Are derailments cash-flow neutral? (Honest question. Could be, if the public foots clean-up and insurance the train and lost revenue.)
The solution here would seem to be penalizing derailments using a large fine that is proportional or progressive to weight or length.
If there was damage to private property, a hazmat spill contaminating private land, or injury or loss of life, the railroad is going to get sued.
Not all the externalities mentioned are specific to derailments, but also apply to the general difficulty of our infrastructure in supporting such long trains.
And a derailment sounds like a massive cost to a rail company. You need to clear the tracks (which can't be used until you do), probably pay higher insurance costs for the material you are transporting that is lost, etc, etc
Of course that is not the only stakeholder in the situation. Now for each key stakeholder, including railroad companies, railroad employees, shipping companies, the purchasing public, and landowners near tracks, what would be your professional opinion on the correct outcome?
It is pretty clear that what you see depends on where you sit.
Now step back even further and imagine you are an omniscient being that can truly comprehend all of the above perspectives. How would you go about deciding the correct outcome? It will depend on your notion of good and fairness. I think for many definitions of good, you'll find that considerable analysis is involved.
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Transportation_Safe...
There is no regulation that will prevent all derailments with 100% effectiveness.
Engineering rail systems so that derailments do not happen at all is a reasonable shorthand for almost never. It is engineering malpractice to run things so close to the edge that fatalities or serious property damage are to be expected next month instead of sometime in the next few decades or so.
> Longer trains are harder to stop, harder to control, less robust to disturbances.
All other things equal, this seems plausible, but I’m no expert on trains. So if I studied it, I would likely agree in most cases.
However, I do wonder if longer trains, being more massive, do offer some benefits in some cases. Perhaps a disturbance affecting only one car would have less effect because the other cars have more inertia and resist change.
This of course relates the question of the design criteria. Clearly trains should be designed with a cost benefit analysis such that more common disturbances can be handled. What kinds of disturbances can and should be planned for?
> As a mechanical engineer, my professional opinion is that trains should not be derailing, period.
I was also trained as an engineer. Part of that training is understanding probability and risk. There is going to be some risk of derailment. How do you go about deciding the acceptable risk of development? Have you done such a calculation before? What is it based on?
Hopefully you can see (in retrospect, at least) that this language is not going to build goodwill or help understanding.
Some people dismiss complexity theory without giving it a chance.
Even if this is only about maximum train length, which it isn't, the underlying dynamics, as they are perceived by and affect all the stakeholders, are complex.
This is what I mean by complex systems: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complex_system
Is this what you mean?
I mean, sure you can legally, but you’re still a harmful entity with a problem.
I can't see what's wrong with calling out people for unethical, shitty and harmful behaviour however.
Because they can offload most of the costs of the derailments as externalities while pocketing the money from larger trains.