If the committee votes were secret, aka more of the process were secret but not the final floor votes, then we could still see how they voted in the end.
Also, if I'm not able to see how they vote individually, I'd probably be more likely to vote for people based on their team performance and not their individual performance and I think this is the biggest point for me. I don't care how Senator X votes, I care if Senator X convinces the team of Senators to pass a legislation. One Senator who says "but I voted the way you wanted me to vote" accomplishes much less for me than one Senator who is able to convince and negotiate with the other 99 to pass a bill that I wanted. So I'd look at whether things were happening that I wanted overall and if they weren't, I'd get rid of the person for not having the ability to move the team to better represent what I want.
[0]: https://congressionalresearch.org/SevenDeadlyMyths.html
I pay attention to what my representatives vote on the issues I care most about.
How do you know if your senator convinced people to vote for their bill if the process is secret? I could just be that they would have voted party line regardless.
> The arguments in that source are pretty poor.
Which arguments are poor and why?
> They offer no objective evidence to support their position.
Which positions do you think lack objective support?
> They even claim that all sorts of social ills were lower during the period of secrecy and suppose they must be related.
I agree that it may overstate the causation where it might just be correlation. At the same time, do you think that it's not worthy to investigate further? That many of at least the political ills could be strongly correlated with the increase in transparency?
> For example, given the number of people who die from medical mistakes, people absolutely should be taking more of a role in their own care.
I'm not sure if this is an example they mention or you were providing an analogy. I agree people should be taking more of a role in their medical care, I think the authors would agree as well. But do you think the patient should watch the surgeon's every move to make sure the surgeon is doing it exactly how the patient wanted it? At what point should the patient let go and trust the surgeon to do their job?
They make claims about significant data supporting thus, but don't provide it.
"And because lobbyists for the powerful appear to be the main consumers of transparent government, the evidence (below) suggests that governments function even better without a fully informed citizenry."
This doesn't logically follow. One could make lobbying reforms to curtail the problems associated with that while still allowing transparency for the citizens.
"This is because a republic works in much the same way as one might hire a plumber, roofer, surgeon or a mechanic. Indeed, when citizens choose to hire doctors or mechanics, the evidence is pretty clear that even when it comes to possible life threatening outcomes, few of us choose to become as informed as we likely should."
People still need to be vigilant and I formed when dealing with these professions so they don't get ripped off. People should be educating themselves enough to ask intelligent medical questions. People should seek second opinions. People should educate themselves to know the terminology and basic function of a car so they aren't getting ripped off by a mechanic. To People who view the whole situation and know the details, their example is actually an argument against the point they are making.
"By publishing just the final floor votes, the active citizens can still correlate votes to candidates, but by closing the doors of committees, the lobbyists and other extreme demanders are kept in check."
How did they reach this conclusion that lobbyists would be kept in check? Wouldn't lobbyists still be able to see the floor votes? I see no reason would affect the ability of lobbyists to continue their influence.
Most of the rest of the content are quotes, fluff, and supposition about inequality being related to a lack of secrecy. There's no objective data or links to studies.
Regardless, for now, thank you.
You can find citations/studies related to Transparency Benefits Lobbyists[0], Transparency Drives Partisanship[1], Transparency is Weaponized[2], Citizens Do Not Monitor Congress[3], Perverse Accountability[4], The Secret Ballot & the Gilded Age[5], The Politics of Intimidation[6], Bad Democracy[7], and a testimony before US Congress in 2019 called "Congressional Transparency: A Word of Caution"[8].
I put the links there just because right now I don't have the time to dig through them to find ones that connect directly to your concerns, but as I said, I hope the authors do illuminate those connections more and in the meantime, I hope you or others may read through some of the evidence behind the more abstracted summaries on the 7 myths page.
EDIT: One quote from that testimony which I just found and think is relevant:
> As I will discuss below, transparency burdens deliberation in two key ways: (1) it empowers organized groups to press their demands in the legislative process; (2) it tends to divert congressional discourse outward toward messaging rather than toward problem solving.
[0]: https://congressionalresearch.org/Citations.html
[1]: https://congressionalresearch.org/PartisanshipCitations.html
[2]: https://congressionalresearch.org/WeaponizedTransparencyCita...
[3]: https://congressionalresearch.org/CitizensDoNot.html
[4]: https://congressionalresearch.org/PerverseAccountability.htm...
[5]: https://congressionalresearch.org/SecretBallot.html
[6]: https://congressionalresearch.org/BruberyCitations.html
[7]: https://congressionalresearch.org/BadDemocracy.html
[8]: https://docs.house.gov/meetings/MH/MH00/20190510/109468/HHRG...
Maybe the only benefit of this would be to put the emphasis (imho) correctly back on being diligent in electing congress members, but outside of that anything done by the government in secret, is not likely to be done for the people, but rather solely to benefit those with the power to act in secret. The incentives for congress members to act outside of their own selfish interests just doesn't exist in secret.
So I wonder if the current transparency initiatives inspire the ones who like to be in front of the cameras, constantly campaigning, more than those who like work together to govern.
I believe a person can talk with constituents, maybe even 90% of the time, and learn as much from those conversations and then take that info into closed door discussions and negotiate on behalf of those people.
And I think Congress would do a lot better collectively if we cared more about the team performance and less about the individual performance.
https://www.slowboring.com/p/the-rise-and-importance-of-secr...
Or, it would allow them to vote in favor of the biggest donors with impunity.
Just look at our current voting machines. They're questionably secure and they're not even remotely as regulated/audited as even our gambling machines.
So, even stronger partisan based voting? Don't care about the individual, only if their party wins...
That football analogy is broken. The football team shares common goals. The parties in Congress very clearly have separate ideals/philosophies on specific issues. Even when they have a shared end goal (as the often do) the means to achieve it can be complete opposites.
The football team may not share common goals. The offense may care about scoring lots of points because each player wants to get a higher salary in their upcoming contract negotiations. The owner may only care about offense because it gets more viewers and more lucrative TV contracts.
I believe if we started rooting for Congress instead of rooting for one party (or one legislator), we might solve more collective problems.
Personally, I don't care about the Republican or Democratic parties, I care if Congress solve problems. I want the American team to win not the political party, and I'm willing to guess that there are many more citizens who think like this than it appears.
"Well, BurningFrog, as you know, we really needed to get bill 1 through this month, bill 2 through next month, and bill 3 through by the end of the year. Since bill 1 passed, with the extra money we'll save and/or make we have an extra $500,000 in the budget to donate to your campaign, here's that check, BTW.
Now, if bill 2 passes after that, our lobbying budget will be an additional $500k, and if bill 3 passes we'll have an extra $1,000,000. Good luck BurningFrog."
Politicians themselves benefit from the lobbyists. And the politicians who wouldn’t do what the lobbyists wanted any more would just lose elections since they would receive less campaign contributions. Natural selection.
But how would they lobby for that...? you ask. It would go marginally slower because of this temporary roadblock. But the necessary information would nonethless get through by way of more informal means, in the same way that de facto bribery cannot be eliminated by boneheaded laws like “you may not explicitly say that you intend to do something if someone gives you money”. As long as there are lobbyists and politicians and they are allowed to interact... there’s a way.
Or the politicians would just overturn the act by their own initiative since they want that sweet money.
Yes I agree they'd try.
> But how would they lobby for that...? you ask. It would go marginally slower because of this temporary roadblock.
You seem certain it would happen anyway.
Maybe an analogy: would you prefer that the votes of private citizens were public info? That everyone would know, with certainty, how their neighbor voted? I imagine lobbyists would love certainty over this information. Yes they try their best to guess it with all the voter info they buy and glean from data firms, yet don't have certainty over it.
So why haven't they been able to get public citizen voting records? It actually used to be this way and apparently it could get quite violent, in terms of how people would intimidate each other into voting certain ways[0].
I'm not saying that lobbyists wouldn't find a way to still influence the votes, I just think it would likely be a lot harder than you imagine it would be.
How do you imagine the money would flow if there were more secrecy in the Congressional process? If you were a lobbyist (or more accurately, a rich person who pays lobbyists), how would you do it?
The general thought is that lobbyists pay politicians to buy votes. That means they'll do what it takes to make sure they get their money.
I agree the general belief is that lobbyists pay politicians to buy votes. I think lobbyists pay much more money to intimidate politicians to vote in certain directions, as it's much cheaper to threaten 100 by paying to make an example of 1, than to pay 100 directly.
So yes, I think they would try to intimidate them, I just don't see how it would actually happen. Perhaps the lobbyists would punish all, just as the teacher punishes the whole class when no one will admit to pulling the prank, or the coach punishes the whole team when no one takes responsibility for a mistake. I just think that for lobbyists to punish the whole team of 100 senators and 435 members of Congress would require a lot more money and would be harder to coordinate than it currently is. Increase the numbers of senators or members of Congress and that could become even more difficult.
I'm not saying it's not possible, it just seems significantly more difficult to intimidate when these details are secret.
I think the root cause is not political donations but being able to track whether those political donations have the intended effect. I imagine very very few lobbyists would give cash if they couldn't make sure the strings were attached just as they wanted them to be.
What you propose can only work under specific circumstances, which, even when those circumstances existed, could not thwart the corruption of the system.
What specific circumstances do you mean?
It would accomplish two things: lobbyists wouldn't be able to tell who actually voted for legislation and party leadership wouldn't be able to effectively enforce party allegiance through committee assignment and campaign funding. I am sure there are some unforeseen consequences (like would lobbying just be replaced with some kind of real bribery behind the scenes), but not being under the influence of lobbyists and party leadership would allow congress members to truly vote on what they think is in their constituents best interests.