News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by nineplay on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @11:59AM (#31262278)
My experience has been that some companies pressure engineers to want to advance. If you come into a performance review and say "actually I'm happy where I am" it's seen as a lack of motivation and will count as a mark against you. I had a boss say to me "I always want to move to the next level and I expect the same of my reports". Whatever, I guess I'm a poor employee because I like my job.
Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by toast0 on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @12:57PM (#31263025)
Some (many?) companies have an 'up or out' requirement where each position has a time limit to get promoted, unless it's a 'terminal position' which is ok to stay at.

When I was at Facebook, this was administered by using the next level review guidelines after you had a position for N months (depends on the position), and if you don't meet those expectations, putting you into the firing pipeline (PIP, etc). One of many reasons I was happier when I stopped having people reporting to me.

Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by zeroonetwothree on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @01:31PM (#31263443)
Only true for E3/4. After that you can stay forever. I know someone that’s been E5 for 12 years
Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by ShamelessC on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @02:50PM (#31264362)
I just want to say that I can't believe some of the smartest people in the world are willing to put up with all of this off-putting corporate bullshit. No disrespect.
Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by dougmwne on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @07:37PM (#31267307)
I would say that a high affinity for playing the games invented by others for the rewards invented by others is orthogonal to raw intelligence. In fact, smart people usually have a lifetime of being rewarded for exercising their intelligence on command. Where are they supposed to learn a healthy disrespect for authority when they have always been the darlings of authority?
Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by cmrdporcupine on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @10:47PM (#31268784)
And now you know why Google, etc. have a strong bias for hiring out of academia and out of the higher levels of education. (Not just because the founders never worked industry, just academia, when they started Google, but I digress...).

The interview process is highly highly biased towards recent grads (algorithm/data-structure courses) and the kind of people who do super well in university show-and-tell.

Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by effingwewt on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @03:03PM (#31264512)
I'd argue they are far from some of the smartest people in the world. Smart? Sure, some (many?) but I've known quite a few idiots in software. But I'd hardly compare the regular software engineer at a FAANG to some of the geniuses in the world.

But they put up with it because it's a career and not a job. Many of them couldn't handle a minimum wage or working class job. No breaks, short lunches, no wriggle room for life, permanent fast-tracks to firing.

Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by cmrdporcupine on Thursday May 05, 2022 @04:21PM (#31277969)
I dunno, I would say on my whole in my 10 years at Google I really did meet some of the most talented (in terms of raw knowledge or focus or some other skill) people ever in my career.

But they were mostly being paid handsomely to apply those amazing skills to really humdrum tasks -- but painting them up to be really profound -- and that's the saddest thing.

Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by sokoloff on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @12:29PM (#31262672)
I’ve openly stated that I want my retirement job to be an SWE3-ish role somewhere. High enough to have interesting, somewhat challenging work, but with negative desire to climb the ranks any further.
Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by ryandrake on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @12:46PM (#31262880)
Problem with that is due to inflation, you're making less and less compensation every year. Standard "you're doing a good job" raises often do not meet inflation, and certainly are not right now where inflation is higher than the recent historical mean. This is not a problem for some people, maybe including you, but I think most people have a general vague career expectation of making more when they're 60 than they make when they're 50, than they make when they're 40, and so on--even if they don't plan to be an overachieving "ladder climber".
Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by sokoloff on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @12:56PM (#31263010)
I may have been unclear. By retirement job, I meant a job that I took during (read: after) retirement, not the one I’d walk away from at the moment of retiring.

At that point, financial arrangements are presumably already all set.

Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by Firmwarrior on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @02:41PM (#31264246)
I agree, but this isn't as bad as you might think once you're a senior engineer at a top-end company. A lot of your compensation is in the form of stocks that will appreciate in value with inflation, so assuming you're in good graces with your director and VP, it's possible you'll fall behind the market rate very slowly
Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by throwaway_1928 on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @12:58PM (#31263035)
You can always move to the same level in a different company to readjust your pay.
Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by fshbbdssbbgdd on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @05:18PM (#31265994)
If you had a paid off house, and no kids to take care of, you should be able to live off a junior engineer’s salary no problem.
Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by daemin on Thursday May 05, 2022 @10:25AM (#31273762)
That reminds me of the guy getting a burger flipper job in the film American Beauty.
Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by kziojzwsndppqgg on Thursday May 05, 2022 @12:09AM (#31269344)
Can confirm, it’s a great choice. Step one, convince a FAANG/MAGMA to let you work remote at the same salary level you already have. Step two, move to an extremely cheap cost-of-living area. Step three, avoid promotion at all costs, and just fix bugs.

Provide value, but _never_ get promoted. Every year come review season, talk about how your goals for the next year are to improve latency/perf/whatever. It doesn’t have to be specific, just something that’s important enough to be useful, but don’t be ambitious. Just keep your head down and make enough improvements that people consider you to be a good “grunt” worker.

Yeah yeah, inflation sucks and technically I’m making less because my RSU’s have mostly vested and my yearly grants haven’t made up for it, but I don’t care. I’ve saved up enough that I could retire now if I really wanted to.

Every day for me, I work 9-5, fix a few bugs, provide some value, then work’s over and I get to play with my son and completely forget about my job. Then once he’s in bed I smoke some weed, watch shows with the wife, talk about the good old days. It’s heaven.

(By the way, I say all this, but I kinda failed at it because I got promoted last year anyway. I got hella worried because I thought they’d start expecting more out of me, so I actually slowed down my pace even more. I just got a mid-cycle bonus last month. Maybe I’m not so great at keeping my head down after all…)

Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by sokoloff on Thursday May 05, 2022 @06:33AM (#31271627)
The demand for “reliably and undramatically accomplishes needed tasks” far exceeds the supply.
Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by seanmcdirmid on Thursday May 05, 2022 @12:24AM (#31269454)
I hope I can down level myself after I go over 65 or 70 (depending on my health of course, hopefully I have that option). I think it is an option at some companies (older talent getting ready to retire but still have a lot to contribute).
Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by bluGill on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @12:46PM (#31262885)
i want to retire as an engineer. If I went management I'd be much more likely to get to this high paying jobs in the executive suite. What I don't want is to be doing the same thing again and again with no recognition of how useful I am. If I'm not useful, then I need to get into a different position.
Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by kmonsen on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @01:28PM (#31263413)
I have worked in three FAANG's and that was not true in any of those once you reach a certain level. This is somewhere between 4/5. The reason is that at that point the employee is considered mostly independent and can be expected to solve their task without too much intervention.
Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by iamevn on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @01:09PM (#31263169)
I've experienced managers pressuring me to either go for promo or find a different team.
Re:The Google incentive mismatch: Problems with promotion-or... by tomatowurst on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @05:15PM (#31265957)
You are being pressured to get higher salary for the same level of work you are currently doing and this is a problem? Strange.