News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An approximation to determine the source of the WOW! Signal by marcosdumay on Friday May 06, 2022 @10:13PM (#31291595)
The great filter is something with odds around 10^-30 of surviving.

It's hard to find any convincing argument that climate change will destroy our civilization with anything near 1/2 odds. It's a completely different ballpark.

Re:An approximation to determine the source of the WOW! Signal by asdff on Saturday May 07, 2022 @02:16AM (#31292547)
How can you even put odds on something like this?
Re:An approximation to determine the source of the WOW! Signal by ben_w on Saturday May 07, 2022 @04:26AM (#31292999)
I think it’s a definitional thing: “a great filter” assumes that life is basically everywhere and yet one specific something (or perhaps as many as “a few”) almost always prevents it from taking over a significant fraction of its future light cone.

If there are 10^30 stars in ours, the lower bound on the odds of surpassing it have to be close to that.

Personally I expect there to be many smaller filters rather than a few great filters — 30 things each with a factor of 10 has the same effect, after all.

Re:An approximation to determine the source of the WOW! Signal by marcosdumay on Saturday May 07, 2022 @12:15PM (#31295897)
Personally, abiogenesis by itself looks like something on the 10^-60 to 10^-140 range, so it fully explains everything.

Anyway, there are indeed a few things in our past that look like a 10^-10 odds filter, like each time our genetic encoding changed to increase our codons and the oxygen catastrophe. There are more that look like merely "almost impossible to survive" (I'd guess some ~10^-4 filter) like large asteroid impacts, but not nearly enough to make a difference.