In some regards this is good, but my gut says this will generally benefit the companies that know how to play the game and manipulate / move just the right numbers to limit costs, but still end up on these lists.
If the oil is easily accessible such as the oil extracted by Aramco in Saudi Arabia or Bahrain (where you have to essentially just stick a straw in the sand and oil comes out), it's no wonder that the amount of emission to complete the process is far less than an energy intensive operation such as manufacturing an electric tank such as the Cyphertruck or to a lesser extent the Model Y.
Simple and farcical.
Seems to just make ESG look ridiculous.
Drug cartels rank high on my "Community Benefit Metric" because they provide jobs for the community and only do what they must to manufacture and sell drugs /s
There is nothing to agree or disagree... it's simple physics. If we want to politicize physics then we can go forward and politicize physics too. But at least we should be conscious about it.
Like, if you make it harder for those who burn oil to raise capital, does that mean that there are fewer customers for the people who extract it? Does it hurt their profits?
Is this all passed on, magically, by the Efficient Market?
I suspect not.
2) Yes, it's exactly like that, punishing those who burn oil hurts those who mine oil, if it doesn't it only means that those who burn oil found a way to hide from ESG rating by becoming a private company and getting financed elsewhere eg. via private equity or using old fashioned bank loans and credit lines, or even by convincing clients to pay in advance or with less delay.
Actions and desires have consequences, the passion that people have for climate change has consequences, when you wanna get to zero you don't get to skip anything and even companies which people are emotionally attached to (such as Tesla) have to comply.
With regards to "E" doesn't really matter if the CEO says that the company "is doing more for the environment than any other company ever" , people making such scores are paid to completely sidestep this sort of socio-political talk and just look at factories, their impact on the environent, plans to reduce waste, recycling etc.
An other thing that's important is a comprehensive plan which is put on paper and can be referred to in the future to evaluate if the company kept its promises or is lagging behind. Yeah...
These people at S&P, Moody, Fitch they are essentially faceless individuals who look at spreadsheets and numbers, he won't be able to pressure them into compliance like he does with people on twitter. Mostly because they aren't on twitter, don't care about politics, don't care about him, basically don't even care about ESG and just want to be paid as the number crunchers they are. In one word they are Musk' nemesis: a non-ideology driven number cruncher.