News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel's New Chimera: Alder Lake by zdragnar on Sunday May 15, 2022 @03:34AM (#31385925)
I thought the secret sauce to M1 was largely that it was a new architecture, without the decades of x86 backwards compatible baggage, with an OS and software capable of running natively on it?
Re:Intel's New Chimera: Alder Lake by lstamour on Sunday May 15, 2022 @03:48AM (#31385983)
Both, sort of. The secret sauce to M1 battery life is a combination of OS thread scheduling and efficiency cores. The secret sauce to M1 performance is having an architecture that doesn’t need to be thermal throttled as much as in other platforms.

It’s not that Apple invented chips that are remarkably faster than Intel’s or NVIDIA’s, it’s that Apple invented an integrated experience on this new architecture with split performance & efficiency cores and did so while maintaining backwards compatibility with macOS x86 apps in a way that’s indistinguishable from M1-native apps. (So they kept the “baggage” as it were, and it still performs fine.)

I expect Microsoft’s Surface line will catch up eventually, but the disconnect between Qualcomm/Intel as chip makers and Microsoft as OS vendor will slow down the transition for a good 4-6 years easy, and we’re 2 years into this transition to ultra-energy efficient architectures with less thermal throttling. (Full disclosure, I’ve a few Apple shares.)

Re:Intel's New Chimera: Alder Lake by nicolaslem on Sunday May 15, 2022 @04:06AM (#31386056)
The secret sauce is most likely TSMC 5nm.
Re:Intel's New Chimera: Alder Lake by astrange on Sunday May 15, 2022 @06:13AM (#31386562)
No, that’s cope. There isn’t any secret sauce. It’s just well designed on every level.

You won’t match its power/performance by doing one thing and suddenly making it there. Intel’s process is quite close to TSMC’s already.

Re:Intel's New Chimera: Alder Lake by mhh__ on Sunday May 15, 2022 @11:33AM (#31388172)
It's quite close to the process AMD are on but not 5nm that apple use.

A lot of M1's advantage is in terms of density. That's why they were theoretically able to make such an absolutely enormous processor and keep it cool.

Making that theory work in practice came from decades of low power semi experience. They're extremely good chip designers.

Re:Intel's New Chimera: Alder Lake by tyrfing on Sunday May 15, 2022 @02:59PM (#31390007)
The Alder Lake node is about equivalent to TSMC's N7, maybe 10% better. N5, the node Apple is using for M1, is about 1.8x the density of N7 with 40% lower power usage.

AMD and Intel are on similar nodes at the moment, but Apple has a very notable advantage. It's not "secret sauce" so much as paying many billions for exclusive access.

Re:Intel's New Chimera: Alder Lake by justsomehnguy on Sunday May 15, 2022 @06:22AM (#31386598)
> that it was a new architecture

This is the biggest part of the 'sauce' but having E-cores and extremely close memory (faster memory access - less time the cores need to wait for data - less time spent doing nothing and burning watts) surely helps.