The G stands for governance, including: "Governance deals with a company’s leadership, executive pay, audits, internal controls, and shareholder rights"[0].
Do you think Tesla is a model there?
[0]https://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/environmental-social-an...
The people pushing "ESG" anything only care about marketing some product to the virtue signalers.
I bet most people who buy this index see "ESG", pat themselves on the back and never even look at the component companies. Check it our for yourself: [0]
Apple, Exxon, JPMorgan in the top 10. Still think this is legit?
[0] https://cms.zerohedge.com/s3/files/inline-images/2022-05-18_...
This is an unfalsifiable claim without citing when Musk made the purported transgression.
I don't think it is TOO cynical to assume that often people do things based on some hidden motivation vs. their publicly stated reason.
Weigh my opinion however you'd like but the conclusion I made seems to fit quite well.
> toe the line and stick to the script
What message and what script? The whole purpose of the index is to make money. The movement and everyone in the movement gets paid $$$ if when you plot the ESG index and broad equities the ESG line comes out on top.
I doubt the intent is to quiet Elon but most likely meant as a warning to other Plutocrats/CEOs to ensure they toe the line and stick to the script.