Re:Musk: Twitter legal said I violated NDA by revealing bot ...
by ergocoder on Sunday May 15, 2022 @08:52PM
(#31392712)
I meant it was mundane in the way that any stat new grad could have come up with this methodology.
If you give anyone 5 seconds to come up with a methodology to check for bot, they would probably come up with "yeah, let's sample 100 of our followers and check manually".
It is the most obvious simplest method that it surprises me twitter can even call this trade secret under NDA.
Re:Musk: Twitter legal said I violated NDA by revealing bot ...
by HWR_14 on Monday May 16, 2022 @12:54PM
(#31400187)
Here's an example of something more obvious. We have a new finance grad. He comes up with the methodology of "let's take all the corporate profit for the quarter, divide it by the outstanding shares, and distribute it". It's a bit simple, but it's fine. However, if you know that comes out to $7.22/share and announce that ahead of the announcement, you would breach your NDA. It's just a stupid number, but it means something.
Similarly, the fact that Twitter used 100, instead of 1000 or 2700 gives you error bars. It means something.
Semi-unrelated: a new stat grad would almost certainly not choose 100. They would feel compelled to run some math and come up with a different sample size that matched the results of some equations for power analysis, etc.
It's not like the NDA says "keep our secrets unless you think they're too boring to keep". It says "anything marked in the following way is a secret you cannot reveal." If Musk thought that was public knowledge, he could fight them in court. Of course, that would torpedo his "this is new information to me, I need to get out of the TWTR acquisition" claims.