News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by yumraj on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:14PM (#31437356)
I was just thinking about this today.

Given the very low interest rates in 21-22 and high prices, a certain percentage of folks would have purchased with a convertible mortgage.

Assuming the standard 5-1 and the fact that rates are rising very fast, should we expect a repeat of 2008 in 2026-2027?

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by vmception on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:45PM (#31437806)
2008 was an accounting and leverage problem.

Every product in 2008 was completely viable which is why the Federal Reserve bought everything.

Only 7% of the borrowers defaulted by then, there wasnt mass irresponsibility on the people with mortgages as suggested, this alone blew up some institutions because they were leveraged nearly 50x and one month of missed mortgage payments would cause a massive drawdown on their portfolio.

Without leverage, a portfolio where 93% is going to pay a lot in interest over 5-30 years is a good portfolio.

So there is no reason to get uncomfortable or anxious by seeing the words “subprime” “CDOs” or more, as it comes down to whether the accounting is done properly and the leverage is low. Which, I believe is being done. The "big crash" always comes from a different and unexpected (or less expected) angle, where some completely different sector has too much leverage and flimsy accounting.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by jjoonathan on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:18PM (#31438206)
Yes, a disappointing fraction of armchair generals are fighting the last war.

What are the big speculative candidates for next crash? Contagion from the Chinese real estate market?

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by vmception on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:38PM (#31438418)
Yeah the contagion is important and it also needs to be several trillion dollars in value.

Given that the Federal Reserve wants unemployment numbers to rise, they're specifically trying to make share capital worth less, and borrowing capabilities cost more, making revenue-poor corporations stop being so optimistic. so I would just expect lower valuations with much lower revenue multiples (or price to equity ratios), for that reason alone.

Slowed growth in China is always a threat because thats a key revenue driver for many large western companies. Then sure, there is the leverage and accountability problem with Chinese real estate, but I don't get the impression that contagion is that big because nobody thinks that is a safe bet and also avoid too much exposure to the domestic chinese lenders involved. The rumors behind Tether just aren't big enough to matter for this, could only be a slight sting to the commercial paper market and a moderate "finally" for the crypto market as a tether implosion would probably increase confidence there after steep selloffs.

Oil/gas volatility is probably going to have some casualties.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by mywittyname on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:15PM (#31438846)
> Oil/gas volatility is probably going to have some casualties.

The Oil Glut of the 2010s killed off all but the strongest players in this sector. So I doubt it will be a pillar that collapses. If anything, they will probably do very well in the near-term.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by vmception on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:17PM (#31438865)
the producers won't have the issue, I was thinking just speculators that have over/unexpected exposure to the wrong direction of the oil/gas derivatives market
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by jjoonathan on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:20PM (#31440313)
Yeah, the commodities markets are opaque to me and between food and energy it sounds like they have a major test on the way this winter.

Re: Chinese real estate, the contagion mechanism I've heard the most about isn't West->East investment, it's East->West investment that gets pulled to survive a bear market. I have no idea if it's big enough to matter.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by sveme on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:33PM (#31438355)
As suggested in that famous substack post [1], a venture capital crisis? I guess everyone on this site is fucked then.

[1]https://pivotal.substack.com/p/minsky-moments-in-venture-cap...

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by SkyMarshal on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:48PM (#31438519)
Good article but weird chart, “Bond Markets Over Time”. Both axes are reversed to make it look like something is increasing (y-axis) over the size of the opportunity (x-axis), when instead he’s making the point that Alpha (y) decreases as size of opportunity (x) increases.
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by brazzy on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:35PM (#31438380)
Cryptocurrencies.

In the runup to the 2008 crisis, a commonly heard mantra was "yeah, subprime lending is fucked up, but it's a small fraction of the economy, it can't cause that much damage". Turned out that it could, via the CDO shenanigans.

I would not at all be surprised if someone has already cooked up a similar leveraged dependency from the "real economy" to crypto markets.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by SkyMarshal on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:44PM (#31438479)
It depends entirely on how much cryptocurrencies are being used as collateral for leverage, which was the main factor that amplified the GFC. MBS’s and MBS-based CDO’s were used as collateral for massive amounts of leverage (up to 30:1 for the commercial banks, and 100:1 for Fannie & Freddie). Since the housing market had never crashed, that collateral was considered reliable enough for significant amounts of leverage. Turns out it wasn’t.

But cryptos have never been considered remotely that reliable by the broader financial system. Thus there is probably little to no leverage using cryptos as collateral. Crypto is currently crashing, but it will only take down itself and not 30 to 100 times as much leverage with it.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by komaromy on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:12PM (#31438804)
I'd be more open to this if we hadn't already seen wild swings in the crypto market (BTC is down ~50% from its 12-month peak) without much in the way of broader implications.
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by antisthenes on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:20PM (#31440307)
Generally speaking there aren't fears of a hard crash.

The main concern is stagflation due to rising energy prices. It seems like the market is now finally starting to price in the externalities of abating climate change, which results in higher energy prices across the board (which in turn raises prices of everything else, with inflation due to QE piled on top of it).

This means that output roughly stays the same, but there are more dollars competing for it.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by r00fus on Thursday May 19, 2022 @07:01PM (#31441279)
The last war is continuing to be fought by big finance to remove any of the (even partial/basic) regulations and remediations that were put in place.
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by dv_dt on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:26PM (#31438280)
imho, labor shortages and productivity drops due to a Covid policy causing mass long Covid cases.
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by tootie on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:50PM (#31439983)
And as much as Dodd-Frank was watered down, the orderly liquidation provisions survived and that means regulators have full authority to stop a situation like Bear Sterns or Lehman collapsing and taking down a sector of the economy with them.
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by dragonwriter on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:29PM (#31437602)
> Given the very low interest rates in 21-22 and high prices, a certain percentage of folks would have purchased with a convertible mortgage.

Convertible mortgages became popular as an alternative to either fixed or nonconvertible ARMs when rates were high as a way to preserve the option of locking in on a rate drop without going through a refi. Convertibles don't offer a lot when rates are low—if you want to be able to lock in a low rate and rates are already low, you get a fixed.

Between that, changes in qualification rules, and memories of the collapse leading into the Great Recession, ARMs of all types have shrunk to a very small share (<5%, IIRC) of residential mortgages, and newer ARMs tend to have rate caps.

> Assuming the standard 5-1 and the fact that rates are rising very fast, should we expect a repeat of 2008 in 2026-2027?

Probably not because of adjustments on existing mortgages. If there is sustained stagflation, then the fact that people can't pay their fixed-rate mortgages given other necessary expenses may produce a similar collapse, though.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by UncleOxidant on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:18PM (#31437410)
I thought adjustable rate mortgages were pretty much dead after '08? Why would anyone get an ARM when rates were in the 3% range for a 30 year fixed mortgage (as they were for several years until recently)?
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by gnopgnip on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:46PM (#31438497)
Something like 60% of homeowners would come out ahead financially with an ARM. You can save tens of thousands of dollars in interest before the rates adjust. Many people sell or refinance before the rates adjust, or soon after. The rate early on is a little more important because that is when the principal is highest, but in practice this isn't a huge factor. Only about 35% of the original principal is paid off after 10 years for a 5% mortgage. Even if rates go up and you stay there for 15-30 years, you could come out ahead because of how much lower the interest was for the first 5-7 years. But it depends on how much rates go up.

But the long tail is some people being priced out of their home as their payment rises, and it could have been prevented. So 90-95% of mortgages in the US are fixed rate.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by bgirard on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:51PM (#31437890)
Say you take a 7 ARM at 2% instead of 3% for a 700k mortgage. You're saving $50,000 in interest during the first 7 years. That's 7% of your mortgage. Then 7 years of inflation can knock down your principle further which might be pretty high over the next 7 years.

It can make sense if you're financially secure enough to take on the risk.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by mgkimsal on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:46PM (#31437818)
I went through 2 ARMs between 2013 and 2021. In both cases the 7 year ARM was at least 1.5 % below the traditional 30 year I could get. Between lender rebates and such, in both cases we had essentially $0 out of pocket and in both cases a moderately. In the last couple years, the ARMs I looked at were less than a single % from a traditional 30 year. I had last 3% ARM was adjusting in mid 2023, and I refi'd to a 30 year @ 2.75% last October. Holy tamole things have changed since then!
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by scarface74 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:25PM (#31438958)
Alternate anecdote: I refinanced our house in 2020 and financed points and my interest rate is fixed at 1.87% for 15 years.
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by caeril on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:52PM (#31438571)
Same reason very intelligent fund managers are buying 10y TSYs yielding 2.8% despite inflation giving them a NEGATIVE 5.2% real yield:

Everyone thinks that 5 years out, everything will be rosy. The metalworker saving 0.6% on a 5/1 ARM vs a fixed 30yr is using the same mental gymnastics that J. Poindexter on Goldman's bond desk is, that central banks are omniscient, omnipotent, and will always magic away the risk inherent in our decisions.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by Kerrick on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:53PM (#31440017)
Also worth noting: not all ARMs have a balloon payment. For example, I bought most of my farm on a 20yr ARM with a 20yr amortization. As interest rates rise I will have higher payments, but there’s no moment when the music stops and the rest of the principle immediately comes due.
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by brewdad on Friday May 20, 2022 @12:47AM (#31443463)
There is still the risk of an interest rate reset raising the payment amount to an untenable level though. Maybe not in your specific case, depending on your circumstances, but for many others it will be true.
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by dmitrygr on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:24PM (#31437518)
Because ARMS were in the 2.x% range.

I talked a number of people out of ARMs in '21 and '22 by explaining 2008 to them (they were 7-8 years old at the time, so do not remember). It is scary how bad most people are at understanding exponential growth and just how much worse 5% is than 3%

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by bgirard on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:06PM (#31438073)
It's not exponential. And even though 5% is 66% higher than 3%, the monthly payment is $5,368 instead of $4,216 on 1m which is 27% higher. Sure you pay twice as much interest over 30 years.
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by brewdad on Friday May 20, 2022 @12:50AM (#31443479)
Do you think a typical homebuyer stretching themselves in the heated market of the past 2 years can easily absorb a 27% increase in their payment? I have my doubts.
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by sokoloff on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:41PM (#31438446)
How is a compounding loan (such as a mortgage) not exponential?
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by karpierz on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:02PM (#31438691)
Because you're paying it off faster than it grows. It would be exponential if you were allowed to simply let it sit without paying it down, but that would break the contract and get you foreclosed.
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by NovemberWhiskey on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:24PM (#31440354)
It's absolutely exponential - it's just that the base is barely over one and the exponents involved are not very large.
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by lkjfdslkjf222 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:24PM (#31437514)
Don't know numbers off hand but we had a <4% rate ARM because it was the lowest rate and we liked the flexibility of paying it off asap (or if something happened, paying it off over 30 years) versus a 15-year fixed.

Plenty of other reasons. Others have bad credit or otherwise get significantly lower payments on an ARM compared to fixed.

I guess there are other reasons, but ARMs are definitely not dead. I don't know the numbers or where to get them though.

What are more dead are the "balloon payment" residential mortgages where they may amortize over 30 years but the principal is due in 5 or 10 years.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by paulmd on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:41PM (#31437736)
> Don't know numbers off hand but we had a <4% rate ARM because it was the lowest rate and we liked the flexibility of paying it off asap (or if something happened, paying it off over 30 years) versus a 15-year fixed.

you can pay off a 15-year mortgage in less than 15 years - the lien will be released, etc whenever the principal is paid. Everything depends on the specifics of your contract of course but it would be extremely unusual to have a mortgage where this is not allowed.

fixed vs ARM purely depends on how the interest rate is determined, that's it. In principle ARM should be a bit lower than a fixed rate financed at the same time - but if the prime rate goes up then your rate goes up too, where with a fixed it's locked-in forever. Fixed will have a higher interest rate because someone has to assume that risk of an increase in the prime rate, where with an ARM that someone is you.

Taking an ARM vs a fixed is a bet on whether rates are going to stay the same or decrease, vs increase. And boy if you thought 2020-2021 rates weren't going to increase at some point in the future, uh... it's not every day you have a once-in-a-century pandemic that nukes the economy and drives demand for money almost to zero.

I'm not quite sure what you're saying about balloon payments either, the balloon payment happens at the end of a balloon mortgage, with the intention that values will have gone up so you can refinance at that point - but of course, what if they don't?

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by bluGill on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:49PM (#31438537)
He wasn't worried about paying off the 15 year mortgage in 10 years. He was worried about getting a 15 year mortgage and then sometime happening so he couldn't afford to pay it off in 15 years. With a ARM you get the flexibility of lowering your payments to the minimum - which will pay it off in 30 years if bad times happen, while getting the lower interest rates of a 15 year loan (for the first X years, then who knows), and if you may the 15 year loan payment it is paid off in 15, while if bad times come you drop to the 30 year repayment amount and have more money to deal with whatever.

It can be a very good idea for someone who plans to pay off their mortgage early. If all goes well it is no worse than a 15 year mortgage, but when (really, if is unlikely) something bad happens you have more flexibility. Of course if interest rates go up you will get burned, which is why I go with a 30 year fixed rate that I pay off. I could probably afford payments on a 15 year loan, but I'm not willing to risk it.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by fdjjjkffkk2 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:45PM (#31438486)
Eh, I think we're talking past each other because none of what you said really applies to what I think I'm saying.

A 30year ARM gives you a lot more flexibility then a 15-year anything. I mean, you can pay off the 30 year in 30 years or 15 years or 5.

Regarding the balloon payment-- not sure what you're missing here. Residential mortgages with balloon payments aren't really offered any more because of huge risk of default when the balloon payment is due.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by addaon on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:24PM (#31438256)
> Taking an ARM vs a fixed is a bet on whether rates are going to stay the same or decrease, vs increase

It's also taking a bet on how long you're going to keep the mortgage. When a bank offers a lower rate for a 7 ARM vs 30 fixed, they're assuming that you will keep the mortgage for more than 7 years. If you pay it off fully before then, you win the bet.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by codefreeordie on Thursday May 19, 2022 @11:22PM (#31442997)
Before I gave up on buying a house this year, I was considering an ARM. Why? Because it meant I could qualify for an extra $100k, which gave me a better chance of being able to acquire a house.

It didn't matter whether an ARM was better or worse in the long run, it mattered that the ARM could get the house and the fixed rate could not.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by grahamperich on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:11PM (#31438797)
With rates climbing to 5%+ in the last couple months, a 3% ARM (with the hope they could refi to a low interest 30yr fixed before the ARM becomes adjustable) may have been attractive for some..
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by x86_64Ubuntu on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:49PM (#31437864)
I thought 2008 was because 'D' grade mortgages were repackaged into 'AAA' grade securities. When the 'D' grade folks missed payments and defaulted, it brought everything down because their securities had tainted so much of the landscape.
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by Finnucane on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:10PM (#31438120)
That was one factor. There was no single cause, but a fragile interconnected web of factors.

But yes, subprime loans were carved up and repacked in a way to make them look like AAA bonds. The banks that created these bonds knew that the loans in the bonds were crap; they knowingly lied to investors about it. The ratings agencies stamped all the bonds without any due diligence. Other banks piled on more derivative products on top of those bonds, essentially gambling on whether those bonds would go bad.

There was a slime-trail of fraud, laziness, and greed all the way back the original loan itself.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by yardie on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:36PM (#31438391)
2008 was a lot of 'AAA' grade securities not being able to find a greater fool to keep the profit train running. A lot of financial instruments were basically repacking and reselling loans with a bit of interest on top. Once there were no more new buyers it was a cascade of margin calls.

Subprime was a very small cause of the GFC but it was the tipping point that brought the house down.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by fundad on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:22PM (#31438239)
The article's subhead lists everything but mortgage: car loans, personal loans and credit card debt. That's where the growth has been. I remember hearing about 7 year car loans being a risky way to sell more more car loan for the same monthly budget.

There was also record high amounts paid back in 2020. I'd like to know if they adjust for that or just more fear-mongering by big banks, admitedly I'm too cheap to read further to find out.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by bogomipz on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:03PM (#31438692)
Why would someone have opted for for an adjustable rate mortgage that adjusts after 5-7 years when they could have locked in a historic low rate for 30 years?
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by mrep on Friday May 20, 2022 @12:08AM (#31443253)
I just got a 10/1 ARM because second home rates spiked recently [0] so the ARM was a lot lower (I think 1.125%) than a 30 year fixed.

[0]: https://www.ezhomesearch.com/blog/second-home-mortgage-rates....

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by localhost on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:11PM (#31438800)
In my case it’s because I don’t anticipate being in the house longer than the rate lock period
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by bogomipz on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:41PM (#31440534)
Out of curiosity did you get a 5 o 7 year? What was the differential between adjustable and fixed?
Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by incomingpain on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:35PM (#31438372)
>Given the very low interest rates in 21-22 and high prices, a certain percentage of folks would have purchased with a convertible mortgage.

The 'certain percentage' actually went over 50% of new mortgages, excluding refinancing.

>Assuming the standard 5-1 and the fact that rates are rising very fast, should we expect a repeat of 2008 in 2026-2027?

You would think so but no. We should expect it in 2022 primarily harming the large cities.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by treis on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:01PM (#31438014)
ARMs were not the problem in 08. The problem in 08 was interest only loans and/or balloon payments. Borrowers were intending to refinance before those deadlines hit but got stuck once values stopped rising. So they faced payments of 10s of thousands and/or their monthly payment was going to double or triple once they had to start paying principle down.

In contrast, if your arm resets from 3% to 7% it's like a 50% increase in mortgage payments. That sucks, but manageable given that your salary likely inflated along with your payment.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by ziddoap on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:05PM (#31438070)
>but manageable given that your salary likely inflated along with your payment.

Which, anecdotally, has not been true for myself or any of my colleagues (barring the ol' job switch raise). Wage stagnation is an extremely common problem in many countries and industries. Those that have gotten or negotiated for raises aren't getting raises that account for the record-setting inflation (at least in my country, which is seeing the highest rates of inflation in 30+ years)

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by hbosch on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:13PM (#31438152)
>That sucks, but manageable given that your salary likely inflated along with your payment.

Can I reside in a world where my salary doubles if my mortgage rate doubles? It sounds very nice.

Re:More Subprime Borrowers Are Missing Loan Payments by sokoloff on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:44PM (#31438471)
That's not the most analogous comparison; the most analogous comparison would be "where my rate of salary increase follows the changing interest rate on my mortgage".

It's not that your $100K salary should go to $200K if your mortgage goes from 3% to 6%, but rather that your $100K salary should go to $106K instead of just $103K if your mortgage goes from 3% to 6%.

Similarly, if your mortgage fell from 3% to 2%, you'd be pretty close to even if next year's salary went to $102K and likely in bad shape if it instead went to $67K.