I hope the third option is a bit more of just trying to take the situation in. This is someone sharing their experience, the executives running the show have their perspective as well. I'm not sure why we have to jump so quickly to "I found data that refutes this, is this person lying or is the data wrong?". Just seems to leave out so much nuance. Feels like a very tech industry "see the data and make a decision". This situation is so human, it's about fear and whether those fears are being considered.
I am being a bit facetious with the fiction comment.
However, I do believe there are a lot of problems in the rail industry. With the introduction of "PSR" (precision-scheduled railroading), trains actually have no schedule, and only leave when they're full. This maximizes efficiency.
It's very hard on rail staff, because it means they, too have no schedule. They work a train in one direction, do a staff change, and then go to a hotel while waiting for a return trip. They get as little as 90-120 minutes of notice for the return trip. So it's a lot of time away from home, with very little ability to control one's schedule. I imagine that this source of frustration emerges in a lot of different places, and it's possible that this letter was one of them.
This is a major frustration in a nutshell but you have to know that in addition to the short notice that they are about to get out for the return trip back home all the time they spend off duty in the hotel room counts (to the railroad) as time off, in other words it counts as if it totally belongs to them to do with as they please going about all their normal business. In reality they are in a hotel many times with limited meal options, with no way to visit family or to help out around the house, to conduct any of the other normal household business. Their time in the hotels is not their time at all to the point where the actual time they spend on a run (a round trip) can be multiple days and only a part of that time is compensated.
A recent text I had from my relative currently with a railroad gives the railroad's perspective quite clearly during a Zoom meeting - "Y'all hired out to work 24/7/365, we are going to make good employees out of you all."
I am part of a fourth generation railroad family. Three of the last four generations, beginning in 1942, have worked on the railroad. It skipped me because I went a different direction.
EDIT: I forgot to mention that the ultimate goal of the railroads is to decrease train crew size to 1. Each of these trains will be driven by a one-man train "crew". A couple decades ago normal crew size was three - engineer, brakeman, conductor. Brakeman positions were eliminated leaving the engineer and conductors rolling the trains. The railroads were supposed to be using PTC, positive train control a long time ago but were able to dodge the upgrades to track and infrastructure in the typical American corporate way by delaying using a standard set of excuses. PTC would bring about a single man crew by automating almost everything. That would mean huge loss of jobs and a huge investment in infrastructure upgrades since many thousands of miles of tracks have speed limits that are in place due to trackage that can't handle higher speeds safely. There's a lot going on here and it's always deeper than one single argument.
I think you mean "0". Full autonomy is 100% their goal!
I don't think it's that people are jumping to it as much as people are trying to identify what's actually going on. The solution for "this problem is happening more often" is different than for "this problem appears to be happening more, but is actually happening less". Applying a process change for what was a perception problem might actually make things worse. It's important to identify the problem so the correct fix can be determined.
Even if this actually is a problem but the national data belies that, that could be useful in pointing towards the problem being more localized to Iowa, and differences in that area can be looked for.
But the number of derailments dropped by more than 25% during that time, so the probability of a given car being involved in a derailed train still decreased.
There's been other coverage of the ironically named "precision scheduling" in the rail industry causing a lot of labor problems, because it makes for nightmarishly unpredictable schedules for workers. They never know when a train is going to leave until it is full, so after working a shift, workers stay in a hotel waiting for a return trip that they won't know about until 90-120 minutes ahead of departure. I am guessing that the claims around increased derailment may actually be about frustration with the work environment.
The key word here might be "US". The letter writer is specifically talking about Iowa; are state-by-state statistics available?
If you've never spent time in the Midwest, you probably have never seen a train that's a mile or longer. Endless cars of agricultural products, often high fructose corn syrup. I saw this often growing up in Iowa, never in California. In the Bay Area, freight sometimes moves along the same tracks as Caltrain at night, but the trains are tiny in comparison to those of Iowa.
For a while, I think trains in Iowa were limited by how long a train was allowed to block a roadway (IIRC 10 minutes). I think trains were sized so at least in theory they could comply with the law when at speed. The law might have changed since, and/or maybe there aren't as many at-grade crossings anymore. (A painful intersection in my home town recently got grade separation.)
https://cen.acs.org/articles/82/i27/TRAIN-DERAILS-CHLORINE-L....
If I run half as many twice as large trains I'd expect fewer total derailments even if these monster trains derail more often than the more normal trains of yesteryear.
As some other commenters have noted, it might be even more useful to get the total weight of derailed cargo, per (mass times distance), I suppose.
Rail safety seems a lot less complex and pretty much as regulated as aviation safety, how come there aren't just ~1-2 per year? Is it just because fatalities are luckily fewer (due to the nature of these derailments) so no one really gives a shit?
And then there's the human element. Nobody knows when they're going to work, how long it's going to take, what kind of bullshit they're going to run into. You can get stuck for long periods of time away from home terminal, and the Class 1 doesn't care. And there's things like rules on how to walk. The environment that's been constructed isn't meant for human consumption and it's taking a toll on the workforce. There's reams of other shit to whinge about.
And the derailments always matter, it's a total clusterfuck. They're not easy to fix, you've got to "bad order" and set out the car, at least by regulation. This involves rerailing, finding a set-out track, and making all the moves to get everything back in order. You've also got to wait for carmen (who are understaffed) and management, which depending on the route, could be a long sit. If it's bad enough it'll shut down traffic for a couple of days, requiring significant diversions around it while the Class 1 pays out the ass for a third party to come clean it all up and rerail shit.
None of the current infrastructure is built to deal with these train lengths, either, so everything moves slower. The fact the Surface Transportation Board had a hearing with the Class 1's, I think, is a pretty good indicator they're about as interested in moving goods as GE is in manufacturing.
^: Each coal car has two draw bars with +/- 2-3" about the same for shipping container cars (from eyeing it) of run built in. This varies with car, auto racks have way more run out. Opposing forces in the trainline will pull it apart, the more run to build the faster the opponent acceleration... This typically results in broken knuckles. But it is possible to just push cars off the rail with these forces, which is exacerbated by the doubled length.
> None of the current infrastructure is built to deal with these train lengths, either, so everything moves slower.
Is it due to extra freight demand caused by the recent surge in consumer demand?
Or this was long way in the making, but the system's capacity seems to have basically topped out? (And any effort to move even more freight on this network will cost a lot more and cause a lot more pain and very likely fatalities for the humans involved?)
What's the "solution"? Building more tracks? Running more but smaller trains? (But I guess the trains are already long to keep fuel costs down?)
https://youtu.be/Q0rk5tnrFqA?t=9300
I think their new-fangled methods are crippling their ability to service the surge. I think their reputation and their current working environment has cost them people. I think all this has exacerbated the problem. If you Google Surface Transportation Board you'll find several articles about C1s being implicated in kneecapping business.
The megatrains are pretty old hat, they were being discussed while I was still in, 2017 or 2018. Shortly thereafter they started piloting the program. The problem is they just can't be accommodated, period. 150 car trains are bad enough, 270 cars and 6 engines is way worse. Sidings, yards, and loading facilities aren't built for it.
https://dataportal.orr.gov.uk/media/1999/rail-safety-2020-20...
After all one of the communication problems in this pandemic was that even technical, medical professionals could not agree on the definition of “airborne” as it relates to the public’s best interest.
Put every train car in the country on one train and derail it. Now 100% of the capacity was derailed, but it's an incredible success, because the number of train derailments shrank from 1056 to 1!
So much safety!
still, awesome that you went to check the source.
According to the Bureau of Transportation Statistics, there were 1,056 train derailments (both cargo and passenger) in the US in 2021. This was the lowest number in the dataset going back to 1975.
Ten years ago, it was 1,470 derailments. In the year 2000, it was over 2,000 derailments.
In reality, the data suggest we are on a strong downward trend in derailments per year.
Is this government data wrong? Or is this writer trying out a career in fiction?
Data: https://www.bts.gov/content/train-fatalities-injuries-and-ac...