To be clear, I'm actually quite bullish on AI (well, bullish on it ultimately happening, not necessarily on how it will impact humanity). I was mostly reacting to the timeline for photonic quantum computing rather than on ML advancement, actually.
Language modeling is extremely impressive. I've been saying since 2017 that modeling language is basically modeling the world/intelligence, but at the time most people did not seem to believe that. People still don't really seem to believe it, but I think the smarter among us are beginning to now that they see GPT-X & PaLM. I think there is still a substantial gap from "good language model" to "embodied agent taking actions in the world" that we have not bridged and will be potentially pretty hard to, more than mere "minutes."
This makes it sound like you’re arguing against something no one said — which makes it a weird thing to quote.
> The answer it gave me was surprisingly coherent wise and useful. From there (AGI) we could be minutes away from artificial super intelligence
What am I missing? I assumed of course that they didn't mean literal minutes but more metaphorically, but my reply was also using it in the metaphoric sense - it could be a potentially heavy lift to go from point A to point B.
e: I guess I am missing that they are conflating GPT with AGI and saying it will be minutes from AGI to artificial super intelligence in the literal sense. That, I actually do agree with, but I don't think GPT-X or PaLM or LMs in general qualify as such.
Upon reflection, my comment was too critical for having a different read than you did.
Microsoft QuArC has published a number of papers on QAI, and I both work on photonics and discuss with other companies who do the accelerators being developed. Accelerating AI with photonics is an active area of development.
I think you’re projecting that your knowledge of this is only based on pop-sci.
We are so far away from being able to do this with photonic quantum computers that I am really skeptical that you actively work in this field.
FWIW, I know quite a lot of people involved in AMO physics (which involves related techniques) and work in ML myself.
2025-2030 is way too soon for these things to come to fruition.
We’re not more than a single breakthrough from being able to make photonic accelerators — and there’s already worked out algorithms to accelerate ML once those circuits are available.
I’m confident in 2025-2030.
Such false bravado, not going to keep replying.
Yawn — you’re the one who came in with ad hominems and trying to tell other people what they work on, lol
I’m sorry your friends are ignorant and you don’t know what I do.