News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by mrtksn on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @02:44AM (#31324206)
Passwords are extremely counterintuitive and require understanding of the architecture of the systems to make any sense of it. Why do you need a password to your phone and then why do you need a password for the apps and websites? Why do you need an SMS and why do you need a code generator? Why do you sign in into your Google account to sign in into Stackexchange? None of that makes unless you understand the distinctions between systems and all that happens when we race to make the experience seamless as if there's no distinctions. It's getting so messy that phishing becomes hard to detect even for the more experienced people, you simply follow the instructions of typing codes and clicking links.

It only makes sense to have a device that can identify you personally and then use that device to get identified to other systems. That's actually why anonymous accounts and fingerprinting are very effective in tracking people(remember that companies like FB can identify you without you ever creating an account with them).

Passwords only use is account sharing IMHO. Once everyone goes passwords-less, sharing a Netflix account will be a thing of the past for example. Maybe this is one of the motivations of the big tech but overall I think it's for the greater good and sharing a service will be served better through explicit means of sharing the service.

Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by alaricus on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @08:48AM (#31326429)
This sounds dystopian and also really bad engineering.

First, I don't want a single login for everywhere. For obvious privacy reasons, using multiple disjoint accounts is preferable.

Second, using a device to identify someone creates a single point of failure. That device will get stolen or will break at the most inconvenient time. The battery will run out. Or something else will happen.

This is far from theoretical. My phone died on a business trip. It turned into a nightmare because almost everything needs two factor authentication. It's really bad not being able to spend money you have. That is when I learned the value of cash.

The obsession with passwordless logins and 2FA is anti-consumer. It needs to stop.

Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by mrtksn on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @09:10AM (#31326664)
> For obvious privacy reasons, using multiple disjoint accounts is preferable.

Actually, the reasons are not as obvious as one might think and not as preferable as assumed. Disjoint anonymous accounts are one of the core reason for all the problems we have on the internet(there are much more spammers and manipulators than there are whistleblowers).

I'm sure you are exposing corruption all the time or you are doing gay stuff in Iran but the majority of the anonymous activity is spamming, trolling or political manipulation.

If you say why you need anonymous account we might work out a solution for you.

Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by alaricus on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @09:12AM (#31326687)
Is this serious or a bad attempt at sarcasm?
Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by mrtksn on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @09:17AM (#31326739)
I don't know why you think I'm not serious because trolls spam and political manipulation is a thing on the internet these days, Google it! Care to answer and further explain your arguments?
Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by wvh on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @09:54AM (#31327129)
Because people tell you their name if they want to, and give you their thoughts if they choose to do so. Having your name available to all at any time and anything you've ever said regardless of context or without limits to the intended audience is madness. It's a freedom we should not be willing to give up so easily because of technology.

On top of that, having all that personal information available will actually increase the power of trolls and political manipulation, not to mention exacerbate identity theft, profiling, security and phishing problems.

Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by mrtksn on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @10:04AM (#31327249)
You don't have to give your name to anyone. Single sign in implies a single person but doesn't need to have any more information on that person and even if it has the info doesn't have to share it with anyone.
Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by alaricus on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @09:21AM (#31326777)
It's really serious? Wow! Not even Microsoft TPMs write such nonsense.

Forcing people to have a single ID across the web is a terrible idea. Having multiple disjoint accounts makes it much more difficult to track your activity online. It's not worth killing privacy just to stop a couple of annoying spammers.

Of course Google/Facebook/Microsoft love the idea because it makes tracking user behaviour much more easier.

[dead]
Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by feanaro on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @02:16PM (#31330472)
How does Facebook have this magical power for which you provide no explanation? Of course, there is no such magical power. The trick works if you allow it, that is unless you block it with technical means. After all, you are still in control of your computer, so if you block the information they use to track you, they won't be able to track you. Thus, it is not sufficient reason to force the implementation of a dystopian surveillance machine.
Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by mrtksn on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @01:07AM (#31336025)
No, no magical tricks. They do device and browser fingerprinting, essentially they can detect you across the internet and in real life through your device networks, device identifiers like MAC address, device specs and configuration.
Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by feanaro on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @10:32AM (#31340521)
All of these information sources can be sanitized so that the entropy they give off is reduced. See efforts by the Tor Browser and Firefox on reducing the effect of fingerprinting. Additionally, your MAC address is not exposed over the internet, just to the next hop.

I'll repeat what I said:

> Thus, it is not sufficient reason to force the implementation of a dystopian surveillance machine.

[dead]
Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by mrtksn on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @09:40AM (#31327003)
See, this behavior is absurd in real life and I should have been able to avoid speaking with you so I don't waste my time. The anonymity gives you a shield against it and I don't think this is something healthy. Why I'm being called a troll for pushing an argument? Because of people like you, we can't have healthy arguments anymore because calling someone names without repercussions has become the norm even beyond kindergarten.
Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by feanaro on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @02:18PM (#31330497)
> Maybe you should study these things and come back later when you know what are you talking about?

You were extremely condescending and rude in your argument. That's why you were called a troll.

Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by alaricus on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @09:50AM (#31327097)
if we had a single sign in system, you would have been banned from the internet already :)
Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by mschuster91 on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @05:30AM (#31325117)
> It only makes sense to have a device that can identify you personally and then use that device to get identified to other systems.

What to do then if the device gets lost, damaged, soft-bricked, or worst case seized by the police?

Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by mrtksn on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @05:47AM (#31325205)
You get a replacement if lost or broken. Then re-authenticate and restore from a backup. That's how it's done with iPhones.

And about the police, you destroy or lock your device. If that's not %100 secure, it's OK because that's part of the risks about going against the authority. Can you imagine revolutionaries not revolting because the police might hit back? The risk of being caught by the police is part of the outlaw experience and you will need to actively try to avoid it.

Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by account-5 on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @06:53AM (#31325567)
Who's providing the back up? How do you re-authenticate if you lost the thing you use to authenticate with?

It's easy saying it but I don't understand how you do those things. If the answer is you need a password to access the backup and to access an account to re-authenticate, I'm not enjoying the irony. If the answer is to trust a company like Apple, Google, Microsoft with the literal keys to my kingdom then this thing misses the point.

Currently I'm in control of my authentication, why would I hand that to some company and hope I don't annoy them enough to ban me, or just randomly cone up against their AI guardians.

Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by mrtksn on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @07:07AM (#31325654)
On iPhone's case it's Apple and it is accessed by a password but in this hypothetical scenario it could be your own infrastructure or another device you own and that one can be password-less of that's your thing. Having one password to activate your authentication device is not a gin deal, it can be something like mnemonic seed etc.

The hazard is not one password but endless ways to authenticate through endless passwords.

Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by mschuster91 on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @07:05AM (#31325642)
> If that's not %100 secure, it's OK because that's part of the risks about going against the authority.

I was more talking about border control, which has been known especially in the US to believe that non-US citizens have no rights at all and even the rights of US citizens and permanent residents have limited rights.

And for what it's worth you can end up having your devices seized or being executed by police simply for the "crime" of being at the wrong place at the wrong time because the cops managed to fuck up the warrant or its execution by blowing up the door at the wrong address.

Police going rogue are a threat model everyone should be aware of these days.

Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by mrtksn on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @07:09AM (#31325671)
I guess the US has its problems. If that's an issue, don't go there and if you choose to go, don't bring a device with you that you can't tolerate being investigated by the authorities.

It's unreasonable to say that all your problems in life must be solved by this one tech or it's not worth having it.

Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by mschuster91 on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @07:20AM (#31325746)
The problem with police overreach is not limited to the US in any way, it's global.

Anyway, all I'm saying is that people should not leave the police out of their threat model.

Re:Apple, Google, and Microsoft commit to expanded support f... by mrtksn on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @07:52AM (#31325957)
You can't solve police overreach through an app. There's no solution to the police overreach because they have access to rubber hose cryptography.