It’s not even close.
I do not want our civil liberties eroded in any way because of mass shootings. Government always uses emotional tragedies to grab authoritarian power.
> Government always uses emotional tragedies to grab authoritarian power
Is that what you think is happening here? If so, could you please elaborate on why you think this?
* "We should better monitor these sites" might be an entirely valid conclusion.*
No, we should not have to monitor sites for the minuscule chance that a psychopath is planning a mass shooting. Senators are already pushing this type of surveillance on social media, it's a matter of time before this type of surveillance is used against thought crimes, and people that don't agree with the establishment.
Be careful that you're not inadvertently asking for social media to be regulated more like cars.
Fortunately, however, there are plenty of countries that have fewer mass shootings and arguably better protection of civil liberties than the US, so they might provide some inspiration.
I mean, to take my car out in public, I'm required to have a license, registration, inspection, various safety devices, and follow a variety of usage rules.
Not buying it.
The airbag requirements certainly have nothing to do with it, either.
Across the whole nation we have a fairly substantial set of restrictions on what you can and can't own, regardless of whether or not you only ever use it on private property (there are no such restrictions for cars).
So the net effect would be mostly no change in public and a massive net loosening of restrictions in private.
Personally I'm fine with this. But I think you'll probably be clamoring to have the status qou back as soon as your local extremists start posting youtube videos of 14yos firing mortars at their summer BBQ.
But if your argument hinges on "mass shootings aren't a big deal" than let's agree to disagree.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mass_shootings_in_th...
19 384 homicides in total.
It is probably a better comparison than car deaths.
Also, check out the cases where Section 230 has been used [1]. Without it, sites would have to prevent defamation (i.e., they need to know whether any content is untrue). Libraries would not provide computers connected to the internet.
Repealing Section 230 is a "common sense" proposal that falls apart when considering the actual results. If there's a good proposal for a replacement, I haven't seen it.
False positives are already awful without adding legal liability for not acting to the mix.
"We should better monitor these sites" might be an entirely valid conclusion.