News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dropbox: The Inside Story Of Tech's Hottest Startup by scott_s on Tuesday October 18, 2011 @01:51PM (#3126205)
A process can't change the address space of another process, period. Even if one is a root process. Separation of address spaces is a basic security service provided by the operating system. So I'm also puzzled how they are able to modify memory in Finder's address space.

The closest thing I can think of is that Finder executes arbitrary processes on behalf of the user. That is, when I double click on something, Finder has to do the fork-exec dance to launch that application. A process fork, however, creates an entirely separate address space for the new process. I would be shocked if Finder did not do that. So, yes, I'm also wondering what it is they do.

Re:Dropbox: The Inside Story Of Tech's Hottest Startup by tlrobinson on Tuesday October 18, 2011 @03:04PM (#3126592)
Not true, at least on OS X:

http://www.slideshare.net/rentzsch/dynamic-overriding

https://github.com/rentzsch/mach_star

I don't know if this is how Dropbox works, but it seems likely.

Re:Dropbox: The Inside Story Of Tech's Hottest Startup by scott_s on Tuesday October 18, 2011 @03:40PM (#3126775)
The first chunk of those slides talk about library hijacking. Say, you define your own version of malloc, make sure the application links to your version of malloc, and play your tricks from there. Process isolation has not been violated.

The last five slides seem to be doing this: http://www.blackhat.com/presentations/bh-usa-09/DAIZOVI/BHUS...

Slide 4 is the difference: OSX is BSD running on top of Mach. So these techniques use the Mach layer to get around basic process protection. This is terribly insecure.

Re:Dropbox: The Inside Story Of Tech's Hottest Startup by tlrobinson on Tuesday October 18, 2011 @03:57PM (#3126857)
Yeah, the injection stuff was what I was referring to.

Apple apparently changed OS X in 10.4.4 to only allow root or procmod group to do this http://guiheneuf.org/mach%20inject%20for%20intel.html

Re:Dropbox: The Inside Story Of Tech's Hottest Startup by ataranto on Tuesday October 18, 2011 @05:08PM (#3127199)
Dropbox does in fact use mach_star.
Re:Dropbox: The Inside Story Of Tech's Hottest Startup by bdonlan on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @05:10AM (#3129341)
> A process can't change the address space of another process, period. Even if one is a root process. Separation of address spaces is a basic security service provided by the operating system. So I'm also puzzled how they are able to modify memory in Finder's address space.

Sure you can. Every major PC OS (Windows, Mac, Linux) has a debugging API that, in fact, does allow you to read and write the memory of other processes. Windows even has a convenient function to allocate blocks of memory in other processes' address space, and another function to spawn a thread in another process with an arbitrary entry point - which makes this sort of thing relatively easy to do.

Mind you, the primitives provided can be a bit difficult to work with, but it's far from impossible.

Re:Dropbox: The Inside Story Of Tech's Hottest Startup by wmf on Tuesday October 18, 2011 @07:30PM (#3127791)
A process can't change the address space of another process, period.

Don't forget ptrace.

Re:Dropbox: The Inside Story Of Tech's Hottest Startup by scott_s on Tuesday October 18, 2011 @10:49PM (#3128377)
I had, but that's not the situation I had in mind. You can only use ptrace on a child process. You can't use ptrace to attach to, say, another user's process.
Re:Dropbox: The Inside Story Of Tech's Hottest Startup by mrb on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @03:58AM (#3129188)
You can attach to any of your processes, that's how debuggers work! Ever used gdb to attach to a running process and debug it on the fly? This is done with ptrace() with the PT_ATTACH flag.

Now ptrace is known to be severly limited on Mac OS X, but there are ways around it: http://uninformed.org/index.cgi?v=4&a=3&p=14

Re:Dropbox: The Inside Story Of Tech's Hottest Startup by wmf on Tuesday October 18, 2011 @11:06PM (#3128412)
See PT_ATTACH, and wouldn't both Finder and Dropbox be running as the user?
Re:Dropbox: The Inside Story Of Tech's Hottest Startup by lawnchair_larry on Tuesday October 18, 2011 @10:06PM (#3128263)
> A process can't change the address space of another process, period. Even if one is a root process. Separation of address spaces is a basic security service provided by the operating system.

That is not even close to true, on any operating system.

Re:Dropbox: The Inside Story Of Tech's Hottest Startup by simplekoala on Tuesday October 18, 2011 @02:21PM (#3126368)
Thanks for the clarification. I was thinking may be they were mucking with shared libraries. I found this useful link on digging further. Doesn't seem like too much of black art. http://www.culater.net/wiki/moin.cgi/CocoaReverseEngineering