Regarding the “things... [which] pressure lower prices,” how do you account for the record high pay in the US tech sector [1], or pay increases being greater than the overall US average over the past several years [2]?
I suppose I’m just wondering how much of this is real examples of corporate malfeasance / runaway capitalism / extortionate price extraction and how much of it is standard side-effects of the way markets operate.
[1] https://www.zdnet.com/google-amp/article/tech-salaries-just-...
[2] https://www.hrdive.com/news/high-performing-tech-workers-see...
Ya if you ignore all the forces on that market, supply and demand forces work great in a vacuum. Unfortunately everyone remembers chapter 1 of their Econ book but forgets chapter 2+ (myself included). There are a lot of ways to manipulate those supply and demand forces. Employers certainly have a lot more power to manipulate them than employees do. "Market wages," are one. Who says they are market wages and wages for what position?
>[1] https://www.zdnet.com/google-amp/article/tech-salaries-just-...
I think articles like these try to lump everyone as a "technologist," and it's too broad a category to be useful information.
>A "widespread hunger" for technology professionals has see the average salary for technologists in the US hit a record high of $104,566
Imagine that was "healthcare workers," where they averaged in the salaries of the doctors, neurosurgeons, hospital administration and all the high paid workers, then ponder why nurses think they are underpaid when the average healthcare worker salary is $200K a year. They are misrepresenting what nurses make by obfuscating their actual wage/hours with "average healthcare worker salary."
This also goes back to the "average market wages," discussion. If a company tried to hire an architect and said that they pay market wages, but the market wages they site are the average of all technology workers, the salary would be considered low for the architect. Depending on his circumstance, he might be willing to take it though.
>real examples of corporate malfeasance / runaway capitalism / extortionate price extraction and how much of it is standard side-effects of the way markets operate.
I think it's both. The big problem is the government opened the doors with free trade and H1B visas and it really hurt US workers. Sure it arguably helps the poor in other countries to a degree, but it really helps corporations; both at the expense of the US worker. Those laws probably weren't enacted for the long term benefit of the constituency.
I think you are saying:
1. Despite the news articles, tech workers by and large are underpaid.
2. Some exceptions to 1 exist that are sufficiently large and outsized that they are carrying the average. After discounting those individuals, tech wages are below what they should be.
3. Free trade and H1B visas are allowing large numbers of non-US tech talent into the hiring supply; this is driving down wages at the expense of the American tech worker.
4. Regardless of the fact that the supply of these workers is driving down wages as econ 1 would dictate, actual market wages should be much higher, because... (this is where I’m losing you)?
I’m still struggling to understand the logic whereby tech workers, being overpaid relative to those other industries (so much so that there’s a brisk business and a lot of interest in bootcamps and tech training), are unfairly affected by this system and should unionize.
I think it’s amazing that we’re increasing the talent pool, diversity, and technical literacy of the American workforce. I think it’s remarkable that the barriers to entry into the space are so low, and the potential for improvement so high. I think the opportunity boundary for technological innovation is broad, and the barriers to entry similarly low, that the best possible answer to the current situation to drive even more money to even more people is to keep innovating, keep creating tech businesses, and keep pulling in and expanding that talent pool.
Which, perhaps, will in turn start applying sufficient scarcity effects on nursing, service workers, and so forth that wages inevitably increase there and/or the threshold gets met for tech innovation in those spaces to even further lift the bar for what we can all benefit from in those aspects of our lives.
Saying tech workers are underpaid when there are so many people making bananas levels of income relative to those other economic sectors is tonedeaf af, imo. What am I missing?
Again - thank you for taking the time to reply.
Also, if people don't work, they starve, so there is an incentive to take a job whether it's a good one that pays what they need or not. This also doesn't exist in a housing market.
Comparing the labor market to the housing market only works if you squint and don't compare it too long.