Personally I think Fuchsia is cool, and there is a lot to like, but I expect to hear it was killed by google anyday now.
The issue I have with Google is it's never clear to outsiders when projects are simply "experiments" that google is going to kill later. Dart, GWT, Angular Dart, for example, seemed like more than "experiments" yet google did a soft kill on Dart and effectively a hard kill on GWT.
You learn that something is "an experiment" when all the sudden updates slow or stop and the mailing list stops getting responses.
I don't trust google software because google bureaucracy is fickle and unpredictable.
Well if it's any comfort that's not clear to the Googlers either.
On the other hand if something is done by a startup there's also no way to know how much of a future it has. At least if it's open source then you have time to migrate to something else if Google stops investing in it. All the examples you name are Open Source.
And I don't think it's accurate to say Google did a "soft kill" on Dart. I don't recall any time when they reduced the manpower on the project, excepting perhaps the Dartino/Fletch (embedded Dart), which was explicitly labelled as tentative and experimental. These days things are going great for Dart.
What makes you say it's being killed?
From roughly 2013->2015 the mailing list was practically silent on dart.
Even then, the language got "rebooted" with a v2 in 2018 to try and stir up some new life in a language everyone thought was dead.
Because the real reason for its existence seems to be to slowly kill open source, by not requiring hardware vendors to provide kernel/driver source anymore.
Yes it does. The GPL literally does exactly that.
The Fuchsia design is good because it recognizes that reality and creates a world where patching the kernel doesn't require hardware vendors to rebuild their drivers.
In any case, the transition to MIT based FOSS on embedded platforms like Zephyr, RTOS, NutX,... proves that it won't matter for much longer anyway.
https://sfconservancy.org/copyleft-compliance/vizio.html
If it does, then any recipient of Linux will be able to sue for compliance.
As to why there’s so much negativity: no clue. I quite appreciate the idea of a blank slate devoid of cruft.
I'm concerned that it may not get real use or that Google might poison the well it dug.
But I would love to see it become a minimum viable desktop/embedded platform. But looking at CLs, sometimes the enemy of better/good is perfect.
Change is quite scary for some judging from the responses and there is finally a serious new OS that abandons the legacy Unix model and gives a refreshing approach to doing something new with support for only modern architectures.
To see it already running Chrome, Flutter, and being deployed on a Nest Hub without the users noticing tells me it is likely going to be the base of ChromeOS first and then it will replace Android in a couple of years with all Flutter and Android apps all running on Day 1 on the first phone running Fuchsia.
Won't be surprised to see Fuchsia on Chromebooks.
Easy: this is not the future we want. We don’t trust google. We don’t want an OS designed to further their goal of total control and surveillance capitalism.
“It’s all just a little bit of history repeatin’.”
Android is also open source, and is notably very difficult to simply fork and do your own thing and then actually use the thing, unless you happen to be a handset maker.
My OS entirely driven by Google? No thanks, they're making enough of a mess of the web (and Android lately, TBF).
What parts of the operating system design do this?
I am not sure why there's so much negativity around Fuchsia. From a technical point of view it's finally a serious attempt to do something new in the OS space. It might not be the right and perfect answer, but it might introduce new paradigms and maybe some fork of the project might be able to provide additional benefits for end users down the road. I know that there are lots of hobby/research projects trying out new stuff, but i think Fuchsia stands out because it might be able to land the innovation and make it accessible for a larger user base.