News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Friday May 20, 2022 @01:48PM (#31450530)
ETH will soon move from PoW to PoS (let's not debate the timeline or if it is a good idea). This will put about 32 million GPUs worth of compute and millions of CPUs searching for something else to do (or just flood the market with used equipment).

I have been searching, for years, for alternative workloads for these GPUs beyond just PoW mining and password cracking. Many of them are on systems with tiny cpus, little memory, little disk, little networking so the options are heavily limited. AI/ML/Rendering/Gaming actually make bad use cases.

If anyone has thoughts on this, I'd appreciate hearing them. Let it all die is certainly an option, but it also seems just as wasteful as keeping it going. Maybe we can find a better use case, like somehow curing cancer...

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by PragmaticPulp on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:08PM (#31451347)
> ETH will soon move from PoW to PoS (let's not debate the timeline or if it is a good idea). This will put about 32 million GPUs worth of compute and millions of CPUs searching for something else to do (or just flood the market with used equipment).

Crypto markets crashing together could do this, but ETH's switch isn't going to do much for old cards.

Checking https://whattomine.com/ shows that ETH mining isn't even in the top 5 most profitable things to mine with a 1080Ti right now. The miners looking to squeeze every bit of profitability out of old hardware switched away from ETH a long time ago.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:58PM (#31451837)
Wrong. Why?

1) The cards have already paid for themselves. They are 100% ROI positive and even at the current low amounts very profitable. Regardless of what W2M says, ETH is still the top most profitable coin. Large miners don't sell immediately, they wait for the market to go up or the option against their ETH holdings.

2) ETH doesn't require latest hardware because the algo is memory hard, which means that the bottle neck is in the memory controller, not in the speed of the GPU chip itself. https://www.vijaypradeep.com/blog/2017-04-28-ethereums-memor...

3) The actual consumable is electricity price, which really hasn't changed much in the last few years for large miners who have contracts.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by PragmaticPulp on Friday May 20, 2022 @07:27PM (#31453827)
> Wrong. Why?

What? ETH isn’t the most profitable thing for these cards to mine. Why are you so confident that ETH switching to PoS will open the floodgates when ETH is already not the driver of their usage?

The ETH proof-of-stake switch isn’t going to be the driving force they causes GPUs to be abandoned in bulk.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Friday May 20, 2022 @08:07PM (#31454073)
> ETH isn’t the most profitable thing for these cards to mine.

You can mine shitcoins on a small scale for maybe a bit more profit. The issue is always unloading a lot of shitcoin in a very small volume market. Even ETC has a 6.5 day deposit time on exchanges like Kraken. Nobody is going to want to deal with that.

> The ETH proof-of-stake switch isn’t going to be the driving force they causes GPUs to be abandoned in bulk.

The GPUs will move to other shitcoins, which will cause the prices of those shitcoins to go down as people will mine and dump them, which will cause a lot of GPU miners to shut off.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by RealityVoid on Saturday May 21, 2022 @05:58AM (#31456608)
Usually, with POW, the issuance is the same. So they will mint the same amount, no way that will crash the price. What _will_ make the mining not profitable is the difficulty increase. It boggles my mind people don't seem to get this.
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Saturday May 21, 2022 @10:53AM (#31458408)
More hashrate will earn more of the pie.
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by ShamelessC on Saturday May 21, 2022 @05:05AM (#31456398)
> the ETH proof-of-stake switch isn’t going to be the driving force they causes GPUs to be abandoned in bulk.

The proof-of-stake switch is also pretty unlikely to ever actually happen.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Saturday May 21, 2022 @10:57AM (#31458450)
The merge will absolutely happen, there are 12.6m ETH in the staking contract [1] that people want out of there and the only way to get it is to get to the next steps.

[1] https://etherscan.io/address/0x00000000219ab540356cBB839Cbe0...

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by ShamelessC on Saturday May 21, 2022 @01:23PM (#31459848)
Sorry but I'll believe it when it happens.
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Saturday May 21, 2022 @01:57PM (#31460221)
When is irrelevant in my eyes, it honestly doesn't matter. It will happen though.
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by RealityVoid on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:54PM (#31451808)
I hear people say this, but I am absolutely certain their assumptions are wrong.

1) The sum total of rewards is fixed for POW 2) Introducing extra hashing power will increase the difficulties of these mining ops up to the profitability equilibrium point.

After the overall "free" hashing power increases to a point, GPU's will start flooding the market at dumping prices.

It will be incredibly rad!

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by VHRanger on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:49PM (#31451751)
Proof of Stake has been 6-18months away for 5 years now.

As far as I'm concerned it'll release along with Star Citizen

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by zamadatix on Friday May 20, 2022 @01:56PM (#31450605)
There are plenty of good uses, projects like BOINC have been using GPUs for good for over a decade. The problem is the incentive system disappears, it's a lot easier to get people to run 32 million GPUs when it makes them money instead of costs them money.
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Friday May 20, 2022 @02:07PM (#31450704)
Well, exactly. It has to be incentivized.
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by whoisterencelee on Friday May 20, 2022 @02:16PM (#31450788)
Please please check gridcoin.world
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:01PM (#31451268)
This seems like an incentivized BOINC built on top of an inflationary shitcoin. There is no utility in the coin itself and that is reflected in its price history.

What we need is something that has utility... like run BOINC, earn tokens that can be used in the real world for something other than just dumping on the market.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by mwt on Friday May 20, 2022 @01:53PM (#31450571)
Folding@home would love to take a swing at a sliver of that compute
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by jseliger on Friday May 20, 2022 @02:55PM (#31451202)
It's peculiar to me that Folding@home never managed to get GPUs working for MacOS, given the platform's popularity: https://foldingforum.org/viewtopic.php?f=83&t=32895

As a consequence, it seems not worth installing on MacOS: https://stats.foldingathome.org/os

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by dekhn on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:08PM (#31451348)
It's not worth implementing for MacOS because it woulnd't increase the overall folding rate very much given the relative weakness of the Mac GPUs compared to the existing f@h fleet.
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by dekhn on Friday May 20, 2022 @02:09PM (#31450728)
folding@home has been doing this for 20+ years. They already did all the smart research and tech development. Just use that until somebody comes up with a workable DrugDiscoveryAtHome or CureCancerAtHome.
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Friday May 20, 2022 @02:58PM (#31451241)
This is a very dismissive answer which seems odd coming from someone with a lot of karma. Running GPUs at scale isn't easy or cheap.

There is no incentive to run this other than good feelings. Unfortunately, that isn't enough in the business world to spend millions on cap/opx.

What I'm looking for is incentivized options. Even better if they come from a web3 situation where a business can operate without having actual customers.

"Mining", but with not such "wasteful" work.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by bryans on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:15PM (#31452014)
It's ironic to be declaring the GP as dismissive while you're flippantly dismissing the work of everyone involved with F@H. You're conveniently ignoring the incentive of expanding our understanding of biology, which has very real applications and results[1] that benefit the entire world for the rest of human existence, instead of benefiting a single participant in the short term.

[1] https://www.hpcwire.com/2020/10/14/how-foldinghome-identifie...

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:58PM (#31452420)
What? I'm not dismissing their work.

I'm just saying there is no direct financial incentive for 32 million GPUs to move over to it. If there was, they'd be on that instead of ETH.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by bryans on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:37PM (#31452834)
You literally said "no incentive [...] other than good feelings." Regardless, even adding the words "direct financial" is still incorrect. For one of many examples, insurance companies investing in F@H infrastructure would be beneficiaries, albeit via savings and not revenue.
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Friday May 20, 2022 @06:00PM (#31453051)
I literally clarified my statement since you came to an incorrect conclusion.

"direct financial" is correct when you're giving examples that are not direct.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by bryans on Friday May 20, 2022 @06:35PM (#31453378)
You're moving the goal posts, on top of changing the definition of "direct" to fit your false narrative. First you claim there was no incentive at all, then there was no "direct" incentive, and now direct apparently means "immediate" instead of linear.

If a company invests in research specifically because the fruits of that research will reduce expenses, that is direct financial benefit.

[dead]
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by bryans on Friday May 20, 2022 @08:24PM (#31454161)
> Reducing expenses is not direct financial benefit.

You've created a seven word sentence which contradicts itself in every conceivable way. Expenses are financial. Reducing them is beneficial.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Friday May 20, 2022 @10:39PM (#31454819)
>Expenses are financial. Reducing them is beneficial.

You're missing the word 'direct'.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by bryans on Friday May 20, 2022 @10:59PM (#31454897)
Expenses are the "loss" portion of "profit and loss." That is 50% of the concept of accounting, making it as direct as it gets. Please stop this prolonged line of trolling.
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by quickthrower2 on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:24PM (#31451499)
The dark side is you need a ponzi scheme to fund it. When that ponzi collapses the work stops. Good feelings are better IMO!
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:44PM (#31451706)
It is odd that you think of crypto as a ponzi while promoting a referral network in your HN profile.
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by quickthrower2 on Friday May 20, 2022 @09:41PM (#31454557)
Yes Digital Ocean. They are not a ponzi/pyramid because

1. They sell a useful product

2. They do not charge people to be affiliates.

3. They do not sell a token/security that you buy with the intent of making future gains, funded only by other people buying the token expecting more people will do the same.

If anyone uses the link ... I haven't checked ... I get some DO credit, not even money, which I will use for hobby projects. If I get $5 in credit in a year, I would be pretty suprised.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Friday May 20, 2022 @10:37PM (#31454794)
I'm not saying it is a pyramid/ponzi. It is an affiliate marketing scheme, and those are never slimy. /s
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by quickthrower2 on Saturday May 21, 2022 @12:48AM (#31455305)
So any job in sales is slimey.
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by dekhn on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:34PM (#31452788)
yeah, everybody knows crypto is a pyramid scheme, ponzi schemes are specifically about a type of coupon fraud.
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by quickthrower2 on Saturday May 21, 2022 @04:16AM (#31456190)
It is structurally more like a ponzi than a pyramid.

By large crypto has no MLM style referral system where the product is the business opportunity to sell the product.

However it does have a feature where crypto gains are only funded by newer people coming in and buying at a higher price. But no cashflows are produced other than selling the investment tokens. This is almost identical to a ponzi except it has decentralisation that makes it probably legally not a ponzi.

Imagine I did an IPO of a company I incorporated last night but hid behind a panama shell. That’s crypto.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Saturday May 21, 2022 @02:01PM (#31460243)
> However it does have a feature where crypto gains are only funded by newer people coming in and buying at a higher price.

"only" is inaccurate. This was true early on before there were markets and contracts. Now we have DeFi which allows for gains on trades by anyone who wants to provide liquidity. Similar to any sort of commodity market where people buy and sell what they own (or even don't own with margin and options).

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by ShamelessC on Saturday May 21, 2022 @05:08AM (#31456415)
> This is a very dismissive answer which seems odd coming from someone with a lot of karma

Are you kidding? Shallow dismissals masquerading as insight are easily the most popular genre of comment on Hacker News.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by dekhn on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:14PM (#31451410)
only good feelings? f@H has made fundamental contributions to our understanding of biophysics of folding proteins!
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by passivate on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:53PM (#31451789)
I am aware of domain applications from F@H, but not core science work. What are those fundamental contributions?
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by dekhn on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:02PM (#31451884)
We conclusively demonstrated that kinetic models of folding are critical to do better drug discovery against GPCRs and other target classes.

Or did you mean something more fundamental, like "the biophysics of protein folding is primarily determined by entropic-driven hydrophobic collapse, not enthalpic contributions from hydrogen bonding?"

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by passivate on Monday May 23, 2022 @04:16PM (#31484303)
>We conclusively demonstrated that kinetic models of folding are critical to do better drug discovery against GPCRs and other target classes.

How was this demonstration done? Or are you referring to building a better high throughput screening mechanism? I'm by no means a protein expert, but I am trying to learn more about them.

>Or did you mean something more fundamental, like "the biophysics of protein folding is primarily determined by entropic-driven hydrophobic collapse, not enthalpic contributions from hydrogen bonding?"

I don't want to minimize anything or anyones work. But conformation of experimental observations via molecular dynamics simulation isn't what I was thinking of - but maybe I am misunderstanding your claim. Its my own ignorance.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:50PM (#31451767)
Sorry, it was just a way to say "not financially incentivized".
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by daniel-cussen on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:00PM (#31451260)
Oh you know what an alternative use is? Oaths. Works with old ASICs as well...well I think. So you take a document, like this comment, you append a nonce (you'll see) and you hash it until you get a lot of zeroes in the front. Same as bitcoin, but you're not hashing the bitcoin protocol. Then, you know the document has been sworn, as a cryptographic oath, to that extent. Nonce: 38943
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by daniel-cussen on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:38PM (#31451640)
So then go to https://geraintluff.github.io/sha256/

> oath = "Oh you know what an alternative use is? Oaths. Works with old ASICs as well...well I think. So you take a document, like this comment, you append a nonce (you'll see) and you hash it until you get a lot of zeroes in the front. Same as bitcoin, but you're not hashing the bitcoin protocol. Then, you know the document has been sworn, as a cryptographic oath, to that extent. Nonce: 38943"

> sha256(oath) 00009ea9ab415b7f60cd43571c159d1bf1e01de4bae6a706ec9053ceb94d385c

Note the leading 0's. That's no timestamp, that's an oath.

In reply to the sibling comment: no. I like timestamp.com, and in fact I could have never found out about it other than by talking about the oath concept, but this is not just including it in the blockchain. It's proving its value to the author to bother doing the work of getting a good nonce for it. Literally putting my money where my mouth is. And swearing an oath to that extent, I could cryptographically swear it more, with more work, or use a smaller less impressive nonce if I'm not as sure.

And incentives? There is an incentive for me. At the same time it is effectively burning money, swearing by burning money. Took like seven seconds of compute, too. I had to wait human time for that. It's collateral, it's an oath. And it's an impediment to forgery, and in addition, an impediment to eg news sites telling different people different things. With oaths they have to tell everybody the same thing.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by ephbit on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:50PM (#31452349)
Could you kindly point me/others to some info about this oath concept?

I mostly get pointed to Oauth stuff when searching for "oath sha256 nonce".

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by daniel-cussen on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:12PM (#31452577)
There's nothing out there beyond what you've read in my two comments above yours.

Well I suppose I can still point you to it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31451260

You know what? I'll make a post about it and link it here.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:03PM (#31451289)
This is effectively timestamp.com

There is also very little incentive structure.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by redisman on Friday May 20, 2022 @02:26PM (#31450880)
Why isn’t there a folding coin? Productive mining and you reward the new protein folds or whatever
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by fancyfredbot on Friday May 20, 2022 @02:44PM (#31451074)
Because folding is too hard to verify. For a Blockchain to work it needs to be very easy to prove that the miner has actually done the work. With a folding problem it's very hard to prove the answer a miner gives is actually a solution to the problem rather than a quick guess. It's a shame!
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by quickthrower2 on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:20PM (#31451466)
Just make it centralized (like most cryptocurrency effectively is anyway). You would still need some checks and balances sure.

Make a token. Altruists buy the token to fund the “miners”. They may also make a profit but they buy knowing most likely they wont and it is for a good cause.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by latchkey on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:48PM (#31451739)
That is what gridcoin is. Unfortunately, it doesn't work.
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by bufferoverflow on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:15PM (#31452017)
There's Folding Coin (FLDC)

https://foldingcoin.net/

But it never took off.

Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by netsharc on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:40PM (#31452864)
Crypto is <valley-girl>literally</valley-girl> stopping us from finding the cure for cancer!
Re:“Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce... by PartiallyTyped on Friday May 20, 2022 @02:30PM (#31450931)
What about federated learning to deal with the little memory issue?