News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Job interviews that go too far by mattcwilson on Monday May 16, 2022 @08:47AM (#31396318)
I’m confused - are we underpaid?

If people from all those other industries are scrambling to break into tech because it’s so lucrative, what is it you or I are bringing to the table that they couldn’t?

Re:Job interviews that go too far by bluGill on Monday May 16, 2022 @08:56AM (#31396435)
You can be both underpaid and paid far more than most people. Different jobs have different values, and so someone in a correctly paid job can still make more money by switching to an underpaid position that has far more value.

Of course in reality pay is about to supply and demand, not value. Thus underpaid just means you haven't found it worth your while to switch to a job that pays better. There might be good reasons for this.

Re:Job interviews that go too far by mattcwilson on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:06AM (#31396553)
If I’m satisfied enough with the money I’m getting for the position I’m working that I’m not looking to leave, how is that not just “paid?”

Flipping it around, if the company isn’t ready to fire me for underperforming, does that make underworked?

Re:Job interviews that go too far by Clubber on Monday May 16, 2022 @08:53AM (#31396400)
I dunno, but I would guess tech ability.

>I’m confused - are we underpaid?

Most certainly yes. If nothing else, just by nature of corporations setting "market rates," or at least defining the position and what they are willing to pay.

Another example, that famous productivity pay gap chart? Most of that is through automation done by computerization.

https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/

Re:Job interviews that go too far by mattcwilson on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:08AM (#31396587)
If you set a house for sale at the “market rate,” are you getting less than you’re supposed to?
Re:Job interviews that go too far by lapcat on Monday May 16, 2022 @10:05AM (#31397391)
An interesting thing about the real estate market is that most buyers and sellers hire an agent, who likely knows much more about the market than you do personally.

As far as I've seen, job seekers in most industries rarely hire agents. The information differential between buyers and sellers in the labor market is vast.

I'm not saying job seekers should hire agents. I'm not saying they shouldn't either though...

Re:Job interviews that go too far by ThrowawayR2 on Monday May 16, 2022 @11:11AM (#31398599)
> "As far as I've seen, job seekers in most industries rarely hire agents."

If software job seekers hired agents, it would be the agents (the reputable ones anyway) that would require stringent testing of the seekers. One has to know exactly what one is selling to get the best price for the sale; they're not going to take the seeker's word for it any more than an employer would.

Re:Job interviews that go too far by lapcat on Monday May 16, 2022 @11:20AM (#31398754)
> it would be the agents (the reputable ones anyway) that would require stringent testing of the seekers

That's a great way to get zero clients. ;-) It's one thing to go through all that crap to get a job, but who wants to go through all that crap just to get an agent? Not to mention, how is an agent even qualified to give a technical test to a software engineer.

In real estate, a home inspection is required by the buyer's agent, not by the seller's agent. Sellers would rather not have that contingency. And the home inspection is only performed after the offer is accepted.

Re:Job interviews that go too far by ThrowawayR2 on Monday May 16, 2022 @11:44AM (#31399115)
An agent that sells dud employees to employers will have zero clients much, much faster. An agent with a high placement and retention rate, well, people will be lined up around the block to become their clients. So ;-) right back 'atchya, sport.

As for houses, they can be visually be examined by the seller's agent. They are not going to take the seller's word for it that it has four bedrooms when they can see it only has two and are certainly not going to try to sell it as if it had four.

Re:Job interviews that go too far by lapcat on Monday May 16, 2022 @11:57AM (#31399319)
> An agent that sells dud employees to employers will have zero clients much, much faster. An agent with a high placement and retention rate, well, people will be lined up around the block to become their clients.

A new agent starts with zero clients. The beginning is "faster" than anything. You can't place any clients if you don't have any, so this is putting the cart before the horse.

> As for houses, they can be visually be examined by the seller's agent. They are not going to take the seller's word for it that it has four bedrooms when they can see it only has two.

Of course. But the linked article is "The 'working' job interviews that go too far". It discusses huge time-consuming pre-hire projects. This is not at all comparable to a walkthrough of a house. I've bought and sold, personally experienced the real estate market on both sides.

Addendum:

The seller's agent doesn't walk through the house to check whether the seller is lying about the number of rooms. Any buyer who goes to a showing will see the number of rooms immediately, nobody can get away with lying about that. The seller's agent walks through the house to estimate the list price of the house, to give the seller advice on how to best present the house, and to gather information for buyer questions. Also they need to take photos for the listing.

I think you're misunderstanding the role of a real estate agent. The seller's agent is not the seller. The transaction is still directly between the seller and the buyer. Nobody buys a house because of the "reputation" of the seller's agent, that would be insanity. The purpose of an agent is to help their client through the process and give them advice. The seller's agent may hold open houses, but it's actually the buyer's agent who usually takes the buyer on a personal showing, so the seller's agent is not even there to "sell" the house to the buyer.

A home inspection is not conducted by a real estate agent, it's conducted by a professional home inspector, it costs hundreds of dollars, it's paid for by the buyer, and it's not done until after the offer is accepted.

I'm going on at length here because these facts should be obvious to anyone who has been on the real estate market. The way you describe agents in your imagination is not how real agents behave.

Re:Job interviews that go too far by Clubber on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:35AM (#31396953)
Define the market rate, that's the trick. If I define the market rate and I'm the only one to do that, I say your $200K house is really only $180K, then that's what payers will be willing to pay assuming a not-fire market. Right now, it's a seller's housing market, it's also a seller's market in tech. One market has sky-high prices, one does not.
Re:Job interviews that go too far by mattcwilson on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:46AM (#31397086)
But isn’t that idea - the level at which both sides agree the transaction is “worthwhile” / the arrangement is “worth keeping” the definition of “market rate?”

Price is what the market will bear, all that?

In your example, I have two options. I take your “lowball,” grumble about it, etc - but I also establish that evidently my house is worth $180K.

Or, I sit back and wait, grumble about it, etc, and see if in fact my house is worth $200K after all. And then that gives you two options; both involve grumbling, one involves establishing a “market rate”

Re:Job interviews that go too far by Clubber on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:50AM (#31397154)
There's all kinda of things in the labor market to pressure lower prices than the housing market. For example, H1B visas, offshoring, etc.

Also, if people don't work, they starve, so there is an incentive to take a job whether it's a good one that pays what they need or not. This also doesn't exist in a housing market.

Comparing the labor market to the housing market only works if you squint and don't compare it too long.

Re:Job interviews that go too far by mattcwilson on Monday May 16, 2022 @11:44AM (#31399113)
I acknowledge that analogies fail at a certain remove. I wasn’t particularly trying to make a comparison to the housing market, it was just the example that sprang to mind. Any market should operate similarly, no? Buyers and sellers negotiating over what they consider acceptable terms of exchange?

Regarding the “things... [which] pressure lower prices,” how do you account for the record high pay in the US tech sector [1], or pay increases being greater than the overall US average over the past several years [2]?

I suppose I’m just wondering how much of this is real examples of corporate malfeasance / runaway capitalism / extortionate price extraction and how much of it is standard side-effects of the way markets operate.

[1] https://www.zdnet.com/google-amp/article/tech-salaries-just-...

[2] https://www.hrdive.com/news/high-performing-tech-workers-see...

Re:Job interviews that go too far by Clubber on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:22PM (#31400582)
>Any market should operate similarly, no?

Ya if you ignore all the forces on that market, supply and demand forces work great in a vacuum. Unfortunately everyone remembers chapter 1 of their Econ book but forgets chapter 2+ (myself included). There are a lot of ways to manipulate those supply and demand forces. Employers certainly have a lot more power to manipulate them than employees do. "Market wages," are one. Who says they are market wages and wages for what position?

>[1] https://www.zdnet.com/google-amp/article/tech-salaries-just-...

I think articles like these try to lump everyone as a "technologist," and it's too broad a category to be useful information.

>A "widespread hunger" for technology professionals has see the average salary for technologists in the US hit a record high of $104,566

Imagine that was "healthcare workers," where they averaged in the salaries of the doctors, neurosurgeons, hospital administration and all the high paid workers, then ponder why nurses think they are underpaid when the average healthcare worker salary is $200K a year. They are misrepresenting what nurses make by obfuscating their actual wage/hours with "average healthcare worker salary."

This also goes back to the "average market wages," discussion. If a company tried to hire an architect and said that they pay market wages, but the market wages they site are the average of all technology workers, the salary would be considered low for the architect. Depending on his circumstance, he might be willing to take it though.

>real examples of corporate malfeasance / runaway capitalism / extortionate price extraction and how much of it is standard side-effects of the way markets operate.

I think it's both. The big problem is the government opened the doors with free trade and H1B visas and it really hurt US workers. Sure it arguably helps the poor in other countries to a degree, but it really helps corporations; both at the expense of the US worker. Those laws probably weren't enacted for the long term benefit of the constituency.

Re:Job interviews that go too far by mattcwilson on Monday May 16, 2022 @08:14PM (#31404563)
I am sincerely having difficulty parsing your argument.

I think you are saying:

1. Despite the news articles, tech workers by and large are underpaid.

2. Some exceptions to 1 exist that are sufficiently large and outsized that they are carrying the average. After discounting those individuals, tech wages are below what they should be.

3. Free trade and H1B visas are allowing large numbers of non-US tech talent into the hiring supply; this is driving down wages at the expense of the American tech worker.

4. Regardless of the fact that the supply of these workers is driving down wages as econ 1 would dictate, actual market wages should be much higher, because... (this is where I’m losing you)?

Re:Job interviews that go too far by formerkrogemp on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @11:35PM (#31418985)
I'm not the person you were discussing this with. I posted the first post about this up thread I think. I think you did a good job of summarizing the sentiment, yes. On 3, I think immigration is good, but it can also depress wages. I agree with 1 and 2 generally. On 4, I think that the revenue per employee in the tech industry vs salary is absolutely ridiculous and that tech workers need a union or higher wages across the industry. I would like to see a higher share of profits going to labor more generally rather than capital. I'm not against profit, but I think that the American worker has been cheated out wages correlating with rising productivity. Now I'm not saying that corporations are holding workers at gunpoint with a ski mask. You should dismiss that mental image. However, Mr. Wilson, I hope that you consider, with all of the retirements and demographics favoring workers now, that this could be a seminal moment for workers to organize and achieve fair wages for perhaps the first time in 40 years. However, outsourcing, scope creep, up-skilling, and automation are all factors, broadly, that could depress wage or job growth or neuter labor organization and rights. Stagnation and inflation could take bites out of the metaphorical apple as well. I'm not denying (most?) tech workers are paid highly relative to other industries. I think for the revenue that they generate or that they protect that they ought to be paid more. However, I think the stress/pay disparity with other industries has and will attract a lot of talent to IT and programming that could depress wages. Nurses, waiters, grocery workers, retail workers, and so forth aren't being paid enough to work in many places or commensurate with the working conditions or education or abuse from customers. There's too much to say and not enough space/time. I hope that summarizes my take on the issue for you, Mr. Wilson.
Re:Job interviews that go too far by mattcwilson on Saturday May 21, 2022 @06:51PM (#31462852)
I appreciate you taking time to reply to the thread.

I’m still struggling to understand the logic whereby tech workers, being overpaid relative to those other industries (so much so that there’s a brisk business and a lot of interest in bootcamps and tech training), are unfairly affected by this system and should unionize.

I think it’s amazing that we’re increasing the talent pool, diversity, and technical literacy of the American workforce. I think it’s remarkable that the barriers to entry into the space are so low, and the potential for improvement so high. I think the opportunity boundary for technological innovation is broad, and the barriers to entry similarly low, that the best possible answer to the current situation to drive even more money to even more people is to keep innovating, keep creating tech businesses, and keep pulling in and expanding that talent pool.

Which, perhaps, will in turn start applying sufficient scarcity effects on nursing, service workers, and so forth that wages inevitably increase there and/or the threshold gets met for tech innovation in those spaces to even further lift the bar for what we can all benefit from in those aspects of our lives.

Saying tech workers are underpaid when there are so many people making bananas levels of income relative to those other economic sectors is tonedeaf af, imo. What am I missing?

Again - thank you for taking the time to reply.

Re:Job interviews that go too far by cumshitpiss on Monday May 16, 2022 @08:55AM (#31396420)
You're underpaid by definition if the company reports a revenue >0.

If your labor was compensated for the actual value it produced, no company could turn a profit. Thats the fundamental problem of capitalism

Re:Job interviews that go too far by bluGill on Monday May 16, 2022 @08:59AM (#31396483)
You fail to appreciate the value provided by capital. The work I do today will earn my company zero this year, since the code won't be released to production yet. (in embedded we don't have the luxury of releasing on each push). Capital provides the pay I need to work today and will recover it over the next few years.
Re:Job interviews that go too far by cumshitpiss on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:17AM (#31396706)
sure, but thats not revenue and doesnt contradict what i wrote above. The revenue of year 2 replaces the investment of year 1, everything beyond is unbounded profit. Whether capital investment earns the right to sole access of those profits is the question.

You can see before your eyes what happens when the answer to that question is "Yes".