There are various ways one can immigrate to the US now, such as H-1B, DV, asylum, illegally, etc. I think only H-1B requires proof of employment before entering. I think the requirements previously may have filtered a lot of people in spite of education and net worth. Also, I am not sure what qualifies as being educated back then since having a bachelor's degree was a lot less common than it is now.
I love the idea of the diversity visa lottery, I think it's a great way to spice up the population. But mass immigration of low educated individuals is not good, they won't integrate as well as highly skilled workers.
Also, in the 1800s, you needed millions of farm workers, miners, rail workers etc. These jobs were dangerous, no skill required, no language required, making it feasible to just import whatever immigrants you can. Today it's not the case, with such a sophisticated economy.
It’s not clear to me the highly educated individuals are integrating well. (E.g. high caste Indians bringing caste-based elitism to the U.S.) They're obviously prospering but that's somewhat different.
https://www.brownpundits.com/2021/06/27/indian-american-surv...
https://books.google.com/books?id=Tj1E7-j8w1MC&pg=PA290&lpg=...
Just look at the bigger picture: when the US imported large amounts of un-vetted immigrants, you had several ethnic based gangs. The Italian mafia was hard to get rid off once established, but in general you didn't have new ones popping up - that stopped with tougher immigration.
Now the only ethnic based gangs are the Spanish speaking ones...it's such a coincidence that the latino gangs started around the time of mass immigration...
“One historian described the typical German immigrant as a poor farmer or artisan who arrived around 1750 with a wife and two children. They were most likely in debt for the passage across the Atlantic but had family or friends already settled in America. They were affiliated with the Lutheran or Reformed church but only loosely committed to an organized religion. Records indicate that they became prosperous members of the community. However, many were too poor to pay the transatlantic passage so as many as one-half to two-third of German immigrants came to Pennsylvania as indentured servants or redemptioners, as Germans called them.”