tiger parents, I can honestly say that I'm learning 100 times faster than when I was a kid.

Also, now that I'm actually practicing multiple times a week rather than 30 minutes before my lesson (like when I did when I was a kid), my sight reading is blowing my mind. I could only wish to read like I do today than when I did in my teens.

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by alfiedotwtf on Thursday May 26, 2022 @08:43AM (#31517620)
Exactly. I now have an alarm that goes off every day after dinner, where I force myself (no matter how dead tired I am) to sit at the piano and play at least an hour.

But like going to the gym, the hard part is getting there. Once I'm playing, I look down at my watch and it's been over 2 hours!

Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by ntlk on Thursday May 26, 2022 @03:33PM (#31522446)
I’m exactly the same. Sometimes I think, ok, just ten minutes, and before I know it I made a ton of progress and spent an hour enjoying the process.
Re:I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or... by nlnn on Thursday May 26, 2022 @12:25PM (#31520297)
This is true, I am very much enjoying it and not benchmarking my ability against others.

My main frustration is around finding people to play with.

People my age seem to have been playing since they were kids and have high skill expectations.

Amateurs looking for people to play with seem much younger, and in it for the fun of hanging out as much as playing.