News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Favorite Liar (2008) by SeanLuke on Friday May 20, 2022 @10:15AM (#31447684)
True story. I live in the US. A [famous] colleague of mine was invited to give a lecture at a major German university in front of a professor's class. At the end of his lecture, the professor picked a random student out of the class, and the student came down and gave a perfect 1-minute summary of the lecture.

My colleague asked how the students could be so disciplined. The professor said it was simple: they knew he would pick one at random, so they all had pre-prepared summaries of the lecture based on studying my colleague's submitted lecture notes the day before.

Re:My Favorite Liar (2008) by thih9 on Friday May 20, 2022 @10:50AM (#31448237)
I wouldn’t want to participate in a course like this. I’d say it’s the lecturer’s job to explain a topic well enough so that the students can summarize it.

If students have to memorize a summary before the lecture then something feels wrong. Good for the lecturer, I guess.

Re:My Favorite Liar (2008) by arkitaip on Friday May 20, 2022 @11:33AM (#31448853)
The purpose of great lectures isn't to regurgitate what is readily available in the literature or slides but to give students an opportunity to Q&A the parts which they don't understand.
Re:My Favorite Liar (2008) by bombcar on Friday May 20, 2022 @12:24PM (#31449554)
Exactly - many talks and lectures would be much better if the audience reviewed the material beforehand and didn't need to spend most of the time having powerpoint slides read to them.